WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Should I sell this saw for parts?

Posts

Should I sell this saw for parts?

#1

Should I sell this saw for parts?

Roy from Cincy

>Hi. I need a little advice. I picked up a saw a couple of weekends ago at a garage sale. It's a Bishop from Cincinnati and says patented 1887 on the medalion. Since Bishop moved out of Cincy to Lawrenceville in 1890, that pretty much brackets the age of the saw. The blade is not bad, most of the etching is readable, the medalion is good, all the nuts are good, but the handle sucks (see pic). Does it make sense to sell the medalion and blade separately or is it better to sell the whole thing?

Any comments appreciated.


img

Re: Should I sell this saw for parts?

#2

ToddH?

Ted Owen, Pittsburgh

>That handle looks pretty good for its age.

And I'm not sure that what works for hand planes, selling for parts, works for saws. ToddH would know.

Best, Ted

Re: Should I sell this saw for parts?

#3

Re: Should I sell this saw for parts?

Ernie Miller Topeka

>I'm betting you will get more for it as a saw the handle looks to be missing part of the top handle. if I remember bight from the few Bishops that I have had they had a sharp pointed top horn that is indeed uncomfortable. it looks like one of the previous owners trimmed it off. I don't know what the rest of the saw looks like but I would move it as a saw and hope for $25

Re: Should I sell this saw for parts?

#4

Re: Should I sell this saw for parts?

Todd Hughes

>I have never sold a saw blade by itself so don't know.Might do OK but think if it was a Disston you might do better with the blade as a handle would be easier to find.The handle shown is Toast. I have done very well selling saw nuts in the past.Bought a bunch off a guy that trashed the blades of about 40 saws and saved all the nuts and some of the handles.Was a shame because some of the nuts and one handle came off very early Disstons that should have been saved. Somewhere i have a big coffie can full of saw nuts that I bought off another fellow but can't find it.I wouldn't think this single saw nut would go for much....If this saw was mine I would look for a handle to put on it ....Todd

Re: Should I sell this saw for parts?

#5

Re: Should I sell this saw for parts?

Roy from Cincy

>Thanks for the advice guys. I think I will hold out and bet on a better handle showing up.

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.