Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Plane Iron Curvature

Posts

Plane Iron Curvature

#1

Plane Iron Curvature

Tom Colligan, Peoria

>A few weeks ago a fella posted a message that the plane iron touches the frog only at the top and bottom of the frog. I was skeptical but I just bought a Stanley 5 1/2 off eBay and low and behold the iron has a very pronounced curvature in it. When laid flat it measures 3/64ths in the center.

Has anyone else examined an iron from an old plane and observed a bow in the center when the iron is laid flat?

Is this something that I should try and correct by reversing the bend? I'm not sure how I would do that as the iron is just under 8". Thanks for your advise and comments.

Re: Plane Iron Curvature

#2

Re: Plane Iron Curvature

Dale Stansbery

>I have found some far worse than others, but considered them abused. I doubt that more than one in a dozen of the old ones are perfectly flat, if even that many.(no scientific observations to back my theory). But if the frog face is suitably flat and the chip breaker and lever cap properly tuned, I suspect it doesn't make much difference as the blade will be drawn into place. If it can't be, then it's too far out.

Re: Plane Iron Curvature

#3

Re: Plane Iron Curvature

paul womack

>But if the frog face is suitably flat and the chip breaker and lever cap properly tuned, I suspect it doesn't make much difference as the blade will be drawn into place.

Nope; if you want a fun experiment, remove the frog from a Bailey plane, and clamp the blade in place. Look in awed wonder at the large gap between the blade and the frog.

I am becoming more and more convinced that blade "bedding" is over-rated; the old timers trick to open the mouth of a new wooden plane by placing a leather shim at the top of the bed DESTROYS any bedding, leaving the blade only supported at the arris of the bevel, and the top of the bed.

I also once owned a woody with a (as I thought) poorly shaped wedge, which only really applied pressure near the blade edge.

http://nika.frontier.iarc.uaf.edu/~cswingle/archive/get.phtml?message_id=60823#message

But this (purported) lack of bedding seems to cause no practical problems. Of course, these planes had 3/16 blades, which helps.

This also suggest that the wooden bedding in an infill may not have the effects claimed for it, since the (IMO) critical contact area is actually metal: a "throat plate"

BugBear

Re: Plane Iron Curvature

#4

Not designed to be flat

Roger Nixon

>If you look at the contact points on a frog/blade/cap iron/lever cap and where pressure is applied, you can see it does not lead to forcing the blade into continuous bedding with the frog.

The lever cap, as the name implies, is a lever which only touches at the top and bottom and pivots around the screw. At the top, it forces the cap iron/blade assembly into contact with the top of the frog. At the bottom, it transfers pressure to the curved portion of the cap iron which transfers pressure to the blade. That point is near the edge of the blade, not where the blade rests on the frog. That force will cause the blade to contact the top and bottom of the frog and try to arch away from the frog in the middle.

Re: Plane Iron Curvature

#5

Factoids-R-Us

WoodburnBob

>Really glad to see you tested this on your own and came to your own conclusion!

The woodworking and tool literature (print and electronic) is peppered with factoids...each begging to be discovered and disentangled from truth.

The term 'factoid' is often corrupted to mean something like 'little fact'. This is a factoid in itself. Thus, I offer a correct dictionary definition:

factoid

Something that becomes accepted as a fact, although it is not (or may not be) true; spec. an assumption or speculation reported and repeated so often that it is popularly considered true; a simulated or imagined fact.

---Oxford English Dictionary