WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Steel for buck saw blade?

Posts

Steel for buck saw blade?

#1

Steel for buck saw blade?

Rod Cole

>Hello all,

As part of helping a friend edit a tool making book he has written, I made a small buck saw to use as a dovetail saw.

His suggested blade is to take a mitre saw blade and cut it in half. This is the sort of blade that goes into a framed handsaw vaguely like a large hack saw. The blades are roughly 24 inches by 2 inches, which gives two 12 inch blades. You can get the blades from several places. I picked one up from the local Woodcraft store, 18 tpi filed rip.

I like the saw, but not the blade. It is too thick, 0.03 inches and does not cut as smoothly as I'd like. I need to see if taking out some set helps (took out a little, might take out a bit more).

Anyway, I'm wondering about just buying a piece of steel and getting it filed into a saw blade at the local saw sharpening place.

I see that LN uses Swedish spring steel, ~50 on the Rockwell scale, something like 0.02 inch for their dovetail saw and 0.015 for their gent saw (have to double check, but something like that).

Given that in a buck saw the blade is under tension a thin blade should be ok. What might I look for 0.02 in, 0.15 inch, does it really matter?

Is there some other type of steel this would work fine?

I presume some calls would find a source for a blank of steel, but if someone wants to offer up a suggested source, it might be helpful.

Any pit falls to be aware of?

Thanks,

Rod Cole

Re: Steel for buck saw blade?

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Steel for buck saw blade?

Jack Guzman from Maine

>There are quite a variety of bandsaw blades to be had.I bet you could find just the right one for your purposes.---Jack

Re: Steel for buck saw blade?

#3

Re: Steel for buck saw blade?

L. Hanson - N. Idaho

>Mcmaster sells a blue tempered spring steel hardened in the Rc44 to Rc51 range - I've used it to make dovetail saws and it is pretty good steel. Look at the catalog page that contains item # 9014K65 on mcmaster.com.

Leif

www.norsewoodsmith.com

Re: Steel for buck saw blade?

#4

Re: Steel for buck saw blade?

Rod Cole

>Looks great. They can ship today and only charge $4 shipping.

I emailed LN to see if there was any chance they'd just sell me a blade, no back or or handle from one of their gents saws. That would save me having to go get the teeth cut, but I suspect the odds of LN selling me a blade for a fairly low price are very small. But who knows.

This way too I'd have enough steel for a crosscut saw too.

- Rod

Re: Steel for buck saw blade?

#5

Re: Steel for buck saw blade?

Bob Hackett

>In his book "The Precision Handcutting of Dovetails" Cecil Pierce advocated the use of a common 14 tooth hacksaw blade.

He had many reasons for using this approach(almost as many as the number of fine dovetail saws he owned),but the most valid one was the results.

It was also handy to be able to carry most of your saw till in a small tube,to include your occasional metalworking saw.If you made a small woodframe bowsaw tensioned by a threaded rod,like the one Bob Smalser wrote about recently,you`d have alot of sawing power and diversity in very little space.No need to carry sharpening equipment other than a stone to fine tune set.

Just something to think about.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Steel for buck saw blade?

#6

Re: Steel for buck saw blade?

Rod Cole

>Hi Bob,

Yeah thought about that. Still thinking. It really appeals to the practical side of me, which is the largest side. A hacksaw makes a surprisingly decent cut and you can get blades anywhere. I suspect with the amount of work I do a blade made to cut metal would last about a life time cutting wood.

On the other hand I have a frame made of curly cherry with a nice mix of heart and sap wood, and somehow a hack saw blade, while very practical, has limited esthetic appeal.

Good idea though.

- Rod Cole

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.