Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Resawing... by hand?

Posts

Resawing... by hand?

#1

Resawing... by hand?

ScottS

>So, I'm in the mood to make some small boxes. Probably don't need anything thicker than 1/2", but all I've got is 3/4", 4/4, and thicker lumber. My buddy has a nice bandsaw, and I'd normally hit him up to resaw the stuff, but he recently moved and doesn't have his shop up and running yet. Given that he has a new daughter, I suspect it's not a high priority.

Received a couple of Japanese saws (ryoba, dozuki) for my birthday and had a foot-long scrap of inch-thick maple sitting on the bench... so I decided to experiment. And I wasn't entirely successful. While I was able to saw pretty consistently to the line that I'd marked around the edges of the board, at some point the blade started to deflect. So the edges turned out fine, but there's a big hollow in the middle of one piece and a hump in the middle of the other. The resulting boards are pretty useless for anything other than kindling...

Any suggestions? What's your preferred tool and technique for resawing by hand?

Re: Resawing... by hand?

#2

Re: Resawing... by hand?

Bob Rozaieski

>Home made frame saw. Bandsaw stock for blade.

http://www.hyperkitten.com/woodworking/frame_saw.php3

http://www.hyperkitten.com/woodworking/resaw.php3

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/handtools.pl?noframes;read=44017

Re: Resawing... by hand?

#3

Re: Resawing... by hand?

Dan Moening, in foggy Sacramento

>Firewood?

How much deflection did you get?

Seems that at the least the board with the hump in the middle could be planed down flat and used for something?

Same for the "divot" board.

Might end up with one 1/2" and one 1/4" board, but still useful; especially if you make boxes of any kind.

Then again, time is money.

Dan.

Re: Resawing... by hand?

#4

Re: Resawing... by hand?

Charlie

>ECE rip bowsaw. You can't miss.

Re: Resawing... by hand?

#5

Frame Saw

Andrew Bacchi

>Great links, thanks. I have a long weekend coming up next week, I'll have to give it a try.

Re: Resawing... by hand?

#6

Re: Resawing... by hand?

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>If you want 1/2" you're not going to get there with 4/4 stock.

Not to sound mean, but is anyone actually using framed saws to resaw, or is this all theory? I know we talk about it. It does seem to make sense.

I recently resawed a 2 4' long 1x12's (I got 5/16 stock at best from 3/4" pine. I found the tricks to be a VERY course saw and a near vertical stroke. (I also had a very long rip saw- 28")

The horizontal sawing I see associated with framed saws doesn't jibe with my experience. That said, there is a picture in Diderot of two men doing exactly that (they were French though).

Adam

P.S. You can look at that French crack in several different ways. Its up to you to interpret my meaning and I'm not telling!

Re: Resawing... by hand?

#7

Re: Resawing... by hand? *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Neither a ryoba nor dozuki is suitable for resawing any board longer than the distance from teeth to the other teeth or from teeth to spine. What you need in Japanese saws is called a Tatebiki, a rip saw with a single side of teeth. Should go really fast.

Pam


Tatebiki

Re: Resawing... by hand?

#8

Re: Resawing... by hand?

Charlie

>Is anybody actually using a framed saw to resaw?

You're joking, right? What else would one use?

Re: Resawing... by hand?

#9

Re: Resawing... by hand?

ScottS

>Well the dozuki obviously won't work, given the spine! Was useful in starting the cuts at the corners, however.

I expected that the ryoba wasn't the ideal tool for resawing. My poor technique may have had something to do with it, too! Will a tatebiki have a thicker blade than a ryoba? Other than not having a second set of teeth to mar the work, how does the tatebiki differ from the rip-cut side of a ryoba? Not questioning your suggestion; just curious...

Re: Resawing... by hand?

#10

Re: Resawing... by hand?

Paul M. in San Diego

>The tatebiki I have is indeed a bit thicker than my Ryoba. But the teeth are also much bigger which gives the aggressive Rip that Adam talked about earlier.

