Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Alternative for a no2 Stanley

Posts

Alternative for a no2 Stanley

#1

Alternative for a no2 Stanley

Jeff

>I love old planes and I like to use them too. (Bet some of you love to hear that!) I recently edged some boards with my plane(s) for joining. I learned a good bit about practical differnces (by trial and error) or using a N0. 4, No 5. and No 7. I was really surprised at the difference the lenght of the sole made! I found the No 4 a bit to long and I started using my block plane on the rough wood then went to the #4.

So I am looking for a No. 3 on Ebay (may have found one .... nope just checked, went to high for me). So I am still looking for a no 3. :-)

Anyway my question is how useful is a No. 2? I know they are very pricey. But the short lenght looks like it would be very useful. I use my low angle block plane all the time. Can't imagine not having one. And I am thinking that a No. 2 would be just as useful becaue of it's short length. What say ye?

And, does anyone have a suggestion of a good one other than the collectible Stanleys? Any of the Sargents or some other brand out there that made a good No. 2? I don't care about the brand, I just want something that is made well and works well. And doesn't cost and arm and leg!

Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley

#2

Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley

Dennis

>Why not take your time going down the slope and look around a bit. Ever think about the smaller woodies?

The last 3 i picked up here was a type 8 or 9 in a bucket with a VBM 10,missing the tote and knob and along with couple other boat anchors......o yea cost me $3 for all 4. Note: and south Florida is not known as great place to find tools.

The 2 size is ok for small things, i use mine for that and the sargent, MF's in that size are not that much cheaper. Look for the 5 or 6inch woodies, lot better buy and work great.

Dennis,who is no hurry to pay big bucks for tool he may or may not use

Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley

#3

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>I don't see much need for the #2 sized plane. The tote is much smaller, and makes it awkward to use, since most folks can only get, at most, three fingers on it. A regular (high) angle block plane pretty much works quite well whenever a plane shorter than a #3 is needed.

If you've really gotta have one, the Sargent #407 is the same size, and IMO, a better plane anyway. Pricing on Ebay, etc. will probably be a little (but not much) less than the Stanley #2.


Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley

#4

Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>Why not a Lee Valley low angle adjustable mouth block plane, with the optional wooden front knob and squirrel tail? A lot more versatile, works better, more durable, less finicky, comes with a full money back guarantee, etc., etc., and so forth. With the old Stanley, OTOH, the most you might get is the old "Oklahoma Gaurantee."

Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley

#5

Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>The alternative I use is a LN 60 1/2 or old Stanley #9 1/2 with a second blade bedded at around 70 degrees to remove localized tearout. Same plane could have a plane with the blade set to 45 degrees if you choose.

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley

#6

Oklahoma Guarantee

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Is this like a taillight warranty - I warranty the car runs until I can see the taillights?

Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley

#7

Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I've never used a No. 2, although a fellow Centralian/Ellis Islander has allowed me to hold one (thanks, Matt Curley!). I'm inclined to agree with the others who have posted that a block plane is what you need. Used possibilities include any of the dozens of Stanley block plane types, with my favorite being the No. 65 - slightly longer than others, which fits my hands well, and with the delightful knuckle joint cap iron. New - well, there's the Lie-Nielsen, the Lee Valley, standard angle, low angle, apron, and so on.

While this is wandering off topic, I'm also a fan of the No. 203 Stanley or its equivalents (Millers Falls No. 45 - though interestingly, since M-F has a reputation for making better planes, the mouth is much larger on the M-F than on the Stanley) - the iron on this is bedded at about 23-24 degrees, so it's a high angle block plane. Shorter than the average block plane, and just generally little and handy. With a sharp iron, it's a sweet little trimmer tool (yes, I know that seems to contradict my earlier praise for the No. 65 for its larger size; but I'm a hand tool guy, I can't be expected to be rational).


Patrick Leace on the No. 203

Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley

#8

Re: Oklahoma Guarantee

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>Much better than that:

If it breaks in two, you get both pieces.

Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley

#9

I'm looking for...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond,CA

>Something like you�re asking about. I have a SW Stanley 2C. It's hard to hold like Bill says (listen to him, he's a wise man) to a point. It's also fun... for me mostly... It only hurts after a long session of planning. I mean long but, I have medium sized hands. I love the size of its footprint. It's great for small boards.

