Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Critique of Ebay Infill *PICS* *LINK*

Posts

Critique of Ebay Infill *PICS* *LINK*

#1

Critique of Ebay Infill *PICS* *LINK*

WoodburnBob

>Some of you have said you think about picking up an infill to try out. You are justifiably put off by the prices, among other things. I thought I'd comment on one that just finished on Ebay for $280. I hope those more qualified than me will pipe in to correct my errors and add their perspective and estimates. (Click the link at the end to see the entire auction.)

At a glance, I'd say this was a Mathieson in good shape. The clues are the head of the lever cap screw, the sillouette of the tote/handle and the overall geometry.



The bun, of course, has been trimmed and finish up in order to clean up broken and splintered wood. That could be what happened to the rear infill, which is not quite characteristic of Mathiesons I've seen. Its height seems lowered and rounded over.

The handle sure looks original and undamaged to me, even though the ad copy indicates the spur was broken and repaired expertly. It would be hard to imagine the plane suffering lots of bun damage and having the spur on the handle go untouched for a century or so.



This view of the head of the lever cap says Mathieson to me. No doubt the subcontractor who made these might have...probably did...sell these to others. And there's no reason someone couldn't copy this. The "S A" stamped in the lever cap would be the puzzle. I'd guess this is one of the many Mathiesons that weren't stamped (that's what I've read), and these letters were put in either by a small retailer or an owner.


In sum then I think this is a potentially great infill user at a bargain price simply because it is unsigned (no surviving Mathieson mark, 'though there may well have been one at some time stamped fainted into the front of the bun).

The seller seems as reputable as anyone could be and I've seen his auctions often over the years. (I don't recall ever buying from him and have never met him, but did see a display from his Bedrock collection at a tool meeting a few years ago). If I was buying another infill this summer, I would have sniped this one...or at least tried.


Ebay page

Re: Critique of Ebay Infill *PICS* *LINK*

#2

Re: Critique of Ebay Infill *PICS*

joel

>My reaction is that this is a worn out infill , possibly by mathison (the handle is distinctly mathison) but probably not, which has sustained a lot of damage in the past 120 year or so years. THe handle has what looks like some small cracks in it - not unusual for an open handle design. THe bun is as you say trimmed, the lever cap screw is too high - which suggests a less experienced builder, and it's a v thread not square.

I would say this was craftsman built - and the bun might even be original.

At some point the plane was taken apart.

the level of pitting suggests lots of wear.

I think the plane sold for about what it was worth and if one wanted an infill to seriously recondition maybe but IMHO the chances it would work as well as a 70 year younger rosewood Norris in g+ shape is small.

Re: Critique of Ebay Infill *PICS* *LINK*

#3

Re: Critique of Ebay Infill *PICS*

joel

>On second thought Craftsman built planes are rarely dovetailed so I would say this is a heavily reworked profressionally made plane - however the performace comments I think still stand.

Re: Critique of Ebay Infill *PICS* *LINK*

#4

Performance of Reconditioned Planes

Steve Elliott

>After buying and working on a number of older infill planes, my opinion of this one is that it's a good candidate for thorough tuning, and could perform as well as a Spiers, Norris or Mathieson. At the auction price, it's less expensive than a Lie-Nielsen 4-1/2. By the time it's all tuned (including a replacement for the tapered blade it was sold with) it might be a little more than the L-N, but in the same ballpark.

My favorite planes have turned out to be the ones that needed the most work. They're favorites because they work as well as the ones that are less worn or damaged and I don't have to worry about decreasing their collector value by modifying or using them. I just sold the most valuable collector plane I owned because after studying it, there wasn't anything I could do with it except look because sharpening its original blade or lapping its sole would decrease its value on the collector market.

The high angle of the lever cap of the ebay plane will be reduced by use of a thicker blade, which might be necessary anyway to close up the mouth after the sole is lapped. And a new cap iron out of thicker stock could be used to reduce the angle even more if needed. Any open-handled plane of a certain age will need repair to the base of the handle, and I'm more willing to do repair to a plane with little collector value.

Anyone buying an older infill plane should be aware that the high performance level comes after considerable tuning. I happen to enjoy the tuning part at least as much as using the plane afterwards, but tuning isn't really woodworking. It involves a lot of metal work.

An older, possibly craftsman-made plane like this one might be a good purchase for someone who's not sure about getting an infill plane. Even after the plane has been worked on, it most likely will go for about the same amount the next time it's sold.

Re: Critique of Ebay Infill *PICS* *LINK*

#5

Re: Critique of Ebay Infill *PICS*

Cameron

>Nice user plane. Why do you say the plane has been taken apart at some stage, Joel?

Re: Critique of Ebay Infill *PICS* *LINK*

#6

Re: Critique of Ebay Infill *PICS*

joel

>look at the rivets and the rear infill. It just doesn't feel right to me. the lever cap screw is of course wrong which suggests to me that the lever cap was replaced. A some point in it's past the front bun along with a lot of the rest of the plane was worked over.

Re: Critique of Ebay Infill *PICS* *LINK*

#7

Re: Critique of Ebay Infill *PICS*

Cameron

>Perhaps. The rear of the plane does look like the infill has "swelled" but one or two of the rivets look tight enough. The cap rivet seems a little too far back as well. Bun definitely looks reworked, I agree.

Love that spur though!