Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

Posts

Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

#1

Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

WoodburnBob

>You thought I was done. So did I. Thought I'd get back on track. Re-honed the blade. Cinched down the lever cap. Inserted the blade/cutter assembly. Felt a little wobble/rock on the bed. Ignored it. Started planing. Shit! Put my thinking cap back on...which you can see is more dangerous than it seems.

Here are new results. Friday's results. Saturday's results may differ.

Recall I accepted the premise the iron was flat. Surface plates tell no lies. Correct?

I checked flatness with the cap iron off!. Cinched down, it turns out everything is a completely different story. Clamping on the cap iron puts a 0.010" (at least) bend in the iron. If there were no twist, so what. It simply lifts the middle section of the iron off the bed...where I presumed my dreaded mound/lump/bump was anyway. It does sort of negate the idea that infills are superior because the iron is clamped tight to vibration dampening rosewood, though...doesn't it.


So if I remove the cap iron, I can't pass even a 0.0015" feeler gauge between my trusty Starrett straight edge and the blade.


This doesn't yet explain the original rock/wobble of iron on bed, you say. Here's a nice V-block. Very accurate.


I set the iron (no cap iron) on the V-block and it's a perfect mating. No rock. No wobble.


I set the iron on it with cap iron tightened and what do you know. The assembly has the same rock/wobble as putting the assembly on the infill bed. In fact, I can measure it with the feeler gauge. What do you know, 0.010".


So putting the cap iron on does two things: bends the iron and puts a twist in it. I occurred to me to inspect the cap iron (he says, knowing full well the audience is way ahead of him). Yup, there's that 0.010" twist again.


Yup. There it is again.


Well, I do remember filing and sanding that hook. Trouble is I must have totally f**ked it up originally and was completely oblivious to what I'd done.


Yup, no rock or wobble here. The cap iron is flat enough.


Fixing things...fixing things should be a remarkable statement coming from my lips...anyway...trying to undo my damage to this cap iron doesn't immediately strike me as a trivial operation and I'm going to think about it a little. Yes, I understand the danger.

It is humbling to think that I could delude myself for some many hours in a row and then publish it on the internet as if I were the great infill tuner from the mount. If anyone is in any doubt that I am actually the local court jester, this should set you straight.

Re: Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

#2

Re: Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

David Miller from Iowa

>Good post, again. Except a bit too much self deprecation. You're doing a great job.

Re: Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

#3

Weird...

Jonathan Peck - N.Y.

>...I forgot who said it, but it has also been my experience...it would seem at times that when a plane won't perform, the performance problem can been traced back to the chipbreaker. I can remember in days past jumping in one foot first (the other being in my mouth at the time) into the LAS debate with Lyn using the lack of a chipbreaker as a weakness in the LAS/bevel up design. Hmmmm..think Lyns response was something in the don't need one genre

I've been kind of curious about this having found that sometimes old stanley blades come bent creating a gap on the frog that you don't need a feeler gage to see. Having gone to the trouble of straightening said bent irons, and then rechecking after the chipbreaker has been tightened only produces the same flex I've just removed. Back off the screw only results in a chipbreaker that moves when I adjust the irons depth, and the dance goes on - too tight...too loose...too..uhh well you get my point.

Anyways, I've really enjoyed your articles and I'm still drooling over your infill with the palm grip..or was it that huge chunk of mahogony (nice driveby)

-Jonathan

Re: Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

#4

Re: Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

William Duffield on the Cohansey

>I like your attitude.

Re: Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

#5

Chipbreaker Problems & Fixes

Steve Elliott

>Well, Bob, we've done it again: our interests and observations have brought us to the same issues. When I started tuning planes I noticed that the chipbreakers would almost always lift the middle of the blade off the bed, so I started making my own chipbreakers that were practically flat, along the lines of the new Lie-Nielsen ones. Here's a scan of what they look like:




This solved the issue you raised of the blade being lifted off the bed by the chipbreaker. It introduced another problem, though, which is rust caused by water trapped between the chipbreaker and the blade. Although I was very careful in handling the blades, I would come back a month later, remove the chipbreaker, and discover matching dark spots on the blade and chipbreaker that must have come from perspiration trapped between them. I've since modified the chipbreaker in the picture so that the relieved area ground into it near the working edge extends back almost to the screw hole. It still solves the lifting problem and doesn't cause rust on the important part of the blade back.

I've also put together a jig to test how chipbreakers affect the bedding of blades in infill planes. Here's what it looks like:




No, I didn't make the lever cap. (I wish I was that good. My metalworking is done with a drill press, hack saw, and files.)

The good part of all this is that the problems are easier to fix if they're caused by the chipbreaker rather than the plane. Of course the plane may need work too, but I feel a lot better modifying a chipbreaker than a Norris.

