Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

How to make a Norris type plane

Posts

How to make a Norris type plane

#1

How to make a Norris type plane

ray k

>I know its absolutely crazy for me to even consider doing this, but I'm still in the early stages of research so here goes.

I've just enrolled in a machine shop course and need to come up with a project to complete. After browsing through different tool catalogs, I've decided to machine a couple simple tools like a steel straightedge, dovetail markers, among others. Then I was re-reading the handplane book by garrett hack and was toying wiht the idea of making one of these. When I got my L-N planes, that was a world better than my un-tuned record #4. I'm wondering are norris type planes that much better than LN planes? I never even paid much attention to norris type planes because one look at their price tag and I started flipping through to the power tool section. But now I'm reading up on various kits and they seem to be a lot of work and not that cheap (I know they're cheaper than completed planes, but at $300 bucks a pop, I can't afford to assemble them incorrectly and that's out of my budget). I'm really intimidated by what looks like a really, really difficult project. But it would just be incredibly rewarding if i could make of one these. With the help of my machine shop class, equipment, instructor, would making these be way too out of my league?

Can anyone suggest a good book, video, plans that will give more insight on how to make one of these tools?

TIA

Re: How to make a Norris type plane

#2

Re: How to make a Norris type plane

Sean Evoy

>Ray,

I noticed that the most recent edition of ShopNotes has a description of how to build a brass infill using a box joint to join the sides and sole, as opposed to dovetailed. You could probably get a good sense from that article of the complexity involved.

Re: How to make a Norris type plane

#3

Re: How to make a Norris type plane

R.J.Whelan

>Ray ... I am not a metal worker by even the most generous definition, so take the following with a large pinch of salt.

I have never been in a financial position to purchase a Norris or Spears plane, but I was able to try one out several years ago and I was blown away by how nicely it worked. I think the real advantage offered by these planes is the wooden bed upon which the iron rests; the wood seems (to me) to completely dampen vibration in even a relatively thin iron.

I had an old #4 body missing almost everything and decided to try my hand at building an infill. I took the body to a machinist friend and had him mill everything from the throat back flat and square. I then built an infill out of Padauk and carefully positioned it for a very tight throat opening and epoxied it into place and followed up by pinning it in place with some 3/16" brass rod. I installed a threaded insert into the infill and used a Stanley lever cap to hold the iron. I didn't have the talent to make an adjuster so I just used the same method one uses to adjust the iron in a woody. I used a standard type of front knob since I didn't think the front infill added anything of great importance (I may well be wrong on this).

The plane worked really well - far better than any of the Bailey types I owned at the time. I ended up giving the plane away so I was never able to compare it to a L-N but my gut feeling is it worked at least a little better.

As long as you're taking the class I think this project is well worth the effort and expense.

Good luck - I'd love to see and hear about the results if you decide to go ahead with it .... rj

Re: How to make a Norris type plane

#4

Re: How to make a Norris type plane

Doug Evans

>Hi Ray:

Doug Evans here at Shepherd. I am amazed that nobody has mentioned Jim Kingshot's book ('92, Guild of Master Craftsman Pub's. - generally hard to find) here which has plans, etc. As well, there is a description in the back of one of the old reprint books written by Bob Baker (Ken Roberts?). As well, the July/August 1999 Home Shop Machinist has an article by Stephen M. Thomas. There was a guy from Australia who had an infill project going on a couple of years back on Daryll Hutchison's site until it shut down - might be some stuff here in the Badger Pond archives. I would guess that it might be cheaper to buy one of Ray Iles adjusters rather than to make one from scratch RH/LH tap & dies might set you back. I would hazard that as an amateur, you will take at least ten hours on the adjuster.

You may be able to get some pointers from Rolf here, as well.

Cheers,

Doug

Re: How to make a Norris type plane

#5

Re: How to make a Norris type plane *LINK*

Wiley Horne--Glendora CA

>Ray,

Attached is Jim Yehle's web page on making an infill (see below). Some great drawings in there.

I believe that the question of infill versus LN versus LV versus vintage Stanley/Record versus Japanese versus C&W, etc etc, is best tackled after one gets really good at sharpening. And I'll share a little anecdote. There is a Japanese tool user of long-standing--a professional cabinet maker and timber framer--who has published articles in journals on sharpening, and who is credited with his peers at being in the highest ranks of sharpening skill. He made a post on the Hiraide (Japanese) forum a few months ago, saying that he had rethought everything, and was starting afresh to relearn what he thought he knew about sharpening.

So it's not like you learn to sharpen, and that's it. It's a continuing process, even for the very skilled. My experience is that gaining skill in sharpening is like peeling layers off an onion--there's always another layer. That said, I think you should go for it on the infill--tremendous challenge, but the rewards could be great.

Wiley


Jim Yehle on Making Infills

Re: How to make a Norris type plane

#6

I`m guessing that

Bob Hackett

>The "Australian guy"from BP would have been Mick Doherty.The name may help to narrow the search.

MB

Re: How to make a Norris type plane

#7

So When you read the BOM...

