>I am just about ready to bite the bullet on a new classical/electric guitar. I have narrowed my search down to a Takamine EC132SC (cedar top, rosewood sides and back), Takamine EC132C (spruce top, rosewood sides and back), Alvarez AC60SC (cedar top, mahogany sides and back) and a Washburn C104SCE. I have played the first three, and will play the Washburn tonight.
The Washburn is available in two different wood combinations - a cedar top/rosewood sides and back and in a cedar top/quilted ash sides and back. It is the quilted ash that throws me...I am not familiar with this wood in guitars, so I have no idea how it affects sound. I will play one tonight, but don't know if it is in rosewood or in ash yet. They have only one, so I'm still going to be a bit unsure.
Does anyone have any direct experience with these guitars and/or woods that you can share with me?
>Save judgement till you've played the Washburn, I recently heard from my son's guitar teacher how much improved their new offerings are.
To keep things woodwork related, I recently reglued a chip of wood grained high pressure plastic laminate onto the back of a Martin guitar. Hid pretty well, plastic or not it still sounds awesome.
>Spruce is generally considered the top of choice for classical, but alot of people like cedar. The sound of the guitar has alot more to do with the bracing layout and the overall fit and finish of the instrument. It's not really a wood problem domain to first order, but a structural problem.
In the price range you're looking at, I have a couple friends who swear by the Seagull/Godin guitars. Godin makes a electric nylon string that's pretty nice. But it needs to be plugged in.
What sort of guitar are you trying to get? It sounds like you want a classical you can plug in to a PA system but that still makes noise. My advice to people who ask me what kind of guitar to get is simple: The one you really want. And never one you haven't played.
I have a Gibson Dove sitting in the closet, but no callouses anymore. I can play a top-notch steel string whenever I want, and can toss in a 12 string epiphone and another 6 string steel (first b-day present from my wife - sentimental value, not much more.)
My "want" is for a classical to sit around in the living room and plunk on while watching tv, but a good enough one that I won't hate playing it (after my Dove, most else suffers by comparison). I had just such an animal; I bought it for about 60% off because of sun damage to the bindings, and paid about $300 when I bought it. Unfortunately (actually, fortunately for him), number one son liked it and asked to borrow it for a while. I gladly said yes, and have not seen it since! :-) This new one will be a replacement for that one.
The electic part is for the one time a year I will use it in a larger setting, or, most likely, so that when #1 son sees this one, he will take it and give me my old one back. It is as much for him to use with his acoustic amp as anything.
I am really torn between buying what will get me by and be perfectly okay, and what I want, but can't possibly justify.
I'll agree that it's the top of a guitar, along with the bracing and general workmanship, that determines the quality of sound. For a few years I played a guitar with a plastic back--an Ovation. I thought my Ovation sounded very good (not nearly as good as my Larivee; which is why I no longer have an Ovation) and of course lots of very good pluckers dearly love Ovations.
There was a luthier/guitarist (I've forgotten his name) who used to hang out at the Ash Grove, and after THE FIRE, moved with the rest of us down to McCabes, who made himself a guitar with a good quality spruce top and a paper mache body. Believe it or not! To everyone's surprise--except him, I suppose--it sounded pretty good.
>One other thing... I've got about four or five guitars (currently) and have disccovered the expensive way that cheap guitars basically suck. There, I said it. I'd seriously look at a Wechter or a Tacoma
Why not play the Dove?
The main trick with guitar playing is you need to store the guitar on a stand, not in a case. Got get a stand and a tuner and put the whole assembly next to the couch. You'll play your guitar orders of magnitude more if it's out where you can see it. The caluses will come back soon. Eventually you learn not to press so hard and they go away again (or at least get smaller)
>Basically buy it on the sound you want. All the wood types you described are fine for guitars.
I used to work at Maton Guitars for a number of years. Maton is Australia's biggest and best known guitar company and have been in business for about 60 years now. They make very high quality guitars that are renown the world over. I still remember seeing wonderful "half-logs" of Brazillian rosewood and meeting a lot of the biggest names in music while I was working there.
We were also, at the time, the exclusive importers of Takamine guitars for the whole of Australia and New Zealand.
But, as stated, it really all gets down to the type of sound you want and the look that you're after. Typically a cedar top will sound more mellow and not quite as bright - especially when coupled with the mahogany sides and back (which has the same "mellowing" effect). However, the mellow sound can be slightly negated or enhanced by the pattern of the internal struts.
Ash is mainly used in solid bodied guitars like Fenders etc. It's generally quite bright sounding as well - similar to maple.
Sound, feel & look. The materials in the guitars are all AOK so it's just a matter of the sound, the feel and the look.
