Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review
Christopher Schwarz
>After my lengthy (but by no means exhaustive) recent test of chisels for Fine Tool Journal and Popular Woodworking, I wanted to post a short follow-up on the Lie-Nielsen chisels because I know people have questions about them. The No. 1 question being: Are they worth it?
My pseudo-scientific test put me and a second editor pounding away at chisels in redheart, examining edges under a 30x loupe, comparing notes etc. In that test, the Lie-Nielsens did as well as premium Japanese tools and Barr chisels. And I gave the edge to the Lie-Nielsens because they are so comfortable and balanced, which is at least half of the chisel equation for me.
So now the chisels are in everyday shop use. Recently I made two cherry tables for Woodworking magazine with some hand-cut dovetailed drawers and hand-chopped mortises. Then I built a wall cabinet in cherry with six drawers with more than 70 hand-cut dovetails in all in cherry and poplar with maple veneered fronts. (Note, I have an aggressive dovetail chopping style. Not Frank Klausz, but I do some serious mallet work.) Plus a bunch of paring, a couple hand-cut dovetail drawers for demonstrations and general joint clean-up.
After all that, the chisels' edges were still quite good. A couple sizes were showing a little wear, and there was a little more fiber-crushing in softer woods. But there was no edge failure. So I sharpened them for something to do a couple nights ago. It beats TV.
I would guess that I would have had to sharpen my Marples three or four times during that same amount of work.
But more important than the Lie-Nielsen's fantastic edge restention was how comfortable they are to use, very lightweight and the correct length for my work. The hornbeam handles are as tough as any wooden chisel I've owned or used. You can whack very hard, and all the ends do is dent a bit.
FYI, in the interests of full disclosure, the set I own was purchased with my own funds.
So for me, the awnser to the No. 1 question is: For me, heck yes.
Chris



