Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

Posts

Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

#1

Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

Christopher Schwarz

>After my lengthy (but by no means exhaustive) recent test of chisels for Fine Tool Journal and Popular Woodworking, I wanted to post a short follow-up on the Lie-Nielsen chisels because I know people have questions about them. The No. 1 question being: Are they worth it?

My pseudo-scientific test put me and a second editor pounding away at chisels in redheart, examining edges under a 30x loupe, comparing notes etc. In that test, the Lie-Nielsens did as well as premium Japanese tools and Barr chisels. And I gave the edge to the Lie-Nielsens because they are so comfortable and balanced, which is at least half of the chisel equation for me.

So now the chisels are in everyday shop use. Recently I made two cherry tables for Woodworking magazine with some hand-cut dovetailed drawers and hand-chopped mortises. Then I built a wall cabinet in cherry with six drawers with more than 70 hand-cut dovetails in all in cherry and poplar with maple veneered fronts. (Note, I have an aggressive dovetail chopping style. Not Frank Klausz, but I do some serious mallet work.) Plus a bunch of paring, a couple hand-cut dovetail drawers for demonstrations and general joint clean-up.

After all that, the chisels' edges were still quite good. A couple sizes were showing a little wear, and there was a little more fiber-crushing in softer woods. But there was no edge failure. So I sharpened them for something to do a couple nights ago. It beats TV.

I would guess that I would have had to sharpen my Marples three or four times during that same amount of work.

But more important than the Lie-Nielsen's fantastic edge restention was how comfortable they are to use, very lightweight and the correct length for my work. The hornbeam handles are as tough as any wooden chisel I've owned or used. You can whack very hard, and all the ends do is dent a bit.

FYI, in the interests of full disclosure, the set I own was purchased with my own funds.

So for me, the awnser to the No. 1 question is: For me, heck yes.

Chris


img

Re: Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

#2

Re: Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>It's amazing how good good chisels are, isn't it? I picked up a pair of Pexto chisels a few years ago, 1/2" and 1/4", and they would go MONTHS between sharpenings.

Re: Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

#3

Re: Follow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

Don Thompson - Cutler Ridge, Florida

>Do you think that the rosewood handles would be as sturdy as the hornbeam?

Re: Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

#4

Sharpening method?

Greg Deavers in Stillwater

>Chris,

Just for grins, what is your preferred method of sharpening?

I have a set of marples that as you say need sharpening quite often, and I am sure that they are not cryonized A2.

Thanks

Re: Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

#5

Nope

Christopher Schwarz

>Don,

The rosewood handles are quite nice looking, but I wouldn't use a mallet with them. I think Lie-Nielsen even posted something on the website about this.

Chris

Re: Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

#6

Waterstones

Christopher Schwarz

>I keep it pretty simple these days. I don't have a bench grinder, so I do all my grinding and initial shaping on an x-coarse DMT.

For honing I have a 1,000-grit waterstone and an 8,000-grit waterstone. I don't find the intermediate grits to be necessary (heresy, I know). I true the stones on the DMT.

I also use the side-clamp honing guide. Always have; and probably always will (sorry Joel).

Chris

Re: Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

#7

Re: Waterstones

Jonathan Peck - N.Y.

>Has anyone tried the 12,000 grit stone (Shapton)? I've been curious for awhile if the super high grit waterstones have any woodworking applications.

Re: Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

#8

Watched a guy once

Christopher Schwarz

>Harrelson Stanley has demonstrated them at shows and I've examined the edges and used the tools a bit after a 12,000-grit stone.

It made some sweet-looking edges. But I personally think it's overkill for most of us. Harrelson could probably convince you of its utility, however. He's got the religion.

Chris

Re: Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

#9

Re: Thanks you for the honest follow up!

CBT

>Chris, thanks for the straight forward follow up. Such tool evals are very important to folks like me. The fancy dancing some mags do in reviews is of no real value other than combining markting hype into one article. We do care what you and your peers think and realize our own style and type of work can vary from your own. But the honest reviews are priceless.

Curtis

Re: Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

#10

Re: Waterstones

Lyn J. Mangiameli

>I've used the original version of the 12000 and it is my constant finish and maintaince stone for blade blacks. I like it quite well, though it is a bit softer than I'd care for. I think they have fixed this in the latest versions. It takes an edge down to about 1 micron which is the bare minimum I'm content with for smoothing plane blades. Bevels are done to .5 or 3 micron on the LV QPSS;

Re: Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

#11

Re: Waterstones

Christopher Schwarz

>Lyn,

Apologies. My comments were referring to the Shapton 15,000 grit (.96 micron) stone. Not the M5 series 12,000 stone. I have no experience with that one whatsoever.

For my work, I find that 8,000 is very, very good. But I don't work with exotics. The toughest thing I work with regularly is curly hard maple.

Chris

Re: Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

#12

Re: Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

Bill Murphy/Reading,PA.

>Thank you for the follow up Chris. I see a set in my future..:o)

What kind of mallet do you use?

Bill Murphy

Reading, PA.

Re: Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

#13

Re: Follow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

William Duffield on the Cohansey

>Are you a "rose colored glasses collector" or a horny user? :^)

The way I see it, rosewood is for someone who wants chisels that first look good and also work good and feel good; hornbeam is for someone who wants chisels that feel good and work good and also look good.

The rosewood is denser, which makes it a bit less comfortable to work with. It's not quite as impact resistant, so will not hold up as well in the long run.

If your demonstration of your skills sells your products, get a set of each -- one for serious demonstrations and one for serious joinery.

Re: Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

#14

I like rosewood, but...

