Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Abrasive wood ...

Posts

Abrasive wood ...

#1

Abrasive wood ...

Stephen in Ottawa

>... is there such a thing??

I had a strange experience planing some hard maple with my LN 5 1/2 some days ago. The board was about 4' long and about 6" wide. I started with a freshly sharpened blade and got some good shavings initially, but then the performance degraded very rapidly. When I checked the blade I found a definite burr on the cutting edge, something I'd never experienced before. I re-honed the blade and repeated the process, and got the same results. I subsequently dressed and planed another hard maple board and did not get this problem. The plane performed very well ( as it always had before ), so the issue seems to be in the wood. I cannot see any embedded metal in the wood or anything that could cause my blade to dull so quickly.

Has anyone experienced this before? I'm quite curious as to what is causing it.

Thanks.

- Stephen

Re: Abrasive wood ...

#2

Re: Abrasive wood ...

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>There are species of wood that have a high silica content, and are thus abrasive. Maple, however, is not one of them.

There are other ways to get abrasive paricles embedded in the surface of boards, however. For example, allowing them to come in contact with the dirt, or dust from a sandstorm, ore even a nearby farmer harvesting soybeans upwind. For sources within your own shop, you need look no further than sandpaper, or the abrasive particles from sandpaper transferred via one of those waffled soft rubber sanding pads. Then there is grit from sharpening on a waterstone or and oilstone, metal filingsif you use the same bench for making tools, or flattening plane soles.

Re: Abrasive wood ...

#3

Re: Abrasive wood - mineral streaks

Stephen in Ottawa

>I would add that the wood has quite a few black (mineral) streaks. Don't know if this could be the problem.

- Stephen

Re: Abrasive wood ...

#4

mineral streaks

bill tindall

>Mineral Streaks are often, if not usually, stain from mold as a result of some tree injury, for example bird pecks.

Re: Abrasive wood ...

#5

Extra-hard Maple

Steve Elliott

>The last piece of maple I bought is WAY harder than any maple I've ever worked with before. To plane it takes a lot of force to move the plane, and the blade edge dulls quickly.

I now think of it as a cross betwen maple and kryptonite. Maybe yours is similar.

Re: Abrasive wood ...

#6

Re: Abrasive wood ...

Frank D.

>Hi Stephen,

I have had similar experiences with wood harvested too close to beaches in the Gasp�sie region of Quebec, near the sea. There is always sand and minerals embedded in the wood that dull saw edges quite quickly. I don't know if your wood is local but maybe it's a similar phenomenon linked to growing conditions.

Frank

Re: Abrasive wood ...

#7

Re: ask the experts

paul womack

>Wait for our Australian friends' timezone to come round. As I understand abrasive inclusions in timber are an Aus speciality.

BugBear

Re: Abrasive wood ...

#8

Re: Abrasive wood ...

Stephen in Ottawa

>Hi Frank,

I think the wood came from somewhere in Quebec, I'm not sure where. I bought it from a guy who had a huge haul. The other borards I got from him didn't have this problem, though I still have some boards left.

- Stephen

Re: Abrasive wood ...

#9

Re: Abrasive wood ...

david charlesworth

>Stephen,

I have occasionally had the same problem. My assumption is some kind of mineral deposit. The offending patches were either greenish or black, can't remember precisely. But definitely in the timber, not due to grit contamination of the surface. The blade damage was spectacular and swift.

David Charlesworth