Re: Questions for Bailey Label Experts
Jonathan Peck - N.Y.
>I'm not sure about the label on the box, but it should be pretty easy to date this plane by going to one of the Stanley dating flowcharts. I think the high price has more to do with the condition of the plane in combination with the box. The plane looks to be in new and unused condition in the original box. I think that this plane would be right at the top of FTJ's rating system and could be classified as NEW.
For anyone who isn't familiar with the FTJ rating system...read on
The more I think about it, the more I'm not really sure what "mint"
means. "Excellent", "almost mint" and "minty" have me scratching my
head as well. And of course there's "crispy" and "bonerific". "Rare"
seems self explanitory, but how can a Stanley #4 "older type" be
rare? Sometimes I see "very nice" and I wonder if that's better than
just plain "nice". "Vintage" with an exclamation point (Vintage!!)
seems to be better than vintage without. "Early type" makes me think
low knobs or pre-lateral and not SW which could be called "later
type". "Pre-war" and "Antique" seem to mean something special also,
especially if your selling "wood planers". I recognize "fine" but
what is "VV fine" (very very)? "Primitive", yeah....that one conjurs
up all kinds of imaginative things.
This is all so creative. Are these terms interchangable? Like, could
I say that I have an almost mint rare vintage antique wood
planer...nice!!
FTJ's tool rating index:
Category-New, Wear-None, Finish-100%, Usable-Totally, Repairs-None,
Rust-None, Misc. +Orig. Pkg.
Category-Fine, Wear-Minimal, Finish-90%-100%, Usable-Totally,
Repairs-None, Rust-Trace
Category-Good+, Wear-Normal, Finish-75%-90%, Usable-Yes, Repairs-
None/Minor, Rust-Minor, Misc. Some dings and scratches
Category - Good, Wear - Normal, Finish 50%-75%, Usable - Yes,
Repairs - Minor, Rust - Minor, Misc. Small chips
Category - Good - (minus), Wear - Normal, Finish - 30%-50%, Usable -
Probably, Repairs - Minor, Rust - Minor to Moderate
Category - Fair, Wear - Heavy, Finish - 30%, Usable - No, Repairs -
Moderate to Major, Rust - Moderate to Major.
Category - Poor, Wear - Heavy, Finish - N/A, Usable - No, Repairs -
Major, Rust - Major.
Regards
Jonathan