Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Which waterstones to start out with *LINK*

Posts

Which waterstones to start out with *LINK*

#1

Which waterstones to start out with *LINK*

Alan Womack

>I have been using scrary sharp for my plane iron and chisel sharpening, however, very respected members of this list and others report a better edge can be made on high end blades/chisels with 8000 and up waterstones.

I also find myself needing a couple of water stones for the continued quest for large fluffy card scraper shavings.

King stones are supposed to be pretty OK, shapton to be at the top of the man made heap. Or should I just order a couple from Japan Woodworker and have at it?

I figure I have 50 years of woodworking ahead of me, so I don't mind the initial wince.

my card scraper page if you missed it on an earlier post.

Alan


http://alan.firebin.net/card_scraper.html

Re: Which waterstones to start out with *LINK*

#2

Re: Which waterstones to start out with

Dan Donaldson

>As far as getting a "better edge" with waterstones, I am not sure that is true. From what I have seen, it is possible to get a good edge with almost any method as long as you use it long enough to get familiar and comfortable.

That said, I prefer the waterstones. (I used to do scary sharp, and still use it sometimes, depending on the application. I have a piece of fine sandpaper on marble, and a strop that I keep next to me when carving)

The waterstones cut fast and give a good edge. I have a couple of the King stones and also Shaptons. For me, I think that for a given grit, the Shaptons cut faster and leave a better finish. The Kings go out of flat faster, but are also easier to flatten. The Kings require soaking, and the Shaptons do not. There is a definate cost difference that may or may not be a critical element of your choice. Depending on your preferences, either should give you good service.

Re: Which waterstones to start out with *LINK*

#3

Re: Which waterstones to start out with

Robin Frierson

>My first choice would be the Shaptons, second choice the Norton waterstones. And then use a 10x4 two sided DMT coarse/extra coarse diamond stone to dress them and keep them flat. But just use the diamond stone on your stones, as they wear out fast if you use them on steel.

That said, I have now abandoned my stones and use the Lee Valley power sharpener. By the time you buy the Shapton stones, diamond stones, you could get the power sharpener.

Re: Which waterstones to start out with *LINK*

#4

Re: Which waterstones to start out with

Tim of San Leandro

>"I figure I have 50 years of woodworking ahead of me, so I don't mind the initial wince. "

Given that....I'd say get the Shapton professional series. Whatever stones you decide to go with.....you MUST figure out a good and easy way to keep them flat. The more fine stones are very easily kept flat but coarse stones are a real pain for me to keep flat. The Shapton diamond reference plate is quite good from my very limited use of it (at a friends shop) as well as from their feedback. But at 300 - 400 for that alone....it isn't for everyone.

I've abandoned ship on waterstones...instead I lapped some steel plates flat and charge them with diamonds - amazingly fast cutting and the 0.5 micron diamonds leave a very good surface.

If I went back to waterstones now....I'd get the reference plate for flattening and the shaptons professionals for sharpening. It would be expensive.....~$700 but imo well worth the expense.

tim

Re: Which waterstones to start out with *LINK*

#5

Re: Which waterstones to start out with

steve knight

>but you have the contined cost of sandpaper. for speed and ease of use it would be faster to use the power sharper for the basic work and the stones to finish the edge off. you will get a more accurate edge that way.

Re: Which waterstones to start out with *LINK*

#6

Re: Which waterstones to start out with

Tony - Memphis

>I took a class with Lonnie Bird last fall and was introduced to the Norton stones there. I was really impressed. So I bought a set when I got home. I have been very pleased with them. I used to use scary sharp, but I like these much better. I got the set at toolsforworkingwood.com for a good price.

Tony

Re: Which waterstones to start out with *LINK*

#7

How about you Steve

Robin Frierson

>You gotta sharpen more than anyone, you still using the Makita and the Hippo Shaptons?

Re: Which waterstones to start out with *LINK*

#8

Same here...

