Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Lie-Nielsen Chisels.

Posts

Lie-Nielsen Chisels.

#1

Lie-Nielsen Chisels.

Ray DuBose, Memphis TN

>Hey all,

Has anyone out there gotten their hands on a Set of Lie-Nielsen Chisels? I was thinking about getting a set. I've got a handful of Japanese Chisels both white and blue steel and love them but they chip pretty easy. Any comments on them? Not much in the Archives other than "If you have the money you might want to look at them"

Thanks for any info.

Ray

Re: Lie-Nielsen Chisels.

#2

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

Re: Lie-Nielsen Chisels.

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

>Ray,

Popular Woodworking did a short review of them in a recent issue. A lot of other good articles in that one as well.

Mark

Re: Lie-Nielsen Chisels.

#3

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Lie-Nielsen Chisels.

Jack Guzman from Maine

>That question has been answered many times here. The general consensus is that they are good quality and nice to look at as well as use.The only negative response has been on the price.However at about $40 apiece I think they're well worth the cost.They do hold an edge well and are shaped good for dovetailing. I prefer them to two cherries for most work.The two cherries are better for delicate paring because of the lightness. As usual Lie-Nielsen has created another fine tool.Now if only LV would make some chisels---Jack

Re: Lie-Nielsen Chisels.

#4

Re: Lie-Nielsen Chisels.

Mick Foley

>I've got a set.

They're the best chisels I've ever used. However, my expience is limited to a set of the Noogidat (spelling??) and a set of the yellow and black ones LV sells (or used to sell). The LN's blow them both away. They seem to stay sharp for a long, long time and the balance (for me) is perfect.

Mick

Re: Lie-Nielsen Chisels.

#5

More data

Christopher Schwarz

>They are my favorite chisel.

In the current issue of Fine Tool Journal I've got an article that is the expanded version of the test I did for Popular Woodworking. It's a three-page article that explains how I compared the LNs to a variety of new and vintage chisels.

But here's the bottom line. They are the most comfortable and well-finished chisel out there. And they hold an edge as long as any Japanese chisel, vintage chisel or handmade Western chisel (Barr) in my test.

If you want to gripe about price then don't buy them. If you want the best, save your money and pull the trigger. I actually think they are an excellent value.

Sorry to write and run, but I'm off to IWF in Atlanta.

Chris

Re: Lie-Nielsen Chisels.

#6

Re: Lie-Nielsen Chisels.

Tony - Memphis

>Howdy neighbor. My wonderful wifey got me a set with the rosewood handles for my birthday - wonderful woman! Anyway, I really like them. I'm not a neander by any stretch, so take that into consideration of my assesment. I polished the backs on my Nortons and sharpened them up (I have the set of Nortons up through 8000 I think it is). They sharpened up real nice and look really nice hangin on the cherry holder I made for the wall. Haven't put them through any real tough work (I don't do much hands only work), but so far, so good. I'm not very picky, but they feel good in my hands. Anyway, I'm glad she got them for me.

Tony

Re: Lie-Nielsen Chisels.

#7

Re: Lie-Nielsen Chisels.

John Richards

>They are great. Amazingly balanced and very well machined with crisp edges. I too have the rosewood handles. They are pretty to look at and a pure pleasure to use.

Thanks,

John

Re: Lie-Nielsen Chisels.

#8

Re: Lie-Nielsen Chisels.

Ray DuBose, Memphis TN

>Well I just got paid today so I guess I'll go buy me a set. You all can quit twisting my arm now :)

Ray