Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

Posts

Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

#1

Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

Chris McLaughlin

>I love Roy. I feel energized and edified each and every time I watch his program. This last episode was particularly wonderful and described the creation of a female thread cutting apparatus to match the large diameter male device he found at a flea market in, I believe, Oslo.

What I'm concerned about is his propensity for cutting himself. I think it's a riot that he occasionally nicks himself and bleeds on the project he is working on. The multiple dirty and tattered bandages on his hands along with the blackened and split fingernails are par for the course, as they say. But today he was sporting 7-8 stitches around his index finger that made me wonder if Roy is scaring away possible converts. This is all tongue in cheek, of course, but that guy seems to cut himself far too often. Perhaps he should do an outakes episode where we can watch him cut himself up a la Julia Child as played by Dan Ackroyd.

I just hope that I'll be able to cut myself with such panache someday.

Chris

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

#2

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>St. Roys injuries may be frequent but stiches at worst can fix him up. Only minor power tool injuries are that easy to repair. JR

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

#3

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

Don Thompson - Cutler Ridge, Florida

>(g) I saw an episode a while ago in which they made a montage of all of his OOPS segmants. OUCH!

Anyway, if you have, or have the potential of, loving handtools, he is great.

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

#4

In some ways, Yes

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native in FL. Exile :~(

>Chris,

When it comes to handtools St. Roy is right at the top of a very short Who's Who list of Handtools Kings. He sits right up there with James Kingshott and Graham Blackburn no doubt.

I say that he is a bit of a bad role model because his shop is all a clutter. Triping over stuff, knocking stuff over, digging around for tools just to name a few are bad, bad, bad. Whilst I'm not a big advocate of keeping a Surgical Room clean work shop I am an advocate for a organized and tidy workshop, as in a place for everything, and most things in it's place at most times. I can understand the problems with making room for a new "member of the family", but roy is way out of control in that respect.

I also find very little humor in him cutting himself. What is humorous is the way he handles it.

I've long said that roy deserves an hour show because he really needs it to be an effective instructor of handtools and their uses. After all, compare a task between Roy and Norm such as making a mortise. norm fires up the drill ptress with an attachment, and Roy breaks out a chisel and mallet, marking guage, clamps, etc, etc. so who needs the more time? Roy handsdown.

Other than a messy, which leads to a unsafe workshop Roy is a PERFECT role model, and is definately worthy of the the title of "Saint"

Todd O.

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

#5

Jim in Burlington Ont.

1 Hour

Jim in Burlington Ontario

>Before I knew anything about hand tools I watched his show. He is so confused and clumsy it's almost like a act till you see the scars and the way he emphasises safety. I was watching his lathe making show the other day and almost fell off my seat laughing a few times. I wish he had a whole hour.

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

#6

You should see him in person

Roy from Cincy

>I had the supreme honor of attending a demonstration given by his Royness. He is a hoot in person. He not only has a lot of information on hand tools, he has a joke a minute. I got him to autograph my book - "To Roy, Best wishes, From Roy." Cool!

I once had the supreme experience of visiting Highland Hardware in Atlanta, where they have an autographed poster of Sir Roy. It say something like "To Highland Hardware, Thanks for supporting woodworking beyond the Norm." Get it? Beyond the NORM?

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

#7

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

William R. Duffield on the Cohansey

>What's the problem with scars? Two of my latest, on two different fingers, on two different hands, were dealt to me by two different hollow chisel mortisers, in two different shops. Luckily, neither one was running at the time, so I just spilled a little blood.

I'd be stumbling all over myself, too, if I had to do the whole show all in one real-time shooting, without any retakes, without editing, no apprentises, no prompter, in an unpowered shop, instead of in Norm's huge TV studio with full production crew. You too could make it look perfect if you had the resources of unlimited retakes, professional directon, scripts, and lots of identical precut parts if you spoiled the operation the first 42 times.

Lots of really incredible furniture used to be built in shops as small, cramped, cluttered, unequipped and poorly lighted as Roy's Woodwright Shop.

An hour would be better, to give him enough time to show more precise workmanship, instead of quickly and just good enough to demonstrate the concept. But he very effectively gets the point across, any no one has time to get bored.

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

#8

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

Bob Smalser, Seabeck, WA

>I think you're missing the point.

His message is, "Hey, look at me...I'm a complete klutz...if I can do good woodwork, so can you."

