Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Get rid of tablesaw?

Posts

Get rid of tablesaw?

#1

Get rid of tablesaw?

Bob Rozaieski in Eastern PA

>Ok, I know there was a discussion about this at some point on this board but I can't seem to locate it in the archives or a current search. I have been contemplating selling my tablesaw as I seem to use it less and less and I only seem to have problems when it comes to setting it up, dust collection, etc. Some of the good points I can see are less noise, dust, a lot more shop space, and safer working (i fear what these things are capable of), not to mention some money for more hand tools (oh boy, oh boy, oh boy!). So I have been trying to think of a real convincing reason not to sell it and I can't seem to do so.

So I pose this question to everyone; is there any real convincing reason not to get rid of it. I am a hobbyist (sp?), I don't make any production runs, I have a good sized neanderbuddy which can rip long boards (albeit not perfectly straight) and a rip handsaw (less straight), I don't have a dado stack so I don't use the ts for joinery anyway and the ts needs a fence upgrade to really be at all acurate and repeatable. The only thing I can see this thing being useful for is cutting plywood, but even then, I need to cut it with circ saw outside first to get it to manageable sizes for my shop before working it on the ts. I could potentially just use the circ with a real good blade to final dimension my plywood stock if I choose to use ply at all (even though it would take a little longer).

So now that I've been so long winded, what do you think? Has anyone sold their ts or never owned one and how has it worked out? Have you missed it or really needed it for something? Thanks for listening and giving your opinion!

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#2

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

deanj

>I gave my TS away, leaving only by BS as my neanderbuddy. I have yet to regret it.

Go for it... :)

-Dean

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#3

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

Jonathan Kaplan (OR)

>I'm with Dean. I never owned one (but I do have a BS), and haven't missed it.

Lately I've been using a cheap disposible blade Japanese-style saw for plywood -- seems to work well, and it's faster even than digging out my circular saw, etc. :)

jk

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#4

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

Alan Hamilton

>Bob,

I sold my table saw twenty-something years ago and I have never regretted it.

I sold all my power tools except an old Craftsman three-wheel table-top band saw, and a power hand drill. I can't remember the last time I used the band saw; and I think a power hand drill shouldn't count. I don't have a pal with a table saw close by. I'm doing fine without one. My wood working takes more time to complete anything, but I'm enjoying it much more.

Alan

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#5

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

jg

>What kind of wood are you guys working? My WIFE bought a tablesaw because she thought I was going to have a coronary trying to rip a 6' length of 8/4 bubinga with a handsaw.

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#6

Dump it

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>Bob,

I have very few electric tools; compound miter saw, and woodlathe, are pretty much it for woodworking. Don't care for the compound mitersaw for fine work. But its okay for building decks, I guess. Sometimes I wish I had a bandsaw.

I've never owned or used a TS. And I've never wished for one.

There are a few electric tools that are worth their keep for fine woodworking. But the TS isn't one of them. Ripping is one of the easiest things to do. Several tools, electric and hand, can do it acceptably.

Have a look at a FWW article in "Tools and Shops" (a few years back) by Gary Rogokowski (spelling) entitled something like "5 essential woodworking tools and why the tablesaw isn't among them". As I recall, the list was: compound miter saw, band saw, jointer, planer, router.

I would argue that the jointer can easily be replaced by 2 hand planes (jointer and try plane). The thickness planer can be replaced, but not as easily, by two or three additional planes(smooth plane, fore/jack plane and possibly a scrub plane).

I think its likley you won't miss your TS. That said, I never work with plywood and I'm not sure what I would do if I had to.

Adam

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#7

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

Ernie Miller Topeka

>I have a table saw but it collects alot of dust and is a catch all. I will keep it because I do production runs of toys starting the first of next month every year. but for most things it isn't considered much. You won't get many LN's for a table saw though.

