Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Mineral spirits and waterstones

Posts

Mineral spirits and waterstones

#1

Mineral spirits and waterstones

Todd M

>Hi,

I read a recent article in Woodworking Magazine by Chris Schwartz about sharpening chisels. In flattening the back, he uses a DMT diamond stone and he recommends using a little mineral spirits for lubricant. Then he goes to a 1000 grit waterstone. Before I do this for my first time, do I needed to do anything to clean the chisel (other than wiping off the mineral spirits and slurry) before going to the waterstone? I didn't know if contamination was an issue.

Also, do you recommend his same procedure for flattening the backs of plane irons, and if so, how far up the back of a plane iron should I flatten? I'm doing a #4 plane, block plane and LN 62 low angle jack plane.

Thanks for your help.

Todd M.

Re: Mineral spirits and waterstones

#2

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Mineral spirits and waterstones

Jim in Burlington Ontario

>Todd I'd skip the mineral spirits they stink to much for me and any unecessary exposure I try to avoid. I use water. If the chisel is dirty or you need to remove a fair amount of material I'd certainly start with sandapaper on glass. You'll be surprised how fast the diamond stone wears when flattening the backs of irons. I do rinse the stone off when done and thoroughly dry it. I usually flatten between 1 1/2"-2" of the back or irons and yes it takes a long time and is alot of work so make sure to keep flattening your waterstones so you don't get a hollow or rounded iron.

Re: Mineral spirits and waterstones

#3

Re: Mineral spirits and waterstones

William R. Duffield on the Cohansey

>You can use either water or a petroleum based lubricant on the diamond stone. The choice depends on what sort of stone you will be going to next. I use a diamond stone followed by a hard Arkansas oil stone, so it makes sense for me to use MS or kerosene or even WD-40 on the diamond stone. If I were using a waterstone for final sharpening, then I would use water on the diamond stone, too.

If you use mineral spirits, spend the extra $$$ for the odorless mineral spirits. They are a lot less toxic.

Re: Mineral spirits and waterstones

#4

Re: Mineral spirits and waterstones

Jerome Laux

>A friend of mine who used to work for Norton before he retired uses water with a little household ammonia mixed in for lubricating his diamond stones. I sharpened a couple of rather dull drawknives with it. It worked great.

Re: Mineral spirits and waterstones

#5

Re: Mineral spirits and waterstones

Alan Hamilton

>Todd,

As I'm sure you know, the only place the back needs to be flat and polished is way down at the edge. So long as the part of the back that actually makes the edge is flat and polished, all is well.

When I do the backs of my chisels and plane irons and the like, I move the tool in little circles on my waterstone, from one end of the stone to the other and back again, ad nauseum. Doing it this way the end of the tool spends more time on the stone than any other; and obviously, as you move up from the edge, the tool spends progressively less time on the stone. After the final stone, only a stripe next to the edge is fully polished, and the tool is less and less polished as you move up the back.

There's no need to polish more than that. With each successive sharpening, the stripe will move farther up the back.

I hope I explained this clearly enough; and I hope it's of some use to you.

Alan

Re: Mineral spirits and waterstones

#6

Re: Mineral spirits and waterstones

Janet Yang

>I don't know if the odorless mineral spirits are less toxic, but they are certainly more pleasant to use. The odor from the regular stuff gives me a headache. But I treat the odorless as though it is just as dangerous.

By the way, I notice that our water heater was placed on a short platform so it is a couple of feet off the ground. Is this to keep the pilot light away from spills and fumes of flammables?