Even with the proper saw, I've found to rip thin wood to be even thinner I need to alternate directions and sides. I clamp the board sticking straight up out of my face vice, and mark both long edges of the board for the cut. I then saw in at about 30 degrees angling down from the end of the board until the saw is advanced an inch or two. Extract the saw, shuffle around to the other side of my face vice, and again start ripping at the opposite 30 degree angle to the end of the board. Shuffle every couple of inches. I no longer get the dishing you experienced in the middle of the board when I do the "rip dance" around the board.

Lots of words... I hope that made sense!

Re: Resawing... by hand?

#11

Bow Saw vs. Frame Saw?

ScottS

>GREAT links! Thanks for the response...

Have to admit, the frame saw looks a bit unwieldy. But it seems to be the saw of choice, looking at the other responses.

One question: in looking for more information, I've found references to both frame saws and bow saws. The frame saws pictured in the articles you link to all have the blade in the middle of the frame. I've also seen saws with a wood stretcher in the middle, blade on one side and a wire or rod tensioner on the other (e.g. like the ECE bow saws sold by Adria). I've seen these referred to as both bow saws and frame saws.

Is one variety of blade placement easier to use than the other, when it comes to resawing? I'm assuming that when people here talk about "frame saws", they mean the blade-in-the-center variety...

Re: Resawing... by hand?

#12

Re: Resawing... by hand?

ScottS

>Thanks for the technique suggestion, Paul. It did make sense and I think it was responsible, at least in part, for my trouble. I tried to do the resaw by cutting from two opposing corners. In looking at some of the other replies and their associated links, it seems like I probably should have made at least four cuts (one from each corner) and used a bit more angle...

Still, I might have to swing by The Japan Woodworker this weekend to have a look at a tatebiki!

Re: Resawing... by hand?

#13

Re: Resawing... by hand?

Dave (Arlington, VA)

>Hi Scott -

I have framesaw, and I do resaw with it - sparingly. More on that later. First, a thought on an alternative.

If you have 3/4" and you want to end up with 1/2" have you considering scrubbing it down to size. I know that means some waste - but here are my thoughts:

1. Even S4S 3/4" is likely to have some bow or twist in it. This means that once you get it flat and true it'll be less than 3/4" anyway... leaving relatively little to remove

2. Also even with a bandsaw you're going to leave a surface (on both faces) that will need to be flattened (somewhat) and smoothed. That means that even with a bandsaw you would need to leave a "margin of error" and your waste would be a pretty thin board (1/8"?)....seems to me. More so with resawing by hand.

3. 4/4 lumber would have the same issues (especially if its rough sawn) - but not as much. I would be more likely to consider resawing with 4/4 depending on its condition (i.e. warp, twist, etc).

As you resawing with a famesaw, I would offer a few observations (take'em or leave'em):

1. I know there is a nomenclature issue here, but, like you, I have come to called the saws with the blade in the middle, framesaws, and the saws with the windlass, bowsaws (or some varition thereof).

2. I have yet to resaw anything where I haven't messed up the alignment somewhat and had one or more of the sawing planes not intersect exactly. I chalk that up to the price of being a novice.

3. If you are going to use a wide, low TPI blade (which I recommend) you are going to need a VERY sturdy bench -- because otherwise the sawing motion will cause the bench to move around ALOT... and that's not good for your cut -- plus it's very annoying :-)

4. Experiment with setting your blade up to cut on the foward stoke and the back stroke - I find that the back stroke seems to work best for me.

5. Experiment with your height relative to the piece you are resawing. I think I'm coming to the conclusion that I like to be somewhat above the piece that I am resawing.

5. Do "starter cuts" as recommended on the hyperkitten website... and go slow. Let the blade do the work. Don't force it.

6. Don't fool yourself. Resawing is hard work. Don't resaw if you don't have to. The great thing about hand tools is that you don't have to be a slave to specifications. You can work with what you've got. Maybe you could rethink your design issues and see if you couldn't use the stock you already have.

Take everything I've said with a grain of salt. I'm still at the start of the hand tool learning curve slope. All the best and good luck.

Regards -

Dave

Re: Resawing... by hand?

#14

Re: Bow Saw vs. Frame Saw?

Alan Hamilton

>Scott,

Which saw is easier to use? I suppose it depends on what sort of cut you're making. To take a cut parallel to the board's width--like you're making veneer--a frame saw (using your definitions) is much easier.