Love him for it, too.

Because the opposing message is, "Kid, ya gotta have all these expensive machines to do decent woodworking."

And Roy's counterpart has me puking and running away in horror as soon as the airnailer comes out to drive 6 brads.

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

#9

Re: In some ways, Yes

Bob Dodge

>Lol, Todd,

"Nahm" does AMAAAAZING stuff, lol, sure DOES go quick, when you consider the mortising attachment is already installed on the drill press, the fence is set, the wood lined up, and all you see is the plunging of the handle. Voila!. A totally finished cherry cabinet, all in 27 minutes ;-)).

Just setting that thing up, would probably take me half an hour; by that time Roy's already finished his mortise, and is already back, from the emergency ward. ;-))

We rarely see him where I live, but he sure is comical.

All the best, Bob

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

#10

only an hour??

John Longwitz-Doraville, GA

>..got to see him at a Highland Hardware tent sale a few years ago. He can keep the folks entertained much longer than a measly hour. He also gets any kids in the area involved and interacting. Had his foot powered scroll saw and his hand tools in a double deer rifle case festooned with travel stickers. His energy level didn't seem to diminish all throughout the morning and always had a crowd around his spot.

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

#11

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: In some ways, Yes

Jack Guzman from Maine

>Hi Todd,

I agree, his shop could be just a bit more organized,but I feel more akin to him for the clutter.I can't relate to a perfect shop with everything in it's place. People like that have to have a helper cleaning up after them.I always strive for it but after spending half a day organizing and getting no woodworking done I care a little less for perfection.Once I get working on several projects the clutter just seems to grow on it's own.

Jack

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

#12

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

William R. Duffield on the Cohansey

>Oh please. Just mention of the nail gun and its compressor makes me wince, thinking about the stress I get every time the oilless compressor kicks in, and then again at the end of the day when pressure is relieved from the tank. There is no worse way for an electron to die. BTW, the new compressor, in another shop I sometimes work in, mostly for spraying finishes, is oil lubricated, and has been relegated to an outbuilding. No compressors and no nailguns in my shop!

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

#13

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

Dave Anderson Chester, NH

>Well Sir William it seems that many folks who have yet to discover our favored way of woodworking lack the skill to use even so basic a tool as a hammer. While a hammer is basic,it is not an uncomplicated tool to use efficiently. Some time you need a good laugh so just make the effort to watch a group of folks misuse a hammer while trying to build something. I think the carpenters here would agree with me that more hammers are misused than used.

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

#14

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

Alan Hamilton

>I think trying to do things too fast is probably the main reason Saint Roy of Underhill's work has blood on it. I've punctured myself more than a few times when I was rushing too much. He seems to me to have that high speed personality; there are not enough hours in a single day to do all the things he wants to do.

As to the cluttered shop, his knocking things over and tripping... That too may result from his high speed drive. He has too many things to do to worry about sweeping up the shop and putting away all his tools.

But also, you don't need to watch Saint Roy very long to see that he's doing something in addition to working wood: He's consciously working to entertain us. The clutter and the mishaps go along with his machine-gun narration to keep it interesting; I know people who aren't the least bit interested in woodworking who love to watch him. I've not seen him when the cameras aren't there, but I'd bet if he's by himself things go more smoothly. But if there's any kind of an audience present...

Alan

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

#15

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

Bob Smalser, Seabeck, WA

>Not to mention that a pneumatic brad nailer does such an inferior job compared to the proper, 4oz Warrington hammer.

Especially when nailing on backs that should be screwed on in the first place for painless dismantling when the piece needs repair sometime in the future....and watching some of Norm's finish carpenter production methods used on freestanding furniture, that'll be quicker than many think.

"Expensive preparation and storage of the next generation's fireplace kindling."

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

#16

Good Point Alan

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native in FL. Exile :~(

>Yes, Roy does an incrediable job of entertaining while doing woodworking I agree 1000%. Trust me that aspect of him is not lost on me.

I can also relate to his fast paced personality and the relationship with the cluttered shop,HOWEVER, I think if his shop was not so cluttered he'd save alot of time by not looking for tools, moving stuff, etc, etc, that he could use to do more of the things he wants.

