Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Right or left hand skew block

Posts

Right or left hand skew block

#1

Right or left hand skew block

Bill H - Austin, TX

>I posted a little while back about getting a plane to trim tennons to fit and many people suggested the lie-nielson skew block plane. As for picking left or right hand plane, do I just pick a right handed plane if I'm right handed and vice versa for left. I know this is probably a dumb question, but I don't spend all that money on a plane and find out that I got the wrong handed plane.

Thanks in advance,

Bill

Re: Right or left hand skew block

#2

Re: Right or left hand skew block

David Miller from Iowa

>I have the "orignal" one which I guess is right handed (the skew slants to the lower left when holding it in the business position). I'm right handed and it works... handily. I suppose it is preference. Imagine yourself raising a panel - if you want to work at the far end (or right side) and put your left hand on the workpiece, then get the right handed one. If you want to fasten the panel down with a bench dog and work on the near end (or left side) then the left handed one is better.

At the risk of a hijack, I got mine when they first came out and it doesn't have the nicker or the fence - will they retrofit, or should I just get another and put mine in the vault as a rare "Type 1"?

David

Re: Right or left hand skew block

#3

Re: Right or left hand skew block

Clay Home

>Do think about how you work ... if trimming tenon cheeks is the intended use, you ought to consider getting the LH skew if you are RH, and vice versa.

Think of it this way - with the plane in your hand, pushing it directly away from you forward, the LH skews from NW to SE, the RH skews from NE to SW.

Trimming tenons, I like to have the stock in front of me, with the tenon 'pointing' to the right. With the LH skew, trimming that tenon cheek on top, the angle of the skew will 'pull' the plane tight into the shoulder - just what I want. With the RH skew, I'd have to either have the tenon pointing left, or pull the plane toward me rather than push, to get the same benefit.

Search the archives for 140, you'll find this explained much better than I can do ... and discussed at great length.

Also, the obvious and ideal answer is ... get both!

Enjoy,

Clay

Re: Right or left hand skew block

#4

Re: Right or left hand skew block

Rob Cosman

>Hi Bill, it would be better described as "Right Skew", "left Skew". The skew is more applicable to grain direction than right or left hand orientation. If you only get one you will adapt regardless. We only started making the left skew a short while ago and I believe Stanley never did. Ignoring grain direction and I can work with either. You should take a look at the new iron version, it comes with a knicker for the same price as the bronze without the knicker, right skew only for now.

Rob

Re: Right or left hand skew block

#5

Re: Right or left hand skew block

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

>Hi Bill,

I just went through this same thought exercise and bought the "left handed" version. I am right handed. What the others said about how you work is spot on. I like to approach the piece with the tenon pointing to the right so I can apply pressure down and slightly to the left with my right hand. Mine has not arrived yet, but I am really looking forward to it coming!

Good luck,

Mike

Re: Right or left hand skew block

#6

Re: Right or left hand skew block

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

>Hi Rob,

I'm just curious, where can I get information about the iron one? I looked at the LN site and don't see it mentioned. As I mentioned to Bill, I just bought one of these, and while I would still have preferred bronze, I didn't even know LN made an iron one.

Thanks,

Mike

Re: Right or left hand skew block

#7

Re: Right or left hand skew block

Don Thompson - Cutler Ridge, Florida

>I have the original (RH) LN 140. If you are right-handed, and choose to put your left hand on the board, and trim the cheeks of a tenon with the plane in your right hand, then the removable plate which is on the right side of the plane is on the wrong side for snugging up to the shoulder.

Recommendation: If you are right-handed, get the LH plane.

Re: Right or left hand skew block

#8

Re: Right or left hand skew block

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I've got the 140 RH without nicker, but often have problems with spelch (blowing out the tenon) as the 140 catches fibers. I've come within a button click of ordering the LH version about 100 times during the last year, then rethink, don't really want to have to change planes constantly on one tenon, return to using the 073. So, I think seriously about getting the rebate block plane.

Also, often I've got the tenon end facing me rather than a face/edge, like to use the 073 in both directions toward the middle.

I don't know what grain has to do with this in planing tenon faces.

Pam

Re: Right or left hand skew block

#9

Re: Right or left hand skew block

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

>Hi Pam,

I'm just curious, but are you using the 073 on the cheeks of the tenon and the shoulders? I've got the 073 but find I have a hard time balancing it on everything but really large tenon cheeks. I don't have that much of a problem with the shoulders. My cheek problems are what led me to the 140. In fact, I was all set to get the rabbet block until doing a little research on this board and that turned me on to the skew.

Thanks,

Mike

Spend most of my time over on the turning side from Apex, NC...

Re: Right or left hand skew block

#10

Re: Right or left hand skew block

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Yes, 073 for both cheeks and shoulders, but, like you, I don't have many shoulder problems. With practice I'm having fewer cheek problems as well.

