Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

The problem with those lovely infill planes�.

Posts

The problem with those lovely infill planes�.

#1

The problem with those lovely infill planes�.

Bob Smalser, Seabeck, WA

>�.is that I can�t figure out how to repair them without destroying them.

I always wince a bit when I read folks extolling the virtues of infills over common Stanley designs. Not that I don�t think they are great planes, it�s just that when they get old, repair becomes problematic.


Over the past year or so, I�ve been rehabbing and handing down old family tools to my oldest son interested in luthier work, replacing them with inexpensive old auction Stanleys like the #93 above that was easy to put back into order. Cheaper than him buying many new tools, and I can�t think of a better start than using and maintaining your Great Grandfather�s tools with some occasional guidance from your Dad.

This H. Burke infill shoulder plane is one we�ve had for probably 80 years or more, as I�ve had and used it hard it for at least 40. It was my only shoulder plane until I bought that Stanley a year or so ago. Still works OK, in spite of the wear�but not for another generation, that�s for sure.


I can replace the iron easily enough�.the issue is the mouth wear I�d like to repair before handing it down.

I can�t build it up with nickel-steel welding rod without dismantling it�.and there isn�t enough meat left in those dovetails and sides to reassemble, peen and dress it without ruining it.

JB Weld isn�t an option. Any other suggestions?

Thanks.

Re: The problem with those lovely infill planes�.

#2

Re: The problem with those lovely infill planes�.

WoodburnBob

>I would try gluing down a mild steel or brass "shim" of the correct thickness, down on the bed, to be beneath the iron.

Re: The problem with those lovely infill planes�.

#3

Re: The problem with those lovely infill planes�. *LINK*

Ted Shuck

>You might try soldering a new sole onto the plane. Peter McBride has posted an account of doing that to infill smooth planes on the Old Tools group. I have included a link to his posting below.

Ted


Soldering a new sole...

Re: The problem with those lovely infill planes�.

#4

Peter has a great idea! ....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Don't show this to everyone.

From now on I will not reject all those wide-mouthed infills, which are the only one's that are in my price range. The dream of a cheap infill lives on ...

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The problem with those lovely infill planes�.

#5

Great Article - But Doesn't Help

Bob Smalser, Seabeck, WA

>Thanks, Ted.

But he's soldering the bare plane after removing the infill he threw away.

If I dismantle it....I suspect I can't do it without destroying the infill which I want to save.

The sides of this plane are thin and peened over the rosewood. Getting that wood out of there intact and in a manner that doesn't ruin the sides looks almost impossible.

Re: The problem with those lovely infill planes�.

#6

Thanks,Ted...

Bob Smalser, Seabeck, WA

>...but just how are you gonna get those infills out without unrepairable damage, Derek?

Re: The problem with those lovely infill planes�.

#7

Re: Great Article - But Doesn't Help

Ted Shuck

>Sorry about the false alarm on that one. I had forgotten that he removed the infill, but it makes sense that this is the only way the solder would work.

I hope you can figure something out...

Ted

Re: The problem with those lovely infill planes�.

#8

Re: Great Article - But Doesn't Help

Bob Smalser, Seabeck, WA

>Because he reshaped the entire top profile of the plane, I suspect he did some damage to the edges and didn't want to show how he got that infill out of there.

I might have to do that, but my concern is if I spring those sides open, I may distort them beyond the ability to true them later....they are pretty thin.

Good article to have, tho....thanks again.

Re: The problem with those lovely infill planes�.

#9

Re: Great Article - But Doesn't Help *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Bob

When a to-be restored plane (or other tool) is intended to be a user, I think that I would be prepared to make some minor modifications. On the other hand, if either the originality factor or sentimentality is such that no change at all is deired, then I would put it on a shelf. "Minor modifications" include replacing the infill (while trying to replicate it as best as possible), even soldering on a new sole (if the mouth of a plane is so wide that this is all that will enable it to be used once again).

Now before you, or others, splutter into your beer in indignation, please recall that I would only do this to planes that cannot be made usable by less invasive methods.

I'm not sure if the above applies to your shoulder plane. It does require some metal to be replaced at the mouth. Can this be added through welding? I am aware of a technique called "spray welding" that is used on cars to fill holes.

Just thoughts and speculations...

Regards from Perth

Derek


spray welding

Re: The problem with those lovely infill planes�.

#10

Re: Great Article - But Doesn't Help

Bob Smalser, Seabeck, WA

>You may well be right.

Re: The problem with those lovely infill planes�.

#11

Screw a new sole to the bottom

Chris McLaughlin

>Rather than solder, you could try to screw a new sole to the bottom. You'd need to make it thicker than the 1/16" described in the soldering article to accomdate the counter sink and for grinding the screw head/slot off after installation.

This would add a bit of weight to the plane, but would be more or less reversible and could be re-done if it didn't work out so well the first time round.

cj

Re: The problem with those lovely infill planes�.

#12

Re: Screw a new sole to the bottom

Bob Smalser, Seabeck, WA

>That may be the best bet...we'll see.

Re: The problem with those lovely infill planes�.

#13

Re: The problem with those lovely infill planes�.

steve knight

>I would clean up the mouth and have a blade made that is thick enough to close the mouth.

Re: The problem with those lovely infill planes�.

#14

Re: The problem with those lovely infill planes�.

Bob Smalser, Seabeck, WA

>That's probably the simpest solution - thanks.

Re: The problem with those lovely infill planes�.

#15

So you want a bevel down shoulder plane?

WoodburnBob

>

Re: The problem with those lovely infill planes�.

#16

Re: So you want a bevel down shoulder plane?

William R. Duffield on the Cohansey

>Interesting question. Perhaps the answer will be revealed by comparing the blade bedding angles between Bob's infill and his #93 in his photo. I think the much steeper bed angle of the infill indicates that it must be a bevel down plane (or maybe a bevel-up scraper plane? :^). IMHO, even the Stanley's bedding angle is a bit too high for end grain shoulders, especially considering that the steel they used in their blades was, according to lore, less than optimum for edge retention at small bevel angles. He's going to have to replace the cutter any day now, anyhow.

Re: The problem with those lovely infill planes�.

#17

What I should have said

WoodburnBob

>The British infill style rabbit/rebate plane in the picture is a bevel up plane.

The suggestion to use a thicker iron to close the mouth is simply erroneous. To use a bevel down iron in that plane would require opening the mouth to a degree that many would consider it destructive.

Furthermore, if the mouth is opened to try out an experimental bevel down arrangement, the iron's relief angle would necessarily change dramatically One would be locked irreverisibly into a fruitless conflict between the iron's cutting angle and the relief angle.

Re: The problem with those lovely infill planes�.

#18

Re: The problem with those lovely infill planes�.

Terry in Denver

>Bob:

when not hacking up wood I deal with the design, construction, and maintenance of high-end plastic injection molds for the medical industry. Occasionally we will "microweld" very tiny (delicate) areas that need to be built back up in the mold die to breakage or wear. Since the injection molding process can have very high pressures during the fill and pack stages, and the pressures exerted during clamp-up can be high, I believe this process might be durable enough to be an option for your infill. What I don't know is how it might work on cast metals.

Let me know if you want to explore it further.

Terry