Christopher Fitch @ Memphis

>I used Scary Sharp and still do occasionally but I tried some Norton combo stones and I found that I really like the way they perform.

I am considering upgrading to full-size stones since I have the combo stones right now.

Re: Which waterstones to start out with *LINK*

#9

Re: How about you Steve

Alan Womack

>When I visited Steve's place a few months back, he had 3 makitas and 2 hippos. So he practices what he preaches, and the edges are damn fine when they come.

Now if I had only asked him to sharpen the replacement smoother blade I bought, them are some deep scratches in there still.

Alan

Re: Which waterstones to start out with *LINK*

#10

Re: Which waterstones to start out with

Alan Womack

>The advise is helpful, I most likely will buy a M5 series 15000 grit shapton as my final stone to give a try after 2000 grit scary sharp initially.

Then I think I will try the norton stones on the rougher grits to get a feel to useage. I'm sure one could sell them for 80% of purchase price on the bay.

How high of a stone do most of you use? 4000, 8000, 12000, 15000??

Thanks

Alan

Re: Which waterstones to start out with *LINK*

#11

Re: Which waterstones to start out with

Alan Hamilton

>Alan,

Others will disagree, but I'm one that thinks going farther than a 6000 stone serves no useful purpose whatever. I'll upset more people and say that even a 6000 grit stone may be over the line of diminishing returns.

I too have used sandpaper and glass and switched to waterstones. People sometimes exaggerate problems with something to justify their doing something else. It's true that waterstones must be wet and that they need to be flattened sooner than other stones; but I've not found that to be the least bit odious. Waterstones can be flattened in less than a minute.

I got one of those pink, flattening bricks, or stones, or whatever. It works like a champ and costs less than many diamond stones. But expensive stone-flattening implements aren't necessary: I have one friend who flattens his stones on the side of a gray concrete block; and another who uses the concrete floor of his garage.

As another said, all kinds of methods will give you sharp tools. I would add that all methods have their good and bad points. You need only to pick one method and learn to use it.

Alan

Re: Which waterstones to start out with *LINK*

#12

Re: Which waterstones to start out with

joel

>As you let the water on your water stone dry and as you put pressure on the tool the adbrave grits crack and you get sharp, finer abrasive. Odate talks about this in his book and he's right. This is escpecally true with softer stones with more slurry. This might be why you are so happy with 6k grit - in fact you are getting a much higher effective grit. I stop at 8K

Interestingly enough a wide sort of flat concrete slab will get your stone just as flat as a very small flat lapping plate.

Re: Which waterstones to start out with *LINK*

#13

Re: Which waterstones to start out with

Frank Mutchler

>Alan,

I just watched your videos & found them interesting! After you file the edge of your scraper, do you burnish it to roll an edge or are you using right after filing?

I'm also interested in how you make the QT video. Is there much to it? Perhaps you could furnish some info on that subject??

Re: Which waterstones to start out with *LINK*

#14

I have Kings and...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>Their nice stones. Sometimes I can gouge them with thin chisles. If I were to it again (or when mine wear out) I'll go with Shaptons. I use a 3000, 5000, 8000 and 12K grits. Scott, I still use SS too.

Re: Which waterstones to start out with *LINK*

#15

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Some thoughts

Jim in Burlington Ontario

>I have a set of King stones that I started out with. They cut very slowly and are now used to sharpen drawknife's and everything else but chisels and plane blades. I have 2 of every norton stone and use them for chisels and plane blades. As for scrapers the superfine file that LV sells does 90 percent of the work and I finish it off on sandpaper. I also use the 0.5u 3M sandpaper to polish off chisels and plane blades under magnification is appears sharper and performs like they are sharper. I had bought a large DMT stone and it wore down at a alarming speed so I returned it. I am waiting on delivery of diamond paste to give it a try. Also in the mix is lapping powder and glass to speed homemade tools along which it really does. I have a 1" belt sander and use a Surgi sharp leather belt and LV honing compound that is very valuable for sharpening carving tools. Probably buy a Shapton 15000 stone somewhere along the way to give it a try.