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#8

Wow

David Miller from Iowa

>And I thought I was a REAL neander. I'm keeping my table saw. I don't use it a lot for my woodworking, although I'm not as young as I used to be and I'm not ashamed to rip oak boards on it. But, for me, it is a must for the remodeling projects that I spend a lot of time on. I just put in a PVC privacy fence for LOML (she lives in a different house which is probably why we get along) and I ripped a huge number of vertical slats getting all the post spacings identical. I'm finishing off the attic and ripping a lot of thin trim pieces that would be very difficult to do with a saw (I suppose I could get out the 45 and put a slitter on). You get the picture. I'd be interested in knowing the ages of you robust fellows that eschew the table saw. I got mine about 20 years ago and did everything by hand before that, but now I'm not interested.

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#9

I'll be keeping mine, but

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>everyone's mileage varies. If yours is just gathering dust (amazing: mine gathers all kinds of stuff, a lot larger than dust bunnies), you don't need it. I use mine quite a bit and would hate to sell it.

If your saw is a Unisaw or similar-sized saw, contact me offline - I can provide directions to my house.

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#10

Re: Wow

Dean Burke - Yakima, WA

>I agree completely. If you're not going to do any remodelling, they are more disposable. Besides, it's not like you'll get anything much for yours. Selling it is almost more trouble than it's worth, unless you have a super high end and/or old machine.

Dean, 47 years old

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#11

don't do it

Will Tracey

>Would you deny yourself electric light as well? Time is valuable, and the time spent to rip material with a hand saw is just not worth it, especially if it is plywood, and the thought ripping modern sheet goods by hand is the epitome of irony. A square cut is still just a square cut regardless of how you get there. The tablesaw is a means to an end. It may make sense to sell the saw if you do not use it, but I might reconsider using it. A good tablesaw can be the heart of the workshop, without one everything takes longer. Most of the surfaces to be cut with a tablesaw are unseen, shoulders dados tenons ect. Why would you labor over these surfaces with hand saws? Save the handwork for the stuff that shows. You're not going to cut dovetails or smooth a tabletop with a table saw. A good handcut tennon will not be distinguishable from a properly machined one. Tight joints are tight joints.

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#12

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

brucerenfro

>I sold mine three years ago. I also sold a jointer, a drill press and a radial arm saw. I haven't missed any of them. It's like adding on a small room to your shop with the extra space. The only stationary tool left is a neanderbuddy. That stays. A decent quality plywood blade and a clamp-on straightedge for the circular saw does fine on plywood for house stuff when I can't get out of that. Bruce

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#13

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

Greg Sloop

>For me the big question would be...

What would I use for a bench then? :)

I can't imagine living without it and I'm only in my 30's.

But hey, you *would* get a lot more exercise that way! 8/4 Bubbinga? Ugh!

Cheers,

Greg

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#14

It makes a good fit-up table

Roy from Cincy

>I find that mine makes a good fit up/glue up table. I put a 24X48" sheet of MDF on top of it and that's where I assemble all my projects. It's nice and flat and sturdy.

I do like it for bulk ripping if I have a large project. Hand ripping is a chore.

Mine is a relatively inexpensive Delta contractor saw, so using it for a utility table isn't so financially insane.

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#15

Re: Depends on your motivations

Dave Mount, northeastern MN

>While this topic generates an interesting set of perspectives, none will answer your question for you, because the answer is totally dependent on what you want to get out of your woodworking, and how the table saw fits into that world. Everybody who has posted is right. . .and at the same time no one is right.

Adam mentioned Gary Rogowski's (sp?) "essential tools" argument. Interesting, but then again I'm pretty sure Gary has a table saw (and uses it). From another perspective, the concept of those five tools being "essential" is garbage, because some of the finest furniture ever made was made without any of them. And, some tremendous furniture has been made using all of them and more.

I get a great deal of pleasure out of using hand tools, but I'm not even close to selling any of my power tools. Power tools enable me to do quickly things that, although I could do them without power tools, I can do them much faster with them. My time is limited, and the "bragging rights" of having prepped all my rough stock by hand is not even close to enough reward to give up the opportunity to do additional things I'll never get to if I commit the time to doing that by hand. I recently built a shaving horse, so I could make chairs using all hand tools, largely for the experience. Yet, I used some power tools to make the shaving horse, because my goal was not to have a shaving horse I could say I made with hand tools, but to get the shaving horse made so I could start using it. But for others, the equation is very different, and the "zen" they get from having an electron-free zone is well worth the trade-offs. And we're both right.

