Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Antique store etiquette

Posts

Antique store etiquette

#1

Antique store etiquette

Mike G.

>I've been visiting an antique store close to where I work. The person who runs it is nice, but I'm almost sure they don't have a clue about the tools in their store. Most of the prices are way out of line and a couple of the tools are mis-named, although it might not be this person's fault, just bad information.

For instance, they have a type 20 Stanley #4C which has a type 16 lever cap listed as a #10 1/2 rabbet plane with a $300.00 price tag. Would it be improper for me to correct this person? I don't want to hurt their feelings because I think I can perhaps make some deals on a couple of tools I'm interested in. Has anyone else ran into this situation before?

Thanks, Mike

Re: Antique store etiquette

#2

Re: Antique store etiquette

Angus Barclay, in New Zealand

>I would politely tell the person what it is they've actually got for sale. They are likely to appreciate being properly informed about what they're selling and the plane you describe seems unlikely to ever sell for $300 so you are not ruining a bargain for any other rust hunter, user or collector.

regards

Angus Barclay

Re: Antique store etiquette

#3

Hard to say for sure

Neal (San Jose)

>I've had responses that ranged from "I'm sure you are trying to put one over on me here, so get out of my store" to "Thanks for the info, is there anything else in the place I've got mis-labeled?" You might try to "sneak up" on the subject, like, Hmmm, I've never seen a 10 1/2 quite like that, can you tell me more about it? Maybe we can find it here in Walter's.

I actually had one dealer buy a Walter's after I showed him mine. He was very grateful, and pointed out how he had repriced several things in his shop the next time I was in.

Re: Antique store etiquette

#4

Re: Antique store etiquette

John K in Hastings, MN

>Now, if a 10 1/2 is marked as a 4C and is priced at $25, no. If it is marked at $300, you'd buy it for $25 and you can prove it is mislabeled, maybe.

Try it once and see how they respond. If they aren't receptive, watch for mislabelings that work in your favor.

John

Re: Antique store etiquette

#5

Re: Antique store etiquette

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>I'd say that it depends on how well you know each other, not necessarily as mates, but if you visit often and are on nodding terms and chat a little. Otherwise your information is understandably going to be received with suspicion, or you'll be perceived to be a know-it-all. Either way you will not endear yourself to him.

You could also give him Patrick Leach's website (http://www.supertool.com/StanleyBG/stan0.htm), if he has access to the internet. Of course this may kill a deal or two for you!

I'm certain that he must eventually get an inkling that something is wrong with his pricing system - unless he has come to believe that the smaller Stanley planes (#1 and #2) are more popular than the bigger planes (#4 and #5) and prices them accordingly to get them out the door as quickly as possible!! (Let me know if this is the case and I'll be over in a flash).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Antique store etiquette

#6

Re: Antique store etiquette

Todd Hughes

>I have found out in cases like this ,[and in life in general !] it is hard to make the wrong choice when you choose to mind your own bussiness. While it is tempting to "straighten" the seller out you have to think what is in it for you?... Nothing... I doubt very much they are going to drop that no. 5 down from $300 to $10 just because you said it's not a 10 1/2 and is worth that.To start talking about tool identification and vaule guides with them is just plain cutting your own throat.Sure they grossly mispriced that no. 5 to high but perhaps next time you go in they will have a no.2 priced like it is a 202 block plane? This will not happen if they have a Walters value guide. What will happen is that they will have a rough no.2 priced like it is a Type 1 in mint condition instead. It is not in your interest and is not your job to educate sellers like this.To educate them to the true vaule of what they sell is just like showing your hand to the other players in a poker game...don't make much sence. Over time as things don't sell they will come down in price or take it all to an auction where they will sell low.IF nothing else if they can't sell tools[because they have them priced to high] they will be less likely to compete against you buying them in other venues.

I see this a good bit in antique stores because sellers just don't know what they are selling [DUH!] sure you might miss out on some stuff because of that since they price it to high but I have often come out ahead because of it.Have bought nice everlast chisels [labled as "wedges"]for $2.00 that were next to $50 junk fire wood planes. Got a tiny Victor plane for $10 that was next to a rusty incomplete 45 priced at $275

Once bought a 18th century slide rule for $15 when the seller had common junk folding rules priced at for some reason $25. When I go out buying the whole thing is based on that I am pitting what I know against what the seller knows.Hopefully I know more....am I going to give them a leg up on me?...Don't think so! ....Todd

Re: Antique store etiquette

#7

And what about eBay?

David Miller from Iowa

>You see misplabeled and expecially mispriced stuff on eBay. A while back I politely informed a guy that his incomplete rusted 45 should not have a $200 opening bid which MIGHT be justified for a complete mint in the box one.

He told me to pound sand so I just gave up at let them line in the worlds they have chosen.

Re: Antique store etiquette

#8

Re: Antique store etiquette

WoodburnBob

>You are generous in assigning error or ignorance as the likely cause for the labelling and price.

My wife is hot for antique shops. So at one time we hit ever shop we could find within a 30 mile radius. Occasionally I saw fair tools at fair prices. Usually it was the $3 woody for $35 or the $90 #5 with a cracked cheek. I finally concluded that pricing was by specific gravity times surface flaws per inch.

