Re: Molding on frame and panel doors
Alan Hamilton
>George,
I'm not sure I understand your concerns. From what you wrote I think you're worried about planing a profile across the end grain of the stiles; and secondarily if you ought to use the usual assembly technique of leaving the stiles long to avoid splitting out the mortise. If those are your concerns, please read on; if not, stop now.
I've made things exactly like your door--with a profile running all the way around the outside edges of a frame and panel. I'm not certain what I did was the best or easiest way to do this, but it worked fine for me.
I left the stiles long until after everything was glued up, and then trimmed the ends flush with the rails. I didn't cut the profile on anything until after everything was together and the stiles trimmed.
To lessen the time between sharpenings on my molding irons, I used my rabbet plane to cur as much of the profile as I could (which wasn't much). I also used its nickers to score the edge of the molding profile across the ends of the stiles.
I didn't find planing the profile nearly as difficult as I thought it was going to be. I sharpened the irons to as keen an edge as my limited abilities allowed, and I set the plane to take a very fine cut. I planed the edges in the same order as I would a raised panel: I began on one of the rails and then worked clockwise around the frame. As you know, that helps reduce tear out on the end-grain.
The only other precaution I took was to clamp a piece of scrap, the same thickness as the frame, to the stiles so the end of the scrap piece was even with the end of the stile. Of course I did this only on the end of the far stile as I was planing the rail. This too, as you know, virtually eliminates tear out.
If my rememberer is in working order today, I re-sharpened the molding iron just before I began and once more before the second rail and two stile ends. I'm not certain this was necessary, but it did no harm.
BTW, I did this with one of my combination planes, so there was no setting a tight mouth. If I had used molding planes I would naturally want to use those with very tight mouths. Even so, it all went well. There were very few spots that needed TLC after the profile was planed. If I had to do it again, I'd do it the same way.
Alan the Long-Winded