Re: Which waterstones to start out with *LINK*

#16

Re: Which waterstones to start out with

Alan Womack

>I have tried burnishing with a couple of instruments, not actual burnisher yet. The best edge has been after drawfiling the edge, vs. the straight jointing in the video.

I've used a hard torz screwdriver which was cromed, a die, chisel side, and a wrist pin from semi tractor sized diesel engines. I may buy a carbide round next week and try that as a burnisher.

The drawfile edge creates the shavings on the last photo of the page, about 50 times the size of the dust as a WAG.

I have a minolta DZ1 camera bought from Costco which has the movie mode in it. Many digital cameras can make video's with sound. The videos are 320x150 I think it is, there is also a 640x480 mode which is higher resolution than your TV. The resulting file would be about 4 times the size it is now though. I've done no mpeg-4 compression, which could substantially reduce the size.

Re: Which waterstones to start out with *LINK*

#17

Re: How about you Steve

steve knight

>Well I had three hippo's (G) the 1000 5000 and 12000 (all they carry is the 12000) I just wore out my shapton Makita stone. so I am trying out using sandpaper for the basic shaping on the Makita and then finishing off by hand. I got a 120 grit shapton for that job since the sandpaper does not leave a super flat surface at 120 grit.

But I still find the stones are more accurate for final sharpening. And easier then changing grits. But since I freehand everything that's a bit different then others would do.

Re: Which waterstones to start out with *LINK*

#18

Re: Which waterstones to start out with

steve knight

>well this may depend on the steel you sharpen. but I sure find a better edge going to 8000. going past that will not usualy do anything but on the finest japanese steel.

Re: Which waterstones to start out with *LINK*

#19

Re: Which waterstones to start out with

Don Thompson, Cutler Ridge, South of Miami FL

>Robin,

Are you using the LVPSS to flatten and polish plane iron backs?

Re: Which waterstones to start out with *LINK*

#20

Flattening Steel Plates

Don Thompson, Cutler Ridge, South of Miami FL

>What method did you use to flatten the steel plates that you use with the diamond powder?

Re: Which waterstones to start out with *LINK*

#21

Re: Which waterstones to start out with

Don Thompson, Cutler Ridge, South of Miami FL

>I am using 800, 2000, 4000 and 8000 for sharpening and polishing. I recently got the 120 and 320 Shaptons for back flattening, after reading Lyn Mangiameli's recommendations.

The blades look pretty shiny and smooth after using the 8000, but as I have not used or seen a blade finished with a finer grit, I can not comment on whether you should also get a 10000 or 15000.

[Does anyone remember who sells the Ice Bear 10k?]

Re: Which waterstones to start out with *LINK*

#22

Re: Which waterstones to start out with

joel

>We sell the 10K ice bear stones

Re: Which waterstones to start out with *LINK*

#23

Re: Flattening Steel Plates

Tim of San Leandro

>Don,

I used abrasive paper on a granite reference plate. I paid relatively big $ for aluminum oxides (180 and 120 micron 3M microabrasives, 4 inch x 24 inch - $3.25 per sheet) at the local japanwoodworker....cause I wanted them NOW. They don't last very long....I needed a new sheet for each 8 x 3 plate (cold rolled 1018 carbon steel).

I've since been in contact with Val at customsandingbelts.com and will try some very rough zirconia followed by finer grit Al Ox....their prices are much better. Less than $2/sheet for the zirconia. You have to email them for the pricing and such since their website only posts pricing for belts....I don't want a belt, just a sheet.

Tim

Re: Which waterstones to start out with *LINK*

#24

Thank you, Joel.

Don Thompson, Cutler Ridge, South of Miami FL

>