>As was already noted, ash can lend a somewhat bright timbre as a body tonewood, but that in itself is far less a factor than the design and execution (bracing, thinning), and the topwood. Antonio Torres once made a papier-mache back and sides to isolate and demonstrate the predominance of the top as primary resonator. Cedar sounds like cedar across the entire scale, a bit warmer and mellower, as noted, yet can be very loud, especially in the bass notes. In fact, much of the bracing in cedar topped instruments is aimed at strengthening the treble and sometimes to suppress a bit of the bassiness.
Another important consideration is that cedar usually plays open from the start, whereas spruce can often take years before it opens fully and matures. That said, a stronger playing technique on a guitar that gets played often will generally open more quickly. Englemann spruce seems to open sooner than European (now mostly Ukrainian rather than German) or Sitka, but much depends on grade and aging.
More depends on the skill of the luthier than the materials, though. Some of the finest classics from the "Golden Age"; guitars by Torres, Manual Ramerez and Hermann Hauser did not necessarily have the greatest number of rings per inch or the finest grained supporting tonewoods as seen a 1950's Fleta, for example.
Look online for luthier websites and read articles on choosing a guitar; esp. Bill Cumpiano's site (his newsletters are worthwhile).
When did Antonio Torres make funky with his paper mache guitar? I first saw the paper mache guitarist I wrote about above in the early seventies--about 1972 or '73. The name 'Antonio Torres' doesn't ring a bell though (that might be because I don't have a bell to ring). On one hand, there were a lot of strange acts in the folksy-bluesy-traditionalsy music scene back then. But on the other hand, how many guys could there be that played a paper mache' guitar?
Does Torres go back to be around in those lamented sixties and early seventies? The Ash Grove was in Hollywood and burnt around '72 '3 or '4. McCabes Guitar Shop is still in Santa Monica, last time I checked, and has been around forever.
>Darn, I missed your post completely (they say the mind's the second thing to go).
Torres built his papier-mache guitar in 1862. So yeah, the 60's. Just not the 1960's, heh. Antonio de Torres was the father of the modern guitar. Nearly everyone since has used the Torres proportions as the point of departure.
>most of my playing time is when Sweetie Pie and I are sitting in the living room watching tv or after she has gone to bed. The Dove is a bit loud for that.
And watch it, buster! You're starting to sound like my wife!!! :-)
I do need to get the callouses back, though. And you are right about the stand.
>Thank each and every one of you. I appreciate your advice and opinions.
As several suggested, I played each of the guitars on my list at least once, and most were played several times. I was able to play at least 2 of each except the Washburn, which was the worst of all. I drove 30 miles to play a guitar for 15 seconds.
The Alvarez was consistant among the 3 I played - not great, but, if I had not played others, not bad either. I would classify the ones I played as "good enough" guitars.
The Takamine was the biggest reach...I didn't need a guitar for that much money, particularly when I have a Gibson Dove and an Epiphone 12 string in the closet. But it was by far the "sweetest" sound, and, unlike the others, projected through the entire range of the fretboard. Volume and tone quality were by far the best, as you would expect for twice as much money.
The result....the Takamine. More than I needed, I know, but everything I wanted. To quote a good friend when I ran it by him, "How many times do you want to buy a classical guitar? Quit being so cheap and buy what you want now." The price was good, too. Guitar Center's "sale" price was $799, plus $120 for a very good quality case. Their "out the door price" came down to $900. I shopped the internet, finding regular shop prices to be just about the same as GC, but found an e-bay price of $791, which included shipping, original Tak case, several sets of quality strings and other misc. I went back to GC to try the Tak one more time to be sure, then asked my sales guy if that was their absolute best price... yes, unless I had something they could price match. So, we went to my "MY EBAY" page, found the auction I was ready to buy from. They said they could not quite match the deal, but, based on the e-bay price, could go to $830 out the door...essentially, tax was the difference.
Sold, if they threw in a decent strap and stand. It was worth it to walk out with THE guitar I played and liked, not one in the "factory wrap" that I had not played.
I was up-front with everybody from the start, telling each I was playing and comparing prices. Nobody had all 3 models in stock, so I spent 3 days and 200 miles trying guitars. Finally, I was pleased, and misled nobody. I feel good.
Ha! Obviosuly a woman of intelligence and good breeding.
Of course I can't take my own advice I've got three electrics, four amps, an accoustic a fretless bass and a mandola. Then there's the pedals. I'll probably get a tri-cone resonator at some point soon and a 12 string. And an electric baritone.
-Matthew (and no, I'm not married)
And a jazzmaster, and come to think of it I don't have a tele, either.