Re: Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

#6

Re: Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

Dave Anderson Chester,NH

>Hey Bob- BACK OFF and don't be so hard on yourself. Everyone one of us here has been self-deluded many times. Often it's just a case of seeing what you expect to see. I won't even try to count the number of times I've been positively, absolutely , 100% guaranteed sure of something and then found out I was dead wrong. Your posts are still interesting, well written, and very useful.

Re: Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

#7

Re: Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>Not an attempt to throw oil on the fire...but I have read that premium infills are set up with the mouth so tight the iron cannot be slid through the mouth until the levercap is tightened to bow the blade and pull the iron away from the mouth. Flat blades...Perfect bedding...Possibly unobtainable. Unless your name is Stephen Thomas.JR

Re: Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

#8

see Brents post below

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>I hadn't read it until after I had posted.JR

Re: Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

#9

Yes, so what does it all mean?

WoodburnBob

>I can accept the idea that the level cap might be used to open and close the mouth a little...sometimes...within the range of a mouth of say 0.005 to 0.015...as others suggest...whether by design or serendipity...because the cap iron bends the cutting iron.

But, Steve, you've fabricated a cap iron to negate that. So why do we even need a cap iron? (I subscribe to Larry Clark's formulation that actual chip-breaking by a chip-breaker is fantasy.)

When I take the cap iron off the unhandled Norris I show in my recent folly, I get major chatter. Predictably. Nothing is clamping the end of the iron down on the metal part of the bed. Doesn't this mean that the primary function of the cap iron is to serve as a kind of lever arm or extension to transfer clamping force from the leading edge of the lever cap to a line just above the very bottom of the bed? If so, why shouldn't your flat cap iron be purely superfluous...the equivalent of no cap iron? I think I just made myself dizzy.

Re: Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

#10

Chipbreaker Function

Steve Elliott

>I don't accept the idea that the mouth dimension of an infill plane can be significantly regulated by changing the pressure on the lever cap. I've watched what happens to the sole of an infill plane as the pressure on the lever cap is changed, and there is noticeable distortion. I lap the soles of my planes with a blade in place and my usual amount of pressure on the lever cap to avoid problems due to this distortion. Also, if you do the math about how much the mouth dimension would change if the middle of the blade is lifted off the bed by .010" you'll find that it's not enough to be considered a significant adjustment.

So why do I make a cap iron that is almost flat? It's because I believe one of the factors that makes any plane perform well is a firmly clamped blade that won't chatter. The thicker blade of an infill plane is less likely to chatter in the first place, but if I can make it rest firmly on the wooden part of the bed, so much the better. In Bailey style planes, this problem was addressed by two essentially equivalent developments: the Stay-Set chipbreaker by Record that flexes at the joint between its two parts, and the Millers Falls lever cap that puts pressure on the chipbreaker in two places. Both of these designs help overcome the tendency to chatter that results from the combination of a thin blade and the modest clamping pressure of the Bailey design.

Does an infill plane with its blade lifted up off the bed by the cap iron ever chatter? I haven't noticed it with any of my planes, but I mostly plane using the cap irons I made.

Another advantage of the more firmly bedded blade is that there is much less sponginess when the lever cap is tightened. This makes it easier to adjust the blade by tapping. My cap irons are also easier to keep in position as the cap iron screw is tightened.

As for whether a cap iron actually breaks the shaving as it forms in a way that improves the surface on the wood, I doubt it. But both the Japanese and the German traditions are to put a tiny flat on the face of the cap iron that is intended to do exactly that. Both of these cultures have a strong tradition of hand tool use, and I'm not willing to dismiss this idea without doing some careful work to test it.

The most important function of the cap iron, in my opinion, is to transfer force from the lever cap to just behind the cutting edge of the blade. This pre-tensions the blade and holds it down firmly where it counts the most.

Re: Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

#11

A wonderful post!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Bob

I find all your posts educational and enjoyable. This has been the best of all. When we examine our results, not simply accepting them at face value, looking for the dynamic interaction that lies beneath and explains the outward appearance - there begins true knowledge.

I'm learning all the time from these discussions.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

#12

Ditto!!!

Frank Mutchler in Colorado Springs

>

Re: Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

#13

Nice info...more justification for wedged Woodies!

Tim of San Leandro

>

Re: Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

#14

Re: A wonderful post!

Todd O. Cronkhite Native of Maine

>Got to agree, this really is holding my attention as well. Quite interesting. Personally, I enjoy your writing style as it shadows mine a bit. While some folks call it self-deprecating, I call it humor. I don't mind one bit telling a story on myself. I'll be the first to say, "Hey, wanna hear about my latest buffonery"? I figure that I might as well laugh at myself as crying or getting mad has never solved anything.

Keep on keeping on Bob, I wish you the success that you'll eventually get, tho it may cost you a few nights sleep. and it'll be a grand story when it's all finished. How I took this from Bad to Worse, to Excellent in only 15000 enjoyable hours of blood, sweat and laughter.

Todd O.

Re: Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

#15

Re: Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

paul womack

>Bob speaks of the effect of a cap-iron...

