Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Marples Blue Chip Chisel Performance

Posts

Marples Blue Chip Chisel Performance

#1

Marples Blue Chip Chisel Performance

Glenn

>I am just now getting to where I can put a decent edge on a chisel and plane blade. They will shave the hair off my arm but they do not stay sharp long.

I was cutting some dovetails with two full pins and two half pins in 5/8" thick by 4-1/2" wide Popular. I remove most of the waste with a coping saw and then remove the rest of the waste with a chisel. I have noticed I can only chop out the waste for the tails and then have to re-sharpen the chisel before I can cut out the pins. I really need to stop and re-sharpen before I complete the tails but...

Anyway I was wondering how long I should be able to go between sharpening with these chisels. I know this depends on many factors but I am refering to the above mentions scenario in Popular. I am making drawers. Should I be able to get though the entire drawer before having to re-sharpen? I am trying to figure out if my sharpening skills are not as keen as I think they are or if something else is a play here.

I bought the chisels as a set of four, 1/4" 1/2" 3/4" 1", from Lowes. I then purchased a seperate 3/8" chisel from Woodcraft. The 3/8" was much easier to prepare, flatten the back, and seems to stay sharper longer.

Thanks for any feedback

Re: Marples Blue Chip Chisel Performance

#2

Re: Marples Blue Chip Chisel Performance

Alan Bierbaum

>Like most products; quality can vary between batches. I have blue chips that last through a set of several drawers (maple and poplar) without needing to be sharpened. I chop all waste (no coping saw use). I also sharpen at 30 degrees for choping use.

Re: Marples Blue Chip Chisel Performance

#3

Re: Marples Blue Chip Chisel Performance

Alan Hamilton

>Glenn,

I think you should be getting more mileage on your Blue Chips. There are a few things that might be causing your trouble.

You don't say what angle you use on the bevel, and that can affect how long the edge will last. A low bevel angle will not remain sharp as long as a steep bevel, but the "correct" angle depends on what kind of chisel you are sharpening. The bevel angle paring chisel, for example, is usually around twenty-five degrees; but the bevel on a rougher-duty chisel, such as a mortising chisel, should be at least thirty degrees and thirty-five degrees is more usual.

For an ordinary bench chisel, like your Marples Blue Chips, around thirty degrees, plus or minus, is generally preferred--but is by no means universally used. On my bench chisels I put on a bevel angle of about twenty-five degrees or so. When it dulls I put on a micro-bevel of five degrees.

As you said, the problem may be in your sharpening. I've never much cared for the "shaving arm hair" test. When I'm shaving the hair off my face, a pretty dull razor will still cut my whiskers.

A better test is to try to cut a thin shaving--not dust--off your poplar's end grain--or the end grain of just about any other scrap you have around. Your tools are reasonably sharp if they can produce end-grain shavings.

Another test is the "Newton" test. The sharpest possible edge is the meeting of the flat planes of the back and the bevel where they narrow way down until there is nothing between them. So if you hold up an edge with the light behind you, a truly sharp edge won't reflect anything: a truly sharp edge will look like an extremely thin, black line. If you see any white at all, either a very narrow white line or a line of white dots, your edge is not sharp.

There's nothing like using a really sharp tool to learn what really sharp tools can do and how long they will last. Once you've gotten even one tool REALLY sharp you'll know about your others' edges.

I hope some of this overly-long note is of some help.

Alan

Re: Marples Blue Chip Chisel Performance

#4

Re: Marples Blue Chip Chisel Performance

Glenn

>I am following David Charlesworth sharpening method descrived in FWW No. 169. He says to grind at 23 degree, hone at 27 degrees on an 800 grit stone, and put a secondary bevel of 30 degrees using an 8000 grit stone. I will try the end grain shavings test as I am starting to sport the "patchy arm hair" look:) My LV low angle block plane will take a fine shaving on the Popular end grain using the same sharpening method though I do use different angels.

Re: Marples Blue Chip Chisel Performance

#5

Steve Kubien

Re: Marples Blue Chip Chisel Performance

Steve Kubien

>Hi Glenn,

I used to have the saem problem with my Blue Chips. Several of the knowledgeable people on this forum suggested a primary bevel of almost 30 degrees and followed by a SLIGHT secondary bevel (another degree or three). This greatly improved their usefulness on softer species like poplar, pine etc.

If you think the performance is below par on poplar, try something like teak. Teak will cause them to roll their edge just by looking at them! DAMHIKT

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario

Re: Marples Blue Chip Chisel Performance

#6

Re: Marples Blue Chip Chisel Performance

Frank Mutchler in Colorado Springs

>Glen, I use my Marples for on-the-job minor adjustments when installing/fitting kitchen cabinets and infrequently in the shop. My set doesn't keep an edge very long but as has been pointed out the steel in mine may well be of lower quality than that of someone else's.

OTOH, my Bracht chisels seem to hold an edge forever....even when I'm chopping hard maple. They are of German origin (from ebay) and I don't know anything about them except that the set I have is a real keeper. If you only have the Blue Chips you may want to keep an eye on ebay for a different set or individual chisels that will serve you better than what you have.

Re: Marples Blue Chip Chisel Performance

#7

Re: Marples Blue Chip Chisel Performance

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>In my experience, there's a reason they call them Blue CHIPS. I bought a set - same chisel, ash handles - back when a set of five was $19.95 on sale, and they chip out with great enthusiasm at the slightest attempt to make them work.

On the other hand, my $1 Pexto chisels will go what seems months between sharpenings.

Re: Marples Blue Chip Chisel Performance

#8

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Marples Blue Chip Chisel Performance

Jim in Burlington Ontario

>Everyone I have ever met has a set. I use mine for house reno work that way no tears are shed when you run into a nail or knot.

Re: Marples Blue Chip Chisel Performance

#9

Re: Marples Blue Chip Chisel Performance

Tony Z.

>I had a bad experience with the "shaving arm hair" test: chisel readily shaved the hair (trust me--I'm a heavily-haired Italian), but immediately I had appear an enormous number of little red spots appear! Somehow gave myself hundres of little, bleding pinhole sized cuts!

Re: Marples Blue Chip Chisel Performance

#10

Re: Marples Blue Chip Chisel Performance

Alan Hamilton

>Glenn 23 27 30

I don't understand what is meant by "grind at twenty-three degrees, hone at twenty-seven degrees and micro-bevel at thirty degrees." (I hope I got that clearly enough.)

Surely Charlesworth is not advocating having three different angles on the bevel! I have both Charlesworth's books, but I don't remember reading anything like that.

It would be much simpler to use just two angles: a "grind" angle, and a steeper micro-bevel. IMHO the aim should be to get the actual cutting edge somewhere around thirty degrees. I am not a fanatic about such things, and I use whatever gets me there with the least trouble and bother.

Alan

Re: Marples Blue Chip Chisel Performance

#11

A few thoughts...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>I have and use a set my Blue chips all the time. I grind the blades to 30 deg. and hone at 32-35 deg.

I can get a set of drawers done and more with mine. Here's how, (taking all concedertations iabout bacth to batch quality etc.)

Strop, Strop, Strop. I use a peice of double tempered masionite but any flat hardwood would work (mdf comes to mind as a cheap source). Cover it with thew green buffing compound or a green crayon works well too. Now every 10 or cuts just hit the strop a few times. Using this method. I've realy cut down on my sharpening time. This seems to work well with Japanese chisles as well as western chisels.

Re: Marples Blue Chip Chisel Performance

#12

You forgot to use shaving cream.

Don Thompson, Cutler Ridge, Florida

>