Christopher Schwarz

>Before you buy two sets of chisels, take a good look at the hornbeam ones. They are (in my book) totally gorgeous. They are tightly grained, smooth as a baby's bottom and the low weight makes the chisel feel like a pencil in your hand (a good thing).

Chris

Re: Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

#15

Depends *LINK*

Christopher Schwarz

>Bill,

For dovetailing, I really like my Tite-Mark #3 chisel hammer. For mortising, I've been hugely impressed with the new Veritas cabinetmaker's mallet (see link below). I wasn't expecting to like it much; it seemed a bit bulky to my eye. But boy is it balanced and well-suited for the task.

Despite my best efforts I have never become adept at the traditional beech joiner's mallet or the round carver's mallet. I don't know why I'm a numbskull on this point, but I seem incapable of picking up the right wrist action.

Chris


LV mallet

Re: Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

#16

Re: Value - philosophy

paul womack

>The No. 1 question being: Are they worth it?

Sadly, this question can only be answered by an induividual for that induividual.

Value is the ratio of price to performance. Whilst performance can be fairly well judged, the "pain" of a price depends completely on your disposable income.

Is a 500 dollar chisel "too expensive"? Not to Bill Gates...

BugBear

Re: Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

#17

Not a Shapton...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>But I use a 12K grit stone all the time. Scott who goes 1200 (if needed), 3000, 8000, and 12,000. I use Japanese chisles. Truly frighting sharp.

Re: Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

#18

Re: Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

Jim Cosgrove

>Chris,

I enjoyed reading your original review and appreciate the follow-up. For the record, I own a set of the LN chisels (one of the first 100 sets made) and like them very much. However, I am also fond of my Barr dovetail chisels and was a bit disappointed in the PW review because you suggested that the Barr chisels were not as comfortable to use. Now, I've no doubt that you found them to be less comfortable. Nonetheless, I thought the comment was unfair because comfort is such a subjective quality. It just seems to me that it would have been more helpful to say that they were heavier, had thicker handles, or whatever. My point is that something more objective would help readers decide for themselves on this point. As for me, I find the Barr's much more comfortable to hold and well balanced. The LN's are thinner and get into smaller dovetails better. That's why you'll see both sets in my shop. (Well, that and the fact that chisels and spokeshaves constantly follow me home....)

Regards,

--Jim

Re: Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

#19

More details

Christopher Schwarz

>Jim,

I still use the Barr chisels all the time -- I have my set (which I paid full price for out of my own pocket -- full disclosure here) in my shop at home now. I still find them uncomfortable for a variety of reasons I didn't have room to discuss in the article.

All this is only opinion, of course, but I feel pretty strongly that some chisel ergonomics are universal and not just my hand vs. your hand. Take this for what you will.

The chisels are heavy overall for dovetailing (both the Becksvoort-style and especially the standard ones). Many chisels (perhaps most) are too heavy. Nor are the Barr's paring chisels. They are too short for that.

The wood is too bulbous for my hand. It feels like a swollen Japanese chisel in my hand. The hoop ring hits my palm all wrong. And after some serious use, the wood in the hoop splits easily and needs to be constantly tended to, or it will bite your hand.

Also, the wood came rough off the lathe. At that price, I expect a bit more finish work.

All that said, I actually do like the tools a lot. The steel is very well made and fine-grained and durable. And though I think they're heavy, I deal with it as best I can.

Sorry you thought I was unfair.

Chris

Re: Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

#20

Re: Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

Lloyd Robins

>Okay, Chris, what about the longer version of your review on the Nishiki's? Just wondering. They seem to fit my hand well.

Re: Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

#21

Great steel

Christopher Schwarz

>Lloyd,

You cannot ask for better steel. The Nishikis (which I borrowed from Joel for the test) were tough. Especially the dovetail chisel. It just would not get dull.

I don't like how the Japanese chisels fit my hand, though they are just right (size-wise and weight-wise) for dovetail work in my opinion.

If they fit your hand, you cannot go wrong with this brand.

Chris

Re: Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

#22

Re: Great steel

Rick Hoppe (Los Angeles)

>Chris,

Have you tried Matsumura Chisels?

If so, what is your opinion?

Rick

Re: Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

#23

Good tools

Christopher Schwarz

>I've owned a small set of blue-steel Matsumuras for about six years now. It was the first decent chisel I'd ever owned.

They're quite good (though all my comments about Japanese handles hold true here). The edge is very hard, takes a fantastic edge, but can really shatter if stressed. I don't use a mallet with them much. I've found that true with many Japanese chisels.

Right now I'm testing a HSS chisel that should prove interesting.....

Chris

Re: Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

#24

Re: More details

Jim Cosgrove

>Chris,

But other than that you like the Barr handles. ;^) Seriously, what you just added was very helpful. I still would have disagreed--I like the bulbous handles and the unfinished wood because it is less slippery--but others likely share your preferences. Maybe my complaint is that all magazines over the last 10 or more years seem to have dramatically reduced the amount of text and substituted photos instead. Now I like pictures, but sometimes I miss the text--and the information that cannot be accomodated in a modern magazine. Anyway, I continue to look forward to your articles and advice. Thanks for the follow up.

--Jim

Re: Folow up to my Lie-Nielsen chisel review

#25

Re: Depends

Bill Murphy/Reading,PA.

>Chris,

I thought the same thing about the LV after seeing it on thier website, now I'll have to check one out.

As for the Tite-Mark #3 Dovetailing Hammer, I've never seen one. Are they still available?

Bill Murphy

Reading, PA.