Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Tar and finishing topcoat question

Posts

Tar and finishing topcoat question

#1

Tar and finishing topcoat question

Sanfordlevy@yahoo.com

>Hi, I just recently tried out mixing minwax red oak stain with tar to stain red oak. (Ashpaltum from roofing patch stuff) Got the mixture from a magazine, though I have seen lots of similar suggestions. It gave the oak a beautiful mission type color. But when I went to top coat with sme wipe on poly, the tar just disolved and made a mess. I wiped it down and lost a bit of the tar color, but it is still okay, however, I am not sure what to topcoat with given the tar. I do not have facilities to spray and am restricted to brush on or wipe on finishes. Can I use a water based poly with the tar? Will it stick to the tar based finish? Or should I try shellac? As I said, I have read several times about using asphaltum as a coloring agent, but I do not remember any comments about what to topcoat with! Thanks for advice.

Re: Tar and finishing topcoat question

#2

advantage of tar?

bill tindall

>Does tar do anything other than make the stain blacker? If not why not use black tinting pigment and avoid tar problems.

Re: Tar and finishing topcoat question

#3

Re: advantage of tar?

Sanfordlevy@yahoo.com

>I am not sure of the advantage save for the nice color. I know asphaltum (tar) has been a staple in finishing for a long time. Michael Dresdner (The Woodfinishing Book) comments on how a Florida shop he worked in when young kept it as a special trade secret, though, as it turned out, it was only a secret in that region and widely used elsewhere quite openly to stain oak. I have read it is also a key ingrediant in one of the Watco danish oils. It is used as a primary coloring agent for wood, it is used mixed with other colors as I used it, and it is used as a glaze over other things. The result I got is really quite nice and I plan to experiment with other uses. Sanford

Re: Tar and finishing topcoat question

#4

Re: Tar and finishing topcoat question

Tony Sade (Charleston, WV)

>I've used a gilsonite (asphaltum based, I think) wiping stain from SW on a couple of white oak mission pieces and top coated with a wipe-on poly/naptha blend. No problems with the poly affecting the stain. I suspect you didn't wait long enough for the finish to cure before using your top coat. My $.02. Tony

Re: Tar and finishing topcoat question

#5

Re: Tar and finishing topcoat question

Bob Hackett

>I`ve added tar to 4 part finish(poly being on of the 4 parts)and never had any trouble.

You may want to try adding poly to the mix and see if that will help seal it.If you want to topcoat it with straight poly after it should not be a problem.

How long did you wait before applying the topcoat?

Mainely,Bob

Re: Tar and finishing topcoat question

#6

Re: That's the Watco Dark Walnut

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>

Re: Tar and finishing topcoat question

#7

Re: Tar and finishing topcoat question

Sam Simpson

>Hi Y'all,

Sanford, some good answers here, all offering hints at the problem. Let's see if I can round it up.

You are right about the colour of aspheltum being worth the effort, so let's not try to change the initial premise.

Stains can be nothing more than particles in a solution, that when dry, are easily washed off or reamalgamated by the next operation. Most proprietary stains come in a solution that includes a fixative of some kind. Usually nothing more than a drying oil or thin varnish. What this does is encapsulate the stain and trap it on the surface, making it easy to work on top of. Your solution obviously has no fixative. Bob has no problem because he is using a fixative. Tony's suggestion of letting it dry longer will only work in those cases where a fixative is present.

You have two choices with your recipe. 1 - you can add some fixative, such as a little wiping varnish, to the mixture, or 2 - you can seal the stain after it is dry with something like shellac before working on top of it. Your choice should be dependent on what the next layer of finish is going to be. If lacquer, then I would use a shellac sealer. If oil based varnish I would add a little varnish to the stain mix and for most complex modern finishes I would go with a vinyl sealer.

These choices are not critical, you will just have better expansion and contraction compatibility and better mechanical and chemical key if you choose correctly.

Regards Sam Simpson.

Re: Tar and finishing topcoat question

#8

Re: Tar and finishing topcoat question

Sanfordlevy@yahoo.com

>Thanks everyone, I think I have some things to try. I will report! Sanford