Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

what is best cutting gauge for dovetails

Posts

what is best cutting gauge for dovetails

#1

what is best cutting gauge for dovetails

davidewhiting

>Looking for something with a better cut than my Veritas wheel for making hand cut dovetails and other lines

Re: what is best cutting gauge for dovetails

#2

Re: what is best cutting gauge for dovetails

William R. Duffield on the Cohansey

>I would not recommend using a cutting gauge for dovetails, because it cuts too deeply, and therefore weakens the tail at what is already it's narrowest, weakest point. Use a dull marking gauge, or better yet a gauge that holds a pencil or a ball point pen.

Re: what is best cutting gauge for dovetails

#3

Wow.

Tim of San Leandro

>"I would not recommend using a cutting gauge for dovetails, because it cuts too deeply, and therefore weakens the tail at what is already it's narrowest, weakest point."

You've got the world's sharpest, toughest and deepest cutting gauge there is and/or you use a lot 1/16 inch thick stock....hmmmmmm :- ).

I use a "kebiki" cutting gauge. It is essentially like a western mortise gauge but this uses a beveled knife rather than a pin. One really nice advantage to the kebiki is how easy it is to set the knife to match the thickness of the stock. I lay the stock down on a flat surface. Lay the fence on the stock and let the knife drop. Voila! Gauge is set. I normally add a paper shim's thickness as well with my gauge to get a more accurate setting..


img

Re: what is best cutting gauge for dovetails

#4

Re: what is best cutting gauge for dovetails

Alan Hamilton

>David,

Unlike Sir William, I don't see a problem with using a cutting gauge or a knife to score the bottoms of pins or tails. Certainly a scored line deeper than you can get with a marking gauge is useful to obtain a good registration line for your chisel. Sir William is right, though, that for aesthetic reasons--and perhaps for strength reasons--it's probably better to avoid scoring a deep line anywhere you're not going to remove wood. But with all that said...

So far as I know, the Lee Valley wheel-gadget is a marking gauge, not a cutting gauge, for clearly marking a line, and not to deeply cut a line.

For your purpose you should look for a proper cutting gauge. They're not hard to come by--or, anticipating the tool-makers verses too users around here--you can whip one out pretty quickly. They look exactly like an old-fashioned "pin" marking gauge, except a cutting gauge has a knife, not a pin.

I haven't been in the market for a cutting or marking gauge for decades, so it's probable they have undergone some "improvements" and some changes. Surely someone is now making a cutting gauge with a wheel instead of a knife, or makes a cutting gauge in some other configuration. If you have a local wood workers' store you can go in and try them, or try to get some help from an employee who almost certainly won't know half as much as you. If you shop in catalogs...you're on your own...or...you can always use your wheel marker or pin marker to get a real shallow score and then use a marking knife, or the like, to deepen it.

Alan

Re: what is best cutting gauge for dovetails

#5

Re: what is best cutting gauge for dovetails

deanj

>This may be a silly question, and forgive me if it is. But, did you sharpen the wheel in your LV gauge?

I use two shop fox LV knock offs (sorry Rob, I promise I'll order another plane to make up for it). One bevel toward fence, one bevel away from fence, depending on what I am marking and where I want the "flat" to be. But, the cutting wheels had to be sharpened before they worked well. Now they leave nice thin sharp lines....

Cheers!

Dean

Re: what is best cutting gauge for dovetails

#6

Re: what is best cutting gauge for dovetails *LINK*

Rossmoor Galoot

>I use a Starrett Scratch gauge I purchased from Joel at the Museum of Woodworking Tools. I like the square better than the wheel for marking dovetails because I can get better definition and more control by varying the angle of the corner when I'm scribing (if that makes sense).


img

Museum of Woodworking Tools

Re: what is best cutting gauge for dovetails

#7

Titemark!!!!!

Rob Cosman

>David, the best gauge I have ever owned is the titemark by Kevin Drake. I teach a fair bit and it is also the easiest to master. To avoid deep lines where you dont want them you simply roll the gauge between the tails, scoring only where the wood will be removed. I believe the sharper the better, not only will it give perfect registration for your chisel but it also helps give you a good starting shoulder when cutting off the half pins(read; edge of the tail board). His cutters come very sharp, the mirco adjust is well thought out and works like a charm, very precise, the tool has nice heft, very nice machining, the knurl is sharp, the set screws don't wobble in the tapped holes and thier heads are big enough to get a hold of, there are two set screws to tighten and hold the head in place. Kevin also makes mortise blades for his gauge so you can convert it to a very accurate mortise gauge. If you are in the US you can get one from Lie-Nielsen.

Rob, Lie-Nielsen Canada

Re: what is best cutting gauge for dovetails

#8

Re: what is best cutting gauge for dovetails *LINK*

Matt Woodworth

>I've used the veritas wheel gauge, a crown pin style gauge, and a japanese cutting gauge. For my money the japanese gauge is the way to go. It's cheap but that's not why I like it. I like it because I have an easy time controlling how deep the cut is and I like the big fence.

With the wheel style gauge I sometimes angle the cutter because the fence is too small. Sometimes I even follow the grain. The sharp cutter and large fence make the japanese style foolproof. I use this one.


http://www.japanwoodworker.com/product.asp?s=Japan

Re: what is best cutting gauge for dovetails

#9

Re: Wow.