I�d love to get my paws on a small coffin shaped infill smoother �Well maybe someday�

How I hold my No. 2...You wrap both your hands around it like a calzone�Ahhhh...pizza... Whooo...kind of like a block plane.

It's easy (for me) to get thru a small smoothing task with one. I'd love to see a small smoother, coffin shaped with adjusters too (yea all three)...Scott wishing for a truly ripping small smoother that most could get their hands around.

Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley

#10

Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley

paul womack

>Sounds like yer' thinkin' a #2 would do what your #60 1/2 does.

If that's the case, what's the point? It's more beneficial to get a plane that covers a task your existing planes don't.

BugBear

Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley

#11

Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley

Todd Hughes

>Heres four that I have,a stanley, a sargent, a Union corrugated, and another sargent VBM that is corrugated . I sort of fell into accumalating these things, actually have two more out in the shop. Think they are kind of neat.Never really used one for anything other then just taking it for a spin around the block.To me they seem pretty comfortable to hold. Have included an older no. 15 1/2 with the rear knob so you can see the size of the two together. I sort of think the rear knob is kind of gimmicky and feel the no.2 is easier to hold though again I haven't used either much

After all this I really don't know what you could do with a no. 2 that you probably couldn't do with a block plane or on the big side a no. 3. Probably why they are not real common. They are kind of neat though and I enjoyed looking for different types of them.....Todd , who once bought two excellent no.2s for $10 the pair!


img

Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley

#12

Edging for joining?

Don Thompson - Cutler Ridge, Florida

> I recently edged some boards with my plane(s) for joining. I learned a good bit about practical differnces (by trial and error) or using a N0. 4, No 5. and No 7. I was really surprised at the difference the lenght of the sole made! I found the No 4 a bit to long and I started using my block plane on the rough wood then went to the #4.


When you refer to edging for joining, do you mean "jointing"? If so, are you stating that you find a #4 plane too long for jointing?

Or, (as is not uncommon) am I mis-reading the message here?

Don

Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley

#13

Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley

Jeff

>I am not opposed to a woodie at all. I just an mot farmiliar with the proper way to set the blade on them. I am open to to most anything. I have just stayed clear of them because of my lack of knowledge.

Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley

#14

Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley

Jeff

>I wouldn't mind having one but to answer your question, price!

Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley

#15

Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley

Jeff

>You may be exactly right. I may have just what I need. :-) Thats why I am asking!

Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley

#16

Re: Edging for joining?

Jeff

>I am using the wrong terms I am sure. What I was doing is preping the edges of some Maple to glue them to together edge to edge. So I guss the proper term is Jointing.

What I was tring to say was I found that my block plane (#9 1/2) was much better to start with. Then I moved to the #4 and #5 and #7 planes.

Well I really didn't use my #7 much. I bought it cheap and it still needs cleaning and tuning. BTW I could use a tote for this plane is someeone has one. This is a plan I plan to use, not look at.

Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley

#17

Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley

Dan Donaldson

>I takes a bit of practice, but is actually quite easy, assuming that the plane is in good shape. In some ways it is easier to make fine adjustments on them than a metal bodied plane with adjusters. I have a C & W small smoother and it is very easy to adjust.

Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley

#18

What length boards are you gluing up?

Don Thompson - Cutler Ridge, Florida

>

Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley

#19

Re: What length boards are you gluing up?

Jeff

>I did some 9 and 10 foot maple. Then some 3.5 foot cypress and have some more 3 foot maple to do now.

Re: Alternative for a no2 Stanley

#20

Jointing boards with a Stanley #2?

Don Thompson - Cutler Ridge, Florida

>Unless I am totally misunderstanding your messages, you are looking for a Stanley #2 - type plane to use for jointing boards three feet in length, correct?

I believe that most plane users find that a longer plane makes for a better joint. The exceptions would be for very short boards (don't want a plane twice as long as the board), and if a plane is too big and heavy for the user.

Of course, real experts can do great work with just about anything, but I think that you might want to consider something a bit longer.