Now, don't get me wrong, my shop gets cluttered also from time to time, but it only really takes a few minutes to to straighten it up. The biggest obstacle to clutter is off-cut storage. Brother dem off-cut accumulate faster 'n' rabbits I swear. Reminds me off the fellow who said that he had one sharpening stone, than he dropped it so now he has three sharpening stones.

At the end of a shop session I sweep the floor, put tools away etc, etc, and yet my shop is getting smaller and smaller. Really quite amazing thing. I bet it would be a real hoot to put a time delay camera up in a corner and in a years time play the tape in a 5-10 minute clip and watch your shop get smaller, and smaller, and smaller.

Todd O.

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

#17

Re: Hammers! Slowly I Turned...

William R. Duffield on the Cohansey

>Don't get me started on hammers! I've had to repair way to many chairs that had been pushed to the brink, and sometimes beyond some time in the past by some uneducated, misinformed, arrogant citizen who just knew that he could easily repair a loose joint by driving a nail into it. And if one was good, two was better, or maybe he just needed a bigger hammer, or a bigger nail.

Hammers have their place, even pneumatically driven ones, but once you have your CO, they need to be checked at the door.

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

#18

Of course he is a good role model!

Chris McLaughlin

>Really, I was joking. You bet Roy is a good role model. He is hilarious and I find all the nicks and cuts on his hands endearing. My post was intended to bring to mind the horror a truly dedicated electron killer might feel if he were to see the stitches on Roy's hand; never mind the cognitive dissonance generated in comparing relative injury rates and severity between electric and hand tools.

Speaking of cognitive dissonance, I am truly amused whenever Roy gives a lecture on the issue of safety as he typically follows this up with a demonstration of how not to be safe. I imagine this is because he does his show in what appears to be a single take. In the episode withe the stitches, he admonishes the viewer to always wear glasses when breaking a newly fashioned cutter off of the file it was made from and then goes ahead and does it without wearing glasses. Kind of reminds me of an article I read about Sam Maloof in which he describes cutting things freehand on the bandsaw and then states that no one should do it.

Anyway, I've watched Roy make the tap to match his die twice now and will probably watch it again before I tape the next episode over the top of it.

Cheers.

Chris

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

#19

Re: Of course he is a good role model!

William R. Duffield on the Cohansey

>I've watched Sam Maloof do that on video tape. It is a very frightening technique, requiring lots of practice, a superbly tuned saw with a sharp, straight blade, and in depth understanding of the wood and the cutting forces at work. Only an instant's distraction and you could have broken wood, broken saw and crushed fingers. I wouldn't do it that way. I always cut with the work completely supported by the table on both sides of the blade. Sam Maloof has also made a new DVD, which I got to see at the Renwick Gallery when he spoke ther last month in DC. It shows his hands up close, It seems that on any given day, he probably has more dings, cuts, scratches, scars and band aids than Roy.

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

#20

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

Victor Parisian - Houston

>We used to get Roy here in Houston. Loved his show. Where can I catch his show now? How do we get hold of him or his production company to try to bring it back to Houston?

I know, start with the cable operator.

Victor

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

#21

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model? *LINK*

Skip in Falls Church

>I lived in the Houston area until a few years ago. KUHT always shuffled Norm, Roy and Scott in and out of the line up - not to mention changing the times around from year to year. If you want to know what's up you might try contacting them to see what the status is.

Skip


http:///www.houstonpbs.org/

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

#22

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

Jack Guzman from Maine

>I can't help you with houston programming but I thought I didn't get his show here in Maine because I couldn't find it anywhere on satellite. I did a search on pbs and found that it does indeed play here on local pbs on Saturdays at 3 pm. I have to shut off the satellite and turn my antenna but it's almost clear.I tape every show I can.---Jack

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

#23

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

Ted Shuck, Centennial, CO

>I didn't think we got it in the Denver area either, until I checked the PBS listings thoroughly and found him sporadically on at 2am on Friday night/Saturday morning (Channel 12). I've been taping every time slot and seem to be getting Roy about half the time.

Ted

Re: Is Roy Underhill a bad role model?

#24

Hammering

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>It really is an astonishingly complex skill. Try hammering with your "off" hand some time to test out how complex it is. My father used to comment, with awe, that his father in law (my grandfather, of course -- let's keep these relationships clear) could hammer equally easily with either hand. I've done a little right-handed hammering in my life, and have learned not to be a complete klutz, but am much better hammering backhanded with my left (dominant) hand.