Re: Veritas� Bullnose Shoulder Plane Impressions
William Duffield, on the Cohansey
>I haven't had a lot of opportunities to use it, but I quickly polished the back of the blade around the edges and sharpened the bevel, (only took a couple minutes) and we put it to work, cleaning up the corners of the rabbets on a couple of doors to install some flat panels. It worked a lot better than the bench chisels the apprentice would normally have used for that task. Then I took it out to a job site where I had to fit some pieces of a mahogany bar top together. I had a paring chisel with me that could have done the job, but the bullnose plane made it a lot quicker to get a good fit into some inside corners.
As expected, it is a well-made tool. I found the four cap screws and the Norris style lateral adjuster to work well, but not at the same time, of course. A sort of belt-and-suspenders solution to a not very serious problem, but that's because I've gotten used to using shoulder planes that don't have any lateral adjustment at all, including the L-N 073, Stanley #93 and the green monster. Most everyone will appreciate how well they work. Of course, if you tighten up all four set screws, there's no room for the very well machined lateral adjuster mechanism to work. If you have to do any amount of lateral tweaking while you're working, just back off the back two screws.
In use, it balances very well, with the tip of the thumb in one porthole, and either the index finger in the other port hole, or the index finger in the detent on top of the nose and the middle finger in the other porthole.
I have often questioned the utility of a chisel plane, or at least tried to dampen neophytes' desires to rush out and buy one. Now I guess I'm going to change my tune a little. I still think a regular shoulder plane should be put in your toolbox before a bullnose plane, and a dedicated chisel plane is superfluous, because skillful chisel work will get you by for either function.The chisel plane feature on this bullnose plane works so well, that I find it is worthwhile having. If you are considering getting a chisel plane, by all means, get this one instead. Taking the nose off, converting this one into chisel plane mode takes about three seconds, and a lot easier than setting it down and picking up a chisel. Putting the toe back in place takes only anouther four seconds. Also, it doesn't change your working grip on the plane. It does not change the comfort of the plane in your hand!!! The only difference is that the balance moves back from the T-bird portholes so that you need to lift the stern a little with your pinky finger under the adjuster as you set the plane back down. I like the way the mouth adjuster screw works. It makes it almost impossible to ding the edge when reinstalling the nose. Unlike most other shoulder planes, you can also easily remove the nose to remove and reinstall the blade for sharpening, again without the risk of dinging it up while maneuvering it through the top and back of the casting.
I haven't used it in chisel mode yet for trimming dowel plugs. That might be another compelling reason to own one. I'll get back to you when I've had a chance to try it out.
As far as fit and finish, it is very comfortable to hold, without any sharp corners anywhere you might need to get a grip on it, except where there are supposed to be sharp edges, of course. The bottom is sufficiently flat, the toe is coplanar with the sole, and the sides are perpendicular to the sides. At least they are close enough that any possible discrepency is thinner than a glue line. I am not going to waste time to get out feeler gauges to make any meaningless measurements.
One minor problem that I'll eventually get around to doing a little fettling on: There's seems like there's a little too much paint, or maybe rough casting under the paint, inside the body, or maybe on the lever cap, where one engages and pivots on the other. This causes a bit of a mushy feeling when installing, adjusting, and tightening the lever cap down onto the blade, so I have to double check to be sure I have it in the right place, and have the right amount of pressure on the blade. This contrasts markedly with the very positive engagement of the L-N 073, in which a steel through pin engages in a pair of machined slots in the side of the body. This is a very minor point, and I'll get used to it or will easily fix it with a small diamond burr on my Dremel. It does not cause any detectable problems with the stability of the blade while cutting.
Again, Lee-Valley has done an excellent job at a reasonable price. For $129 U.S., you get the best bullnose shoulder plane and the most comfortable, convenient small chisel plane available. Of course, it also has the advantages of the A2 steel blade and the ductile iron body.
Note that the Lie-Nielsen small chisel plane also has a virtually unbreakable body, and a wider and thicker A2 blade, but it doesn't do shoulders.
If you need specs, you can find them on Lee-Valley's website.
Do I think it is a worthwhile investment? Am I happy I bought it? Will I use it? Yes, most definitely.
Am I ready to retire any other of my user tools, because this one will completely take their places? Only one :^)