Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Phenix saw, ever heard of?

Posts

Phenix saw, ever heard of?

#1

Phenix saw, ever heard of?

Roy from Cincy

>I found a saw for $5 last week at a garage sale. At first I thought it was a Diston, until I cleaned it up a little (don't worry, I just wiped it off with a little terpentine and 000 steel wool). Anyway it turned out to say Phenix on the handle button (what's the proper word for that thing?). It has a symbol of a bird, presumably a Phoenix. There is something embossed on the blade but I haven't been able to decipher it yet. It seems like a nice saw. Good shape, just needs sharpening. Has anyone ever heard of a Phenix saw?

Re: Phenix saw, ever heard of?

#2

Re: Phenix saw, ever heard of?

John Fitzpatrick

>Roy-

I have a saw that has a Phoenix medallion. The blade is etched with the logo of The Marshall-Wells Co. Winipeg, Manitoba. I assumed they were a hardware dealer (rather than a sawmaker), and that the Phoenix medallion was sorta like the 'Warranted Superior' medallions that Disston or Atkins or some other maker put on the saws they sold marked with a dealer's name. Would be curious to find out what your's is marked-- let us know.

John

Re: Phenix saw, ever heard of?

#3

Re: Phenix saw, ever heard of?

Bob Nelson

>Roy - Does the buttom really say Phenix vs. Phoenix? Moore Bros. of jamestown, NY, made saws ca. 1900 and used Phoenix as a brand name. E. C. Atkins sold saws they identified as made by Moore Bros., but it's thaought they probably bought them out and continued to use their name - and maybe their Phoenix brand name. Marahall Wells was a hardware comp;any that marked tools (and maybe made some), but Phoenix is not a brand name they are known to have used themselves. Bob

Re: Phenix saw, ever heard of?

#4

Re: Phenix saw, ever heard of?

Joshua Clark

>Hi Roy,

Besides what Bob and John alreay mentioned, another possibility is that the saw was made by the Phoenix Company who made saws in the late 19th century in Hitchcockville, CT. I have one saw made by this company and the medallaion has an embossed phoenix with the words "Phoenix Warranted".

Hope this helps,

-Josh in CT-

Re: Phenix saw, ever heard of?

#5

Re: Phenix saw, ever heard of?

Bob Nelson

>Josh,

On what basis do you say that the Phoenix Co. made saws in Hitchcockville in the late 1800s? The Directory of American Toolmakers says they made wood planes there 1853 to 1864 when they sold out to L.C. Stephens & Co. Stephens & Co. may have used the name for a while after that before merging into Chapin-Stephens in 1901. However, the town name Hitchcockville was changed to Riverton in 1865, so it seems unlikely they'd have marked the earlier name after that. Maybe they made saws as well as planes earlier or something? Bob

Re: Phenix saw, ever heard of?

#6

Re: Phenix saw, ever heard of?

Joshua Clark

>Hi Bob,

The only reference I have to The Phoenix Company in Hitchcockville, CT is from Erv's book on Handsaw manufacturers. I believe he dates the Phoenix Co to 1851-1901. I would date the one Phoenix Co. saw I haveto the latter half of that time period based on the newer saw nuts and "lt in" handle.

-Josh in CT-

Re: Phenix saw, ever heard of?

#7

Re: Phenix saw, ever heard of?

Bob Nelson

>I hate to disagree with Erv. BUT I must. I've separately confirmed that Hitchcockville did change its name to Riverton in the 1860s, so the Phoenix Co. was NOT making saws or planes or anything else in Hitchcockville in 1891. Further, Pollak's book confirms that the plane making Phoenix Co. was sold to Stephens in 1864; Pollak does indicate that Stephens copntinued to make planes with that name and says that Phoenix Co. planes marked Riverton were probably made by Stephens. Did that same Phoenix Co. make saws and did Stephens continue to do so in their name? Maybe so, but I know of no confirming evidence of either. Was there a second Phoenix Co. in Hitchcockville? Again, maybe so, but it seems unlikely. Are you out there Erv? If so, please defend yourself. Bob

Re: Phenix saw, ever heard of?

#8

Re: Phenix saw, ever heard of?

Roy from Cincy

>The name on the medalion is definately Phenix, not Phoenix. It has the word Phenix on top, above a bird roosting on a crown with trade mark on either side of the bird and Warrented below. The medalion appears to be brass. If I can get my digital camera back from my son, I will post some pics.

Re: Phenix saw, ever heard of?

#9

Re: Phenix saw, ever heard of?

Roy from Cincy

>To all of those who expressed interest in this saw, I want to confirm that the name on the medalion is Phenix, not Phoenix.