Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Molding on frame and panel doors

Posts

Molding on frame and panel doors

#1

Molding on frame and panel doors

George Makowski

>Hi All!

I have made a number of frame and panel doors with a plain cross section of the frame. Now I have a project that requires that the outside and inside edges of the rails and stiles be shaped. I know how to fit the inside shape, but how do I generate the outside profile across the square cut ends of the stiles at the bottom and top of the door?

Specifically, do I plane the shape into the stile ends before assembly or do I assemble the door with the squared off ends standing pround and then plane them to match the molding of the rails?

Adam Cherubini, I would especially like to hear your take on this.

Thanks ahead for all of you help folks,

George in AL

Re: Molding on frame and panel doors

#2

Re: Molding on frame and panel doors

Sam Simpson

>Hi Y'all,

George, whether you can run them by machine or if you are forces to hand carve them, will depend on the shape of the molding profile. A full lambs tongue or full bead will dictate that they be carved by hand, because of one cutting across the other as they intersect at the outside corner. to solve this problem in a machine shop, one would daddo/rabet the outside edge of the frame and insert the molding, mitered at the corner. This solution is good for all molding profiles. It therefore seems appropriate to adopt this approach in your circumstance.

Regards Sam Simpson.

Re: Molding on frame and panel doors

#3

Re: Molding on frame and panel doors

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>George,

If I understand your question correctly, I don�t know the answer. I�ve never seen this specific example. But we see similar examples in the attachment of breadboard ends. These manifest in two places most often: dining tables, and secretary/scrutore desks.

Last table I did, (my own) had a simple rectangular bread board end. I molded the table�s edge, then attached bread board with its long edge molded. The ends of the bread board were then trimmed to match the table, and then painstakingly molded. I used gouges to rough in the shape, then did the best I could with the molding plane. The result was pretty rough, though that plane was pretty rough. Nice shape, but it had a really wide mouth. Come to think of it, that explains the roughness in the long grain but not the end grain. Looking back I could have tried rehoning the thing and shellacing the end grain to crisp it up a bit.

I�m fairly certain better men than I mitered such joints though. And that would be a solution to your problem. I�ll bet my friend William has made such a joint. Let�s ask him. William?

Failing all that, I�d be inclined to rabbet the whole bloody thing and nail in a molding. You wouldn�t do that for a dining table or a secretary, but if you are making a door, maybe that would be acceptable.

Sorry I couldn�t be more help.

Adam

Re: Molding on frame and panel doors

#4

Re: Molding on frame and panel doors

George Makowski

>Adam and all you folks,

Do you think that it would work to handle the outside of the frame as if I was shaping a raised panel? That is assemble the frame using mortice and tennon joints with all the outside profiles square. Then plow a shallow groove to define the inner edge of the exterior shape. Next use a bench or rabbet plane to run a long chamfer from the groove to the outside edge of the frame leaving the edge at the desired thickness.

George in AL

Re: Molding on frame and panel doors

#5

Re: Molding on frame and panel doors

Alan Hamilton

>George,

I'm not sure I understand your concerns. From what you wrote I think you're worried about planing a profile across the end grain of the stiles; and secondarily if you ought to use the usual assembly technique of leaving the stiles long to avoid splitting out the mortise. If those are your concerns, please read on; if not, stop now.

I've made things exactly like your door--with a profile running all the way around the outside edges of a frame and panel. I'm not certain what I did was the best or easiest way to do this, but it worked fine for me.

I left the stiles long until after everything was glued up, and then trimmed the ends flush with the rails. I didn't cut the profile on anything until after everything was together and the stiles trimmed.

To lessen the time between sharpenings on my molding irons, I used my rabbet plane to cur as much of the profile as I could (which wasn't much). I also used its nickers to score the edge of the molding profile across the ends of the stiles.

I didn't find planing the profile nearly as difficult as I thought it was going to be. I sharpened the irons to as keen an edge as my limited abilities allowed, and I set the plane to take a very fine cut. I planed the edges in the same order as I would a raised panel: I began on one of the rails and then worked clockwise around the frame. As you know, that helps reduce tear out on the end-grain.

The only other precaution I took was to clamp a piece of scrap, the same thickness as the frame, to the stiles so the end of the scrap piece was even with the end of the stile. Of course I did this only on the end of the far stile as I was planing the rail. This too, as you know, virtually eliminates tear out.

If my rememberer is in working order today, I re-sharpened the molding iron just before I began and once more before the second rail and two stile ends. I'm not certain this was necessary, but it did no harm.

BTW, I did this with one of my combination planes, so there was no setting a tight mouth. If I had used molding planes I would naturally want to use those with very tight mouths. Even so, it all went well. There were very few spots that needed TLC after the profile was planed. If I had to do it again, I'd do it the same way.

Alan the Long-Winded

Re: Molding on frame and panel doors

#6

Re: Molding on frame and panel doors

George Makowski

>Alan, It is not long winded if you explain well as you did. Yes, your solution is just what I have been coming to think is needed. Build the entire door first and then work the profile on the outside edge. I will give it a practice run on a trial frame assembly to get my hand in first, but I think it will work fine. It will be somewhat simplified for me because the profile I need is an easy step down and long flat angle, like the edge of a raised panel mimiced on the outside edge of the frame. I will use my Stanley 45 to plow in the step and then my bench planes and wooden rabbet plane to work the long slope.

Thanks for everyone's help!

George in AL