I got the 140 RH a couple or three years ago as a flexible, general purpose block plane, the only block I've got. Then I ran into the spelch problem on tenon cheeks, which I could handle with the 140 except for the part right next to the shoulder. This part I handled with either chisels or the 073. So then the question was whether to spend a pile for better handling of this small section. So far, I haven't been able to commit those dollars because I haven't seen an ideal solution.

That rebate block plane looks like an ideal solution, but some here have said not.

Pam

Re: Right or left hand skew block

#11

Re: Right or left hand skew block

Dean J in MN

>Pam --

I have the 60 1/2 Rabbet... I'd be happy to answer any questions, or try to mimic your use and let you know what the results are....

-Dean

Re: Right or left hand skew block

#12

Re: Right or left hand skew block

Ted Shuck, Centennial, CO

>Pam,

I have the LN rabbet block plane and use it on tenon cheeks. It's primary benefit is that it works both sides the same. It's only problem is that the blade has to be square to work both sides the same, so it does not work as well on crossgrain tenons as a skewed blade. I sometimes get some grain rolling, but if I keep it *really* sharp, this is minimized. I figure that the surface I am getting on the tenons is "acceptable". It's definitely as good as or better than the inside surface of the mortise! It is my preferred plane because it is so convenient to be able to use it both ways.

Ted

Re: Right or left hand skew block

#13

Re: Right or left hand skew block

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Thanks, Dean. Someone mentioned that the 60-1/2 was so short that their knuckles were always getting skinned on the shoulder. But it doesn't look all that much shorter than the 140, if at all.

And how do you like the metal knob? I love the wooden one on the 140, the shape, too. I can stand at the tenon's end and plane left and right easily.

Pam

Re: Right or left hand skew block

#14

Re: Right or left hand skew block

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Yes, the skewed part is one of the best things about the 140. I take it it's not sufficient to skew the whole plane?

Thanks,

Pam

Re: Right or left hand skew block

#15

Re: Right or left hand skew block

Tony Zaffuto

>I have to agree with Pam on the need to commit dollars to a 140. I started reading the thread early yesterday, before I had to trim the "cheeks" on four tenons, so I was sensitive to watch how my job progressed. I first cut the cheeks with a rip backsaw, then trimmed to fit using my trusty old Stanley low angle block plane, with a minor bit of tweaking close to the shoulder with paring chisel.

Yes it would be nice to have a new tool to do the job. But practically speaking, it didn't take me more than 45 minutes to fit all four tenons. As I don't make a living at the trade, but only do it as a hobby, money-wise, it's very hard to spend $185.00+ (in spite of being very able to spend the money) to shave a few minutes off of a job I do for enjoyment. Quality wise, I really doubt another plane would affect the outcome of the job--only experience with any tool will do that.

I believe it was Pam that hit the nail on the head when she said we can all learn how to do the job with what we got.

Re: Right or left hand skew block

#16

Re: Right or left hand skew block

Randy Robertson

>Gloat...Just bought a 140LH yesterday at the Atlanta woodworking show, in fact I got the last LH they had at the show. Just tried it out this morning on 4 four tenons that I was needing to trim and love it already. I found several of the thing other said to be true, but would do it again. If I could afford it I'd buy an RH today. Good luck!

Re: Right or left hand skew block

#17

Re: Right or left hand skew block

Ted Shuck

>You could skew the plane, and I think you should get the same benefit of the skewed iron. Problem is that you won't get much benefit from the rabbet feature if the plane is skewed. May as well skew any old block plane.

Ted

Re: Right or left hand skew block

#18

Sure you would, on all but a small section.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: Right or left hand skew block

#19

Re: Right or left hand skew block

Dean J in MN

>

Thanks, Dean. Someone mentioned that the 60-1/2 was so short that their knuckles were always getting skinned on the shoulder. But it doesn't look all that much shorter than the 140, if at all.


It is just about the same size as 60-1/2 I have. I hold the plane with my right hand over the back of the plane and my left on the knob, and I have not had any unplesent run ins with the shoulder.



And how do you like the metal knob? I love the wooden one on the 140, the shape, too. I can stand at the tenon's end and plane left and right easily.


Mmm, having not used a 140 I can't say if I would like the larger knob... But as you describe it, it seems nice. Perhaps you can get LN to swap out the front knob for you?

Dean

Re: Right or left hand skew block

#20

Re: Right or left hand skew block

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Perhaps you can get LN to swap out the front knob for you?

Great idea, Dean, I'll ask.

Thanks,

Pam

Re: Right or left hand skew block

#21

Re: Right or left hand skew block

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>I also like the wooden knob on my L-N 140. In fact, I liked it so much, I ordered the optional wooden knob for the Lee Valley low angle block plane I just got. That one works very well, too, and doesn't seem to get in the way at all.

It seems that it should be fairly simple to make and adapt a custom wooden knob to just about any adjustable mouth block plane, unless it is an old Stanley with an obsolete thread size. Same concept as a custom tool handle, using a cut off bolt as the "tool".