Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Round v. Square Dogs

Posts

Round v. Square Dogs

#1

Round v. Square Dogs

Chris McLaughlin

>I'm at the point of making the doghole strip on a workbench and am contemplating routing a bunch of dog hole slots or drilling a number of 3/4" holes in the bench top after vise installation.

Does anyone have any thoughts on the relative merits of square v. round dogholes and dogs?

Chris

Re: Round v. Square Dogs

#2

Re: Round v. Square Dogs

Matti Kuikka

>Wooden bench dogs are easy to make.

Matti Kuikka


img

Re: Round v. Square Dogs

#3

Re: Round v. Square Dogs

Angus Barclay, in New Zealand

>It doesn't have to be a choice between the two.

You can use BOTH round and square dogs on the same bench.

I put a row of square dog holes on the front edge of my bench but have a few round holes drilled when I needed them for specific tasks.

regards

Angus Barclay

Re: Round v. Square Dogs

#4

Re: Round v. Square Dogs

Alan Hamilton

>Chris,

As Angus said, you can have both.

But if you want only one or the other, I'll vote for round. With round dogs you can rotate the flat spot to hold oddly shaped things. I thought that wouldn't be a very often-used feature, but my round dogs have proven to be very handy just for that reason.

Alan

Re: Round v. Square Dogs

#5

Re: Round v. Square Dogs

Jerome Laux

>When I made my bench, I contemplated both. The Lee Valley Benchdogs sold me on the round ones. I found it easier to drill holes rather than go through the trouble of dadoing all of the squares.

Re: Round v. Square Dogs

#6

Re: Round v. Square Dogs

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>I second Angus' suggestion and add that now is the time to create the square dog hole strip. you can always add the round holes.JR

Re: Round v. Square Dogs

#7

Re: Round v. Square Dogs

Don Thompson - Cutler Ridge, Florida

>I have not seen any square holdfasts!

Re: Round v. Square Dogs

#8

Re: Round v. Square Dogs

Janet Yang

>Matti, that's cool. How do you make the holes? It looks as though you glued the benchtop together from narrow pieces, leaving spaces where you intended to use the dogs.

How would you make a round dog?

Janet

Re: Round v. Square Dogs

#9

Re: Round v. Square Dogs

Matti Kuikka

>You deduced right.

I would buy round dogs if I needed them (metal).

Matti Kuikka