William R. Duffield on the Cohansey

>Yeah, I cut dovetails in some rather thin stock, but not that thin. The minimum right angle joint I've found effective in 3 mil ply is a fillet of epoxy thickened with colloidal silica and glass cloth :^)

Rob has some valid advise on technique, etc. as well. It helps a lot if you can see what you are cutting, which is the case with either your Japanese gauge or a metal wheel gauge like the TiteMark and its immitators. I use an old fashioned English style gauge, and I can't see the blade for the beam, so I just score or mark the whole width of the boards. That's probably a bad idea.

If your gauge had a brass knurled thumbscrew instead of the wingnut, I think it would be much improved, but then I really hate wing nuts, because they often hurt my finger tips so much I can't feel what I'm working on afterwards. Ergonomically, they are a really bad idea. Whoever invented them should be made to sleep with several hundred of them, and several pairs of pliers, in his bed with him.

Your thickness gauging strategy is a good idea, but I don't see why would not work with either a metal wheel gauge or a traditional wooden beam gauge. In all cases, when you loosen the knob, won't the beam fall until the cutter meets the far face of the wood?

Re: what is best cutting gauge for dovetails

#10

Yes, you are right - technique works with most gau

Tim of San Leandro

>

Re: what is best cutting gauge for dovetails

#11

Re: what is best cutting gauge for dovetails

Chris Knight

>Rob beat me to it but I use the Titemark which is easily the best marking/cutting gauge I have used.

You can mark with it and with the optional wheel cut veneer quite happily too. I find the "marked" line quite enough to locate a chisel. For me, the ease of setting the gauge to precisely the right dimension makes it a hands down winner over any of the many other gauges I have tried.

Re: what is best cutting gauge for dovetails

#12

You`re so busted,Joel!

Bob Hackett

>Note the use of an apprentice in the pic at the top of the page(nice apron).You can no longer officially consider or sell these tools as being hand forged.

Please make the necessary adjustments to your site and inform the manufacturers in order to avoid further harassment.;^)

Mainely,Bob-Wondering if running the risk of having the cloth apron ignite is worth the risk of making the fashion statement,I`m a leather man myself.

Nothing better than forging a relationship with the opposite sex.Where can I find a woman like that?

Re: what is best cutting gauge for dovetails

#13

Re: You`re so busted,Joel!

joel

>While I usually never comment on a competitors site the picture is a young Nishiki and the woman is his wife.

Incidently the job of hammering was not only done by apprentices it was a formal job known as a "striker".

If you wish to find a woman like that I suggest trying to sell the job of striker as "exercise" and having a forge as "a home gym".

It's great for upper body strength and not to mention the togetherness of exercising with your spouse.

Re: what is best cutting gauge for dovetails

#14

Re: You`re so busted,Joel!

Bob Hackett

>If I remember correctly,the smith would direct the striker by use of a smaller hammer and wherever the smith hit the striker would hit the same spot with the same force.Can`t picture going thru life just doing that kind of job and never aspiring to be a smith but I suppose it takes all kinds of people to make a world.

I think the only way I could get my wife to help with forging would be if there was a chance of her being able to hit my fingers."You missed,try again honey!Gotta be faster if you want to catch me".

Figured you might not mind the reference to that other site.Besides,all those asian tools are the same aren`t they?Maybe Harrelson(sp) can answer for you next time.;^)

Mainely,Bob-Glad that Joel is such a good sport and knows a joke when he sees it(even if it`s not very funny).

Re: what is best cutting gauge for dovetails

#15

Re: Wow.

paul womack

>I use an old fashioned English style gauge, and I can't see the blade for the beam, so I just score or mark the whole width of the boards.

You might consider adopting one of David Charlesworth ideas. He started with the unusual Stanley "diagonal beam and egg shaped head" marking gauges (the model number of which escapes me).

These already have excellent ergonomics; the pin comes through the diagonal of the beam, and is thus quite visible. To render it even more visible Charleworth excavates a small "dip" where the pin leaves the beam, increasing visual clearance.

As a side issue, he regrinds and sharpens the pin, but since we're discussing cutting gauges, I won't bother with the details of that.

But his visibility ideas are just as applicable to a cutting gauge.

BTW, I eventually tamed my cutting gauge by making the bevel rather steep, limiting its penetration.

BugBear

Re: what is best cutting gauge for dovetails

#16

Re: Wow.

joel

>"I can't see the blade for the beam, so I just score or mark the whole width of the boards. "

Just tilt the gauge away from you, resting one corner of the bean on the work. with one corner of the beam on the work you can easily control the pressure to get anywhere from a thick line to a whisper thin line. and of course with it tilted away from you can trivially see what you are doing.

At the end of the board the corner of the beam on the work will exit first leaving you with no support - so don't go off the ends come around onto the ends.

Controlling the pressure makes all the difference and is why this style of gauge was always so popular.

Re: what is best cutting gauge for dovetails

#17

Re: what is best cutting gauge for dovetails

kees

>Wasn't that the type Rob Lee recommanded and will be selling at the end of the year?

kees