To take off a bit from the board's width...well...a frame saw is still easier. A bow saw, with the blade turned a bit so the stretcher won't hit the stock, I find awkward and hard to keep to the line. But, of course, I'm not exactly a great sawyer.

But a frame saw might not work in all situations. Cutting perpendicular to the board's width, your frame saw might not have enough room from the saw blade to either stretcher. This is especially true of frame saws that are made to be a dedicated veneer saw; a proper veneer saw has very little room between the blade and the stretchers.

Alan

Re: Resawing... by hand?

#15

Re: Resawing... by hand?

Alan Hamilton

>Oooo Pam,

Jumping Jehosephat! Those prices. Ouch! When did "Made in Japan" get to mean "expensive"?

Alan

Re: Resawing... by hand?

#16

Re: Resawing... by hand?

William R. Duffield on the Cohansey

>Usually, bowing in the middle of the cut is caused by a dull saw or by too many teeth per inch for the distance being cut. Sometimes, it can be caused by insufficient tensioning of the blade. This is true for bandsaws and for frame saws.

Re: Resawing... by hand?

#17

Re: Resawing... by hand?

William R. Duffield on the Cohansey

>Out of desperation, some of us have had to resort to a bandsaw, or a coarsely toothed D8 thumbhole rip, or even a hybrid approach. I prefer using the framesaw, now that I have one.

The hybrid approach starts with a pair of kerfs, one in each edge, using a circular blade electron eater, and then finishing up, from four directions, with your favorite non-backed rip saw, either framed or unframed. The pair of kerfs guide the handsaw cut, and can save you a lot of time sawing and subsequently flattening the sawn faces, if you are willing to put up with the obvious disadvantages.

Re: Resawing... by hand?

#18

Re: Resawing... by hand? *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>The problem with a ryoba is the cross-cut teeth, once they enter the cut they start deflecting your aim.

A tatebiki can have a thicker blade, probably more related to overall saw size. However, I don't have a short tatebiki comparable to ryoba, so can't really say.

Follow the link below to "5 Practical Handsaw Exercises," pictures and everything. Mark is one of the very few people in the US who can sharpen Japanese saws.

Pam


Mark Grable's sawing site

Re: Resawing... by hand?

#19

Re: Resawing... by hand?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Now how can you seriously ask that question in these days of tiny LN, Adria, etc. backsaws that cost $125? All good saws are expensive; and the Nakaya tatebiki have a huge hand work component.

Pam

Re: Resawing... by hand?

#20

get-your-feet-wet alternative *LINK*

John Truxell-Svenson (jvs)

>Something along the lines of the Nakaya is on my list, but I've had good results with the below. The cut does require a good amount of cleanup, but tracking is dead straight as long as I do my part, and it does cut quickly.




/jvs


scroll down to king rip

Re: Resawing... by hand?

#21

Ryoba works really well.

Tim of Dublin

>Ryoba works just fine for resawing....unless all the resawn walnut I've done is in some way not resawn. I used a 300mm ryoba to resaw some 10 inch wide walnut boards from 8/4 to 1/2 inch finished thickness.

It is a lot of work to resaw by hand...have a towel or two around to mop your brow.

Tim

Re: Resawing... by hand?

#22

Re: Tashiro's Hardware

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Oh, yeah, a lot of people get their saws from Tashiro; so I expect they're really good and an economical approach. Thanks for the reminder.

Pam

Re: Resawing... by hand?

#23

Re: Ryoba works really well.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>So how do you accommodate the cross-cut teeth? A lot of people online have reported problems resawing more than the blade's depth; and I've also had such problems. I haven't tried it in Walnut yet; but in cherry, mahogany, oak, etc....

Pam

Re: Resawing... by hand?

#24

Re: Resawing... by hand?

Tom Price

>Yes Adam, some of us have successfully resawed wood with frame saws.

Goes a whole lot easier than with my big Disston thumbhole rip. My framesaw has a length of Delta 6 tpi bandsaw blade.

- Tom

Re: Resawing... by hand?

#25

Re: Ryoba works really well.

Tim of Dublin

>Same way as managing ripping a long length - some wedges and some tape.