WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Why are spokeshave blades growing?

Posts

Why are spokeshave blades growing?

#1

Why are spokeshave blades growing?

Mike Stallard

>While discussing spokeshaves on this forum a little while ago, I realized that I had neglected the Lee Valley low angle spokeshave kit I bought about six months ago. I decided to go ahead and make the shave.

I have an old wooden low angle shave, and I was comparing it to the new kit. The blade on the old shave is much shorter. I am not talking about the blade width, but the length from sharpened edge back. In fact it is only as long as the bevel, about 3/8 inch.

The new kit blade and the blade on a low-angle shave I also bought from LV are about 3/4 inch long, with a 3/8 inch flat section behind the bevel. I became curious, and I looked at Ron Hock's shave blades as well. They also appear to be longer, with a flat section behind the bevel.

Are these longer blades typical of newer low angle spokeshaves? I notice Dave's Shaves use Hock blades. I haven't seen one of the Harris shaves, and I assume there are others. Do these use longer blades?

Why are the spokeshave blades longer? I see two possible advantages. The flat at the back of the blade gives you some to clamp onto to make sharpening the blade easier, and the longer blades are stronger, although strength hasn't been an issue for my old shave. That greater blade length makes the spokeshave less nimble, however. They just won't follow as tight a radiused inside curve.

Is it not technically feasible to make short spokeshave blades any more? Is there some shave blade manufacturer I don't know about making short blades?

Re: Why are spokeshave blades growing?

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Why are spokeshave blades growing?

Jack Guzman from Maine

>Mike is it possible that your older shave blade was once longer but sharpening shortened it? ---Jack

Re: Why are spokeshave blades growing?

#3

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Why are spokeshave blades growing? *LINK*

Jim in Burlington Ontario

>Not sure why they are longer but there are shorter ones made. Kansas city tool works makes 3 sizes of shaves. I'm not posative but think some of Dave's shaves have Kansas city tool works blades in them.


http://www.kcwtw.com/sshaves/shavespg.htm

Re: Why are spokeshave blades growing?

#4

Re: Why are spokeshave blades growing?

Mike Stallard

>Jack,

Don't think so. If that were the case, there would be quite a gap to the sole. There isn't. It is probably a little wider than it should be ideally, but it's still on the order of a sixteenth of an inch or less. There is a brass sole, but it is continuous with the ware. I've seen pictures of similar blades in David Charlesworth's book.

The spokeshave body is also much smaller than LV's and Charlesworth's designs for new blades. Charlesworth used the Hock blade. The older spokeshave body is similar in size to the metal LV low angle shave.

Re: Why are spokeshave blades growing?

#5

Re: Why are spokeshave blades growing?

Mike Stallard

>Jim,

The pictures on the site show blades that are similar to Hock's and LV's blades. There is a flat area on the blade which contains the holes for the posts. There is then a knotch on either side of the bevel area. My older blade does not have the knotches. I'll look for Kansas City Tool Works blades, though. Thanks for the tip.

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.