Doug Evans

>it's still a "wack" of $ (assuming you dont have to build any fixtures, etc. and have a 3-Axis CNC milling machine at your disposal and the required programming skills). On a more practical note, didnt Todd Hughes build something on a lower budget a few months ago?

BTW, there is a bit of a mislead here at the beginning. If for some reason you make mistakes dovetailing a Shepherd - new steel ships out GRATIS. I am pretty sure others would do the same.

Cheers,

Doug

Re: How to make a Norris type plane

#8

Right You Are...

Doug Evans

>He built a number of planes.

Doug

Re: How to make a Norris type plane

#9

I actually think that RJ has

Wiley Horne--Glendora CA

>the best idea for a class project, and Ray could do a great job using RJ's concept.

I mentioned Jim Yehle's site because of the detailed downloadable drawings of classic planes that can be used as cutting templates. Plus Jerry Schueller's nitty gritty on how to actually make the shell.

Wiley

Re: How to make a Norris type plane

#10

All Good Points...

Doug Evans

>For what it's worth, I would recommend avoiding the adjuster.

Using a Stanley as a basis makes the bed angle in the sole easier too.

D

Re: How to make a Norris type plane

#11

Re: How to make a Norris type plane

ray k

>Boy, it never ceases to amaze me how great it is to have this messageboard as a resource. I've tried to follow up on everyone's suggestions. I ran out and picked out a copy of shopnotes. Their version seems simple enough--I don't think i'll follow their plans, but it did really help make this project not seem like I'm trying to swim across the pacific in an hour.

I also checked out Jim Yehle's website and the photos were detailed (I think that's the understatment of the year for me so far). Geez, Jim is on another planet--I'm not even 1/100th as detailed of a guy as compared to Jim by the looks of his instructions. In fact, I checked out his plans first and I nearly just shut down this possible project in my mind immediately.

Now, I just need to combine the best of both of these "plans"--1) I don't want to be too overwhelmed by the details and just want to give up before I even try it and 2) If I'm gonna learn something in my 5 wk intro machine shop class, I at least want this infill to be a little bit more complex than the version in shopnotes.

AS for Jim Kingshott's Making and Maintaining Hand Tools, it is pretty tough to find a copy. The only ones I could find were some used ones for about $80! I couldn't believe they were that expensive.

Dave, your kits are looking pretty attractive given how tough this project appears to be. However, I have this aching feeling that I'll regret not even trying my hand at making one.

Jim Yehle's bill of materials had what looked like an estimate of the costs for each of his parts seemed to add rather quickly. Anyone have a ball park estimate for how much this would cost in materials on average. I really doubt my first one will be all that great, so I don't want to use expensive materials.

I'm still pretty intimidated just by the thought of making one of these, but just the idea of entering the fellowship of woodworkers that have completed making one of these planes is pretty darn motivation.

Thanks again.

Re: How to make a Norris type plane

#12

Rough Casting Kit

Don Thompson - Cutler Ridge, Florida

>St. James Bay Sells rough, unfinished castings for various sorts of planes, that would be suitable for working on in a machine shop class.

There are more for sale than are illustrated on the web site. Bob, the owner, is not an HTML sort of guy, but is very helpful over the telephone.

I was going to get a thumb plane kit from him once, but he discouraged me from doing it without access to metalworking machinery. This would not be a problem for you, of course. (BTW, other kits do not require machinery).

If you buy from him, make sure both of you are clear on any time constraints or schedules.

Re: How to make a Norris type plane

#13

And,

WoodburnBob

>Apparently you can still get from St. James (per the "videos" page) the superb 3 issue Home Machinist set in which Stephen Thomas illustrates in great detail the construction and assembly of an infill from one of these castings. $5 an issue. I bought them a few years ago just for the reading. Excellent. I suppose they may be out of print and sold out by now.

Re: How to make a Norris type plane

#14

Steve Kubien

and THANK YOU!

Steve Kubien

>for the link to Jim's site. I don't think I had seen that before. There's some good stuff in dat der internet thingy!

Steve Kubien

Re: How to make a Norris type plane

#15

Confession

Wiley Horne--Glendora CA

>Got it off one of Bugbear's old posts. He wasn't around to do the honors himself.

Wiley

Re: How to make a Norris type plane

#16

My attempt ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>RJ

I made one like this a few years ago and posted the story on Badger Pond. The "Stanley infill" was built on a #4 body and used Jarrah for infill. The blade is a standard LN with an old Mathieson chipbreaker and a homemade brass levercap. It is held together with epoxy and brass screws. The mouth is very, very tight and the cutting angle is 55 degrees. Because of the latter it is more difficult to compare to a standard LN #4. The closest plane to the LN that I own is a #604 with LN blade and chipbreaker set. The #604 is a great plane but does not hold a candle to the infill on really gnarley timber. Still, I only use it as a finishing smoother on such timber since it takes such fine shavings that it is a slow process. It was a fun project at the time. I would like to build a traditional infill now (when time permits!).

Not the best picture - taken back then pre-digital camera using my photocopier.

Regards from Perth

Derek


img