So should you get rid of your table saw? First consideration is whether doing so will "take you to where you want to be." Unless you're really strapped for cash and/or shop space, or truly scared by the TS, the financial, space, and safety arguments are probably just noise and rationalization.

Good luck with your decision,

Dave

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#16

Oh, I forgot. It also makes a good T.V. stand

Roy from Cincy

>

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#17

You could paint it and hang it on the wall.

Roy from Cincy

>A nice pastoral scene with an old barn and little flowers in the field. Maybe a broken down tractor in the foreground. That's what some people do with an unused saw. Might need mollybolts on drywall, though.

(this is a joke. i'm not serious)

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#18

Can't get of my table saw it's my son's.

Vic P

>

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#19

Laughed so hard beer was coming out my nose...

Vic P

>

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#20

Dave, well said

David Miller from Iowa

>

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#21

Right on, Dave!

Frank Mutchler

>I have many more human powered tools than electric powered tools. I use whichever tool will accomplish the job at hand in the most efficient manner. I sometimes think that a lot of long gone woodworkers would have loved to have had any of our taken for granted and easily disparaged power tools.

Working with hand tools exclusively is fun/interesting/rewarding when your livelyhood doesn't depend on it. I don't even want to think about building kitchen cabinets without a table saw, making 30 or 40 raised panel doors w/o a tablesaw, router table, and shaper, or dimensioning 300 bf or 4/4 hard maple w/o a planer and jointer. I also love being able to remove tearout/milling marks with a one of 4 or 5 hand planes, depending on grain and so on.

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#22

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

eric in Maryland

>ok for a neader newbie who is becoming versed in chisels and hand planes -- following the OP question -- given that I get rid of my table saw, what would be a recommended set of hand saws to accomplish the usual cutting tasks accomplised with a table saw

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#23

Steve Kubien

One word in your message....

Steve Kubien

>really pops out at me, Bob. You used the word 'fear'. If you are afraid of it, you have two options...Get over the fear or get rid of the tool. Fear will get you hurt.

I have been thinking of ditching my contractor saw for some time. A couple of things have held me back. I saved for quite some time to buy it and I'll never get near the price I paid and I use plywood, making items for painting classes my mother teaches. I've been trying to convince myself that a circular saw and router would work well for getting dead-straight edges on sheet goods. Then, I think about the time needed to set up TWO tools and my enthusiasm for getting rid of it dies for a while.

It will save you some space and probably improve your health (dust/noise reduction) to sell it. You will lose a good assembly table. If you are in this hobbie for peace and tranquility, ditch it. If speed is of high value to you (production work, honey-do's etc) AND you can get over the fear, keep it.

I do not like fear in my shop. Healthy respect for danger is welcome.

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#24

Steve Kubien

I took the liberty....

Steve Kubien

>of starting anew thread for this topic. This has generated some useful debate in the past.

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#25

Though I hate to say it..... *LINK*

A. Byrd

>....sheet goods are a cost effective practical reality when it comes to general carpentry, home maintenance, and even some large scale furniture projects, ( I just can�t see myself gluing up all of the 1/4 inch cabinet backer panels needed for a large kitchen project). I do most of my roughing out work on plywood with a circular saw and then take it to the table saw for squaring up. If I had a more accurate circular saw I would sell my table saw to save shop space. As safety goes the saw I�ve looked the hardest at is the Festool 7-1/2" Portable Circular Plunge Cut Saw and its companion guide rail system. It's a fully shrouded plunge type saw with european saftety features. If you follow the manufactures safety guidelines you would have to be very careless to seriously hurt yourself. People who have it say it�s a dream to set up and work with and has great dust collection to boot, (heck it�s so good that Mr. Forrest even makes one of his special blades for it). If I�m good the rest of the year I might just be able to talk SWMBO into getting it for me for Christmas. If not well there�s always the ubiquitous UPS drop at work��� ;-)

A.B.


Plunge type circular saw.