Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Hey Rob, a question on your straight edges

Posts

Hey Rob, a question on your straight edges

#1

Hey Rob, a question on your straight edges

Doug Littlejohn

>Caution - Stealth Gloat contained within.

SWMBO, bought me several neat goodies from LV for my birthday (the gloat part) which always brings happiness to my heart to see a LV box for me!!

One items was a 38" aluminum straight edge and is where my question is. The machined surface is wonderfully flat (like it is supposed to be) but along the wide axis, there is about a 1/8"-3/16" bow. Is this normal? I know it's not a reference in that axis but I thought it would be straighter than that. Is mine within the normal tolerance range or did I get a bum one??

Thanks for yor info and also for your company, I just love to get stuff from LV.

Doug

Re: Hey Rob, a question on your straight edges

#2

Re: Hey Rob, a question on your straight edges

paul womack

>but along the wide axis, there is about a 1/8"-3/16" bow.

Unless it's mondo stiff, I imagine that small bow will flatten out under gravity when you place the tool on a surface.

BugBear

Re: Hey Rob, a question on your straight edges

#3

Re: Hey Rob, a question on your straight edges

Rob Lee

>Hi Doug -

We don't make 'em that way, but sometimes things that length arrive a little different shape than they started out....

No worries - will have one sent today... (took me awhile to find the address though, the order's under your wife's name...)

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Hey Rob, a question on your straight edges

#4

Your reply begs a question...

Hoa Dinh in Alameda

>"We don't make 'em that way..."

So, how come they end up that way?

Actually the real question is how should one store them so they don't end up that way.

I'm considering a 50-incher (already have a 24). I think the long one is more prone to getting out of shape than its little brothers.

-- Hoa

Re: Hey Rob, a question on your straight edges

#5

Nope, it's 3/8" thick.

Doug Littlejohn

>I could straighten it pretty easy but I woudl concerned that I might introduce a slight change in the flatness on the reference side of it.

Sherwood

Re: Hey Rob, a question on your straight edges

#6

Re: Hey Rob, a question on your straight edges

Doug Littlejohn

>You guys are simply amazing. OF course, that's also why you're my number one place to shop for tool related things (at least WW).

Yeah, she gets me most of my stuff, heck, even just ordered me a firewood cart since my back is so bad.

Let me know what you want to do with the old one, I have saved the original box it came in (nice packaging by the way, it made sure that it would not get damaged in shipment.)

Like I said above, I would straighten it out, which would be pretty easy, but since it is supposed to be a reference, I was worried I would introduce a slight warp in the reference side.

Anyway, this long winded reply is meant to say thanks for a great place to do business with and please let me know hoe you want me to return the other one.

THANKS!!!

Sherwood

Re: Hey Rob, a question on your straight edges

#7

great question

Doug Littlejohn

>Rob, what do your engineers say is the best way to store these things. Since it is a refence, I don't want to mess things up down the road.

TIA,

Sherwood

Re: Hey Rob, a question on your straight edges

#8

Re: Your reply begs a question...

Rob Lee

>Hi Hoa (and John)...

Have gone through this with an engineer here - and they tell me that, while we have a tolerance on straightness for the extrusion, it's not a tight one.

Basically - we can hold the flatness tolerance on the machined edge, but the cross-section of the extrusion was designed for stability in one axis - not two. Being tall and thin (like a truss) - it will hold it flatness on the machined edge (vertically stable), but will vary from side to side.

We do accept/reject the cut extrusion based on a given tolerance (I don't have the number at this time) - but as we don't machine the sides, have to accept the variance that the extruder can hold. But, 1/8" to 3/16 on 38" is outside of what we pass....

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Hey Rob, a question on your straight edges

#9

Re: great question

Rob Lee

>Hi Doug -

The aluminum one is pretty tough - believe it or not - using the hang hole is the best way to store it..

What you really have to watch out for it hitting it, dropping it, or using it as a cutting guide (BTW - Stanley makes a really good aluminum rule one, available at most BORG's - well worth getting!). Just keep it where it won't get hit....

Cheers -

Rob

(PS - cust service has put a "call-tag" in with the replacement...that's the return shipping label (no charge to you))

Re: Hey Rob, a question on your straight edges

#10

Thanks Rob

Doug Littlejohn

>It is a great straight edge. ROck solid and really beefy. I'm glad to hear I can just hang it, that makes it the most practical. If it ever drops, you will hear me cry all the way up there. As an ex-engineer (electronic) I appreciate tolerances and reference tools.

Thanks again,

Sherwood

Re: Hey Rob, a question on your straight edges

#11

Re: Your reply begs a question...

paul womack

>Basically - we can hold the flatness tolerance on the machined edge, but the cross-section of the extrusion was designed for stability in one axis - not two. Being tall and thin (like a truss) - it will hold it flatness on the machined edge (vertically stable), but will vary from side to side.

Yes another example of LV careful thought; it's perfectly possible to make a "dream" straight edge, straight in every dimension. But it wouldn't do the actual job better and it would cost more.

Rob - keep on making things exactly as good as they need to be!

BugBear