If there were no twist, so what. It simply lifts the middle section of the iron off the bed...where I presumed my dreaded mound/lump/bump was anyway. It does sort of negate the idea that infills are superior because the iron is clamped tight to vibration dampening rosewood, though...doesn't it.

Yes - it can be very instructive to remove the frog from a Bailey plane, and clamp the blade to it in the normal way.

Then marvel at the long expanse of unsupported blade...

This explains why the old pad at the TOP of the bed to open the mouth trick doesn't cause chatter. The trick doesn't (greatly) decrease bedding.

OTOH, AFAIK a fully (smoke/ink) fitted blade in a Japanese style plane IS fully bedded.

And, back on the "experiment in community" that was Badger pond, some (who's name escapes me) made an ultra thick, ultra flat cap-iron as an experiment.

BugBear

Re: Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

#16

Function

Lyn J. Mangiameli

>As I see experience it, chip breakers only function as such when making rank cuts on softwoods. I think it does have chip breaking and shaving directing application for carpentry, but virtually none for the fine smoothing of hardwoods.

Re: Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

#17

Re: Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

Brent

>Bob

You've done some good measurements here, but I am not sure they are the measurements that really count. In particular, does it matter that the blade is flat, out of the plane. Does it matter if the blade and cap iron are flat, out of the plane?

If there were serious problems (one or the other looked like a pretzel), the answer might be yes. With the small problems you have (not detectable without shims and a flat surface), I think the answer is no. Usually, the forces provided by the screw cap (can't really call this a lever cap, can we) are easily enough to flatten the two against the bed. If this is not happening, then there is a problem with the bedding.

Bailey planes work and they only bed the iron at the bottom and top of the frog. If your plane does this then it should work as well.

Is this true with your plane? With it set for use, can you push a shim under the iron from below? Can you push a shim under the iron from above? I suspect one of these is the case.

OR

There is one other possibility. Friction between the iron and the bed resist motion of the iron along the face of the bed. If you have smoothed the iron and bed so much that there is no longer sufficient friction, the iron might be moving along the bed. The chattering results when the blade slides up the bed, then is pushed back down by the screw cap acting against the bend in the cap iron. This point of contact is the only thing keeping the iron from sliding up.

When you put the abrasive paper in you stopped this motion and cured the problem.

Now that sounds like it might be the answer.

Perhaps you just over tuned your iron?

Brent

Re: Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

#18

Re: Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

WoodburnBob

>Thanks for your interest and help, Brent. You'll be happy to know I was able to carefully file and grind the cap iron in a way that it no longer wobbled or rocked on a flat surface. Tightening down the cap iron on the blade, the cutter no longer had gaps anywhere along the bed. It no longer wobbled or rocked on the bed. As a consequence, the plane finally performed well...and now consistently. The fundamental lesson I learned was that a poorly configured cap iron can put a performance damaging twist in even a thick 3/16" steel plane blade...a twist that cannot necessarily be counterbalanced by lever cap/screw cap forces against a flat bed, a twist that can erroneously imply that the bed is not flat when in fact it is.

In a way my post was mostly a tongue in cheek illustration that appearances are often deceiving...at least to me. I'm not proud that it had to be such an arduous and confusing process but I hoped some who read the forum got something out of the problem solving process...other than a belly laugh.

Re: Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

#19

Re: Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

Dan Donaldson

>Never a belly laugh for something like this. I enjoyed the whole thread. When you have something like this, sometimes the only way to fix it is to make some guesses and try them. Sometimes they are wrong, or only a part of the problem, but it looked to me like you analyzed as much as you could and then tried stuff, then made other changes in your approach depending on what happened.

I have done quite a bit of work on manufacturing process improvements in a plant. We did the same thing. Analyze the problem, make some guesses at root cause and then try different fixes and see what happens. Sometimes it gets worse, sometimes better, and sometimes gets totally fixed.

I think that your method was an excellent example of seeing a problem and fixing it.

Re: Show and Tell -- Revisited *More PICS*

#20

Re: Chipbreaker Function

Brent

>Steve wrote:

"if you do the math about how much the mouth dimension would change if the middle of the blade is lifted off the bed by .010" you'll find that it's not enough to be considered a significant adjustment."

I have an old infill with a Marples iron, 0.176" thick at the base of the bevel, bevel length 0.425", bevel angle less than 25 degrees (as it came, owners of old infill often seem to have ground their blades with very small angles, using them only for the last few finishing strokes perhaps). Thus the iron extends 0.387" past the base of the bevel (measured along the back).

The bed is 4.75". A rise in the iron of 0.01" half way up the bed is a rotation about the base of the bevel that produces a drop at the edge of 0.0016".

Now, that does not seem like a lot, but when you are trying to take 0.001" shavings, it makes all the difference.

The effect is more pronounced on other planes. I have an old infill panel plane, the plane in which I first noticed this effect. I can see the blade move when I tighten the screw. That plane has slightly different geometry and gets a much large bow in the blade.

Brent