WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Sitting Bench Pics

Posts

Sitting Bench Pics

#1

Sitting Bench Pics

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>Here is some evidence that I am actually sometimes using my tools to make stuff. These benches go with a house I built cabinetry for. The one with just a flat top will set in the entry for taking off boots and shoes. The one with the wierd looking ends will set in between two dormers on the second floor. I made the ends the same height as a chair I had, and with a cushion on the seat and back it will make a very nice nest to set on and read a book in front of the window, sitting with your back towards the end. Definitely influenced by the craftsman style. The seats are 17" from the floor and roughly 17" deep. The flat top bench is 50" long, and the one with the funny ends is 48" long; the panels in the base are the same size, but the top overhang makes the short bench longer. The lids are hinged with non-mortice hinges and supported with lid supports to keep them from slamming. Red oak, finished with the mix of turpentine, blo, and poly, three coats and waxed. A lot of hand tool work here but all stock and joints were cut with power tools and simply fitted by hand. All the surfaces are simply hand planed smooth and not scraped or sanded. The rough grain of oak lends itself to this approach, but when you look at the tops in just the right light you can see the hand plane tracks where my iron corners were not quite right.




Re: Sitting Bench Pics

#2

Re: Sitting Bench Pics

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>Very nice benches, Moses. I've got a couple of similar post and frame pieces in progress. Well, in reality, both of them seem to have gotten to a certain point and then just started gathering dust in the shop.

I have a question/comment on your construction techniques. Why the extra stiles at the ends of each panel? I count eight superfluous stiles, sixteen mortises and sixteen tenons that do the same job as eight stopped grooves cut into the leg posts. I understand that stopped grooves are not as easy to cut as end to end grooves, and I completely understand that once you have set up the power tools for making rails and for chopping mortises, it's not too much extra time to make a few extras. It does make a lot of difference for someone doing all the joinery with hand tools, however, so I figured it was worth pointing this out to those here who are inspired by your work.

Did you also cut extra panel grooves in the outer edges of the end stiles, the edges that adjoin the leg posts? If I were making them that way, you can bet I would have.

Re: Sitting Bench Pics

#3

Re: Sitting Bench Pics

Wiley Horne--Glendora CA

>Moses,

They're handsome. I like the way you put a curve in the aprons, and the way the legs are tapered (double tapered, I think) at the bottom. Makes it all go together just right, and not overdone in any way. The one that will be in the reading area is especially inviting to sit on.

Wiley

Re: Sitting Bench Pics

#4

Nice

Ernie Miller

>I can see why you wouldn't want to get rid of them

Re: Sitting Bench Pics

#5

Nice work Moses!

Paul in NJ

>

Re: Sitting Bench Pics

#6

Re: Sitting Bench Pics

Alan Bierbaum

>Nice work! Since your panel frame is set back from the legs; I like the "extra" end stiles on the panels.

Re: Sitting Bench Pics

#7

Re: Sitting Bench Pics

ray k

>I really like the clean elegant lines. I always find that it's really difficult to make something look simple, yet beautiful. It looks like you struck that balance on these pieces. Very nice! Did you use through tenons? Are the wedged? I too like the double tapered legs--makes the legs look less bulky and more refined.

Re: Sitting Bench Pics

#8

well done

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>I like the clean design and honest execution. Good job!

Re: Sitting Bench Pics

#9

Re: extra stiles

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>I put stiles on the ends simply for the look; they add nothing to the actual structure. I thought it looked better to have the framed panel with legs added, instead of having the leg only. I debated a number of different ways to do this, and decided to butt the edge of the end stile against the leg, instead of letting it into the leg. The top and bottom rails front and back are through wedged mortice & tenon, so they are plenty strong without the stile in the leg, and the ends I think are plenty strong with just a large tenon into the leg. I did end up with very slight gaps there in two places due to not trimming the tenons just right. Design decisions; I think if I were to do it again, I would probably let the stile into the leg, as it would be a little easier to get a tight joint there I think.

Re: Sitting Bench Pics

#10

Re: extra stiles

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>The more I think about it, the more I like your idea. I like putting a quarter round molding detail on the inside edges of my rails and stiles, framing raised panels. However, executing that detail would pose additional problems if I wanted to put the molding directly on the leg posts.

Re: Sitting Bench Pics

#11

Very nice. Great details.

Victor Parisian

>

Re: Sitting Bench Pics

#12

Very nice Moses!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>They came out beautiful. Nice clean lines. I like the balance the extra stiles give it also. Great job, I think the client will be pleased...

Re: Sitting Bench Pics

#13

Great work! They look beautiful.

Jonathan Kaplan (OR)

>

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.