I don't think your observation is specific to tools. I can imagine that the proprietors throw darts behind their backs to select the items that will be priced at 10 times their fair value.

Here's a thought experiment: Rather than informing your dealer of your opinions about price on the fraudulent #10 1/2, why don't you put a #4 in your trunk and drop by the shop. Go in and tell the proprietor you're cleaning out grandpa's tool collection and ask if he/she is interested in seeing a sample. Go get #4 and show it. Ask for an offer. See what they'll give you for your "10 1/2". That should expose intent pretty rapidly.

Re: Antique store etiquette

#9

Re: Antique store etiquette

Ernie Miller Topeka

>Best to let sleeping dog lie. If you teach these people how to value there stuff you eliminate the possability of ever getting a good deal. Besides they are not in the buisness to sell there tools and stuff to users they cater to collectors and interior decorators. people who buy stuff because it will look good on a shelf or have no clue at all. If it sets there long enough some one will stop in and buy it not having a clue. or they will dispose of it in some other mannor to clean up space for somthing else. I have concluded that I could be a million aire if I could sell my tools in the right anteek shop.

Re: Antique store etiquette

#10

Re: Antique store etiquette

Binen Eastern Ia

>Well I may have a little different perspective. My wife and I owned an antiques shop for 15 years. Ninety nine percent will depend on how you approach the subject. Come off like a know-it-all and you won�t get far. Owners of antiques shops are unable to be experts in everything they sell. Most times we have an overall idea but not specialist knowledge or specialized reference books unless that item is a large part of our business. General reference price guides are just that general; you get an idea but not detailed decryptions. Also many times they only list top end items. You pick up a general reference look up iron planes and see only prices listed running $150 to $1200, you make a guess and put an item out.

I would simply and quietly inform the owner they have misidentified the plane and may want to do some further research. Don�t offer information unless asked. If ask be honest and tell them what it is and what it is really worth. Most (not all) antique dealers want to honestly represent what they have for sale and have it priced fairly. Over priced and misidentified items do not sell and you go out of business fast if you�re not selling.

Binen

Re: Antique store etiquette

#11

Re: Antique store etiquette

Tom MacGregor

>I stopped at an antique store with very few tools. All four planes were marked $30, which must have been the default price or something. There was a Stanley #100 with the tail snapped off, ground smooth and repainted. I tried to politely point out the damage and was promptly treated like a con artist. Since then I have developed a friendship with an elderly dealer who has no desire to use a computer. We talk "planes" on a regular basis and I've explained eBay and it's effect on the market. I've located spare parts for him online and given them to him at cost. I also snag things at flea markets and garage sales that he wants & I don't. He now sells to me based more on what he pays for an item than what he thinks he can get from someone else. All my best pieces have come from him. I still look for "gloats" everywhere I go, but don't bother with people who have unreal expectations.

Re: Antique store etiquette

#12

The Other Side

Todd Hughes

>I sell a good bit on the Ebay and I routinly get emails from "experts" telling me what I am selling isn't what I described. Last week had a guy insist that a Stanley 192 should have a fence and mine is incomplete because it didn't have one. Well i would like to know how one is attached and why none is shown in the original Stanley catalogs I own.Also get a few emails all the time telling me that Caulking tools I have up are really stone carving tools.Once had an "expert" tell me the older Stanley No. 21 square I was selling was "put together" because it doesn't look like the one in the Walters Book.I sent him a photo I took from a 1920's catalog showing one just like mine as this is what they looked like befor changing to the one shown in walters in 1934.

Helpful know it alls ain't limited to ebay though. Once was set up at a show and had an old guy tell me all about how a particular axe was made.All wrong of course as I pointed out. He still didn't believe me even when I told him I had made it!Got mad and picked up a Frame saw nearby and asked me"Figure you made that too?!".....Matter of fact I did........Todd

Re: Antique store etiquette

#13

Re: Antique store etiquette

Mike G.

>I appreciate evryone's answers to my question. I'll have to give it some serious thought. Perhaps as one poster suggested, I should make friends with the proprietor and gradually steer the conversation around to pricing of their tools. Or maybe I should buy what I want and what I can talk them down on before making my suggestion. :)

It's funny, but a few of the prices aren't too bad...35 bucks for a 1913 patent date no 65 and 45 bucks for a no 83 scraper, which is about what I bought one for on Ebay, missing the wheel and post, of course.

Anyone interested in Ivory rules? They have quite a few ranging from about 75 bucks and up...way up.

Re: Antique store etiquette

#14

Re: Antique store etiquette *LINK*

walt quadrato

>I'm surprized no one has mentioned the obvious...the dealer also had a #4 and not really knowing his tools..someone switched tags and got the actual 10 1/2 for the price of the #4. I've had my shop for 18 years and you would not believe the things I've seen people try to get away with. If the dealer in question actually took the time to write out a tag with the 10 1/2 info..then he obviously had a glimmer of a clue..but not knowing tools..or having someone else watch his shop with no clue at all..someone can always take advantage. Saying that, I do have to say that all of the old tool galoots I've met and had stop by my shop have been the most honest people I have ever met. I would mention to the owner that someone may have mislabeled the item, he may get a bad feeling about some tool people..but I think he's appreciate your honesty..I know I would.

walt q


brass city toolworks