Re: 10,000 grit stone...feedback?
Lyn J. Mangiameli
>I haven't used this stone, but I do use the 12000 Shapton, .5 and .3 micron "papers" (the latter thanks to Russell Seaton), and .5 micron chromium dioxide honing compound.
There is no question in my mind that the 12000 Shapton leaves a discernably and functionally superior edge compared to the 8000 Shapton. I find this diffence to be most meaningful on the harder more "exotic" alloys such as A2 and M4. All it takes is a hand magnifier to evaluate the difference, and a dense difficult to plane wood to observe the difference in cut. I don't work with the softer woods much, but frankly, I'd expect a very sharp edge to be even more meaninful when one is trying to slice softer and more flexible cell walls.
One of the things to keep in mind is that no abrasive is uniformly graded to its advertised rating. There is always some range of particle size, either in the original distribution, or as the abrasive breaks down during use. Usually the finer grits are more closely graded, but still the range becomes apparent in the uniformity (or more precisely, the lack of uniformity) of scratch pattern that is apparent under magnification. Frankly, I am rather dissapointed in the lack of uniformity of partical size in the nominally .5 micron papers and honing sticks, but at least all of the particles are are relatively small even if some are three times the size of others.
Natural waterstones usually have a very wide range of particle size, but fortunately the particles break down in size with use, thus the reason why final polishing is done with the slurry, rather than on a newly exposed bare surface. The newer waterstones have a more durable abrasive that is less prone to fragmentation, and is less prone to build up a slurry, but there is usually much more uniformity in particle size (but still some). I find a more traditional 8000 waterstone to provide a surface more refined than an 8000 Shapton, and I find a 12000 Shapton to provide a surface only slightly better than an 8000 traditional waterstone (thus the significant difference between an 8000 and 12000 Shapton). There is no subjectivity here, all one has to do is observe the obvious difference under magnification. These differences remain aparrent on a well tuned high performance smoother. I've replicated it literally dozens of times.
Now the difference is not going to last indefinitely, as the edge will become worn sooner or later, the rate at which the difference is obscured will depend on the wood planed, the bevel angles, and the steel from which the blade is made. But again, the difference on a freshly honed blade is unequivocal in my experience. To me the moral is, find a method that will allow you to achieve and highly refined edge, and make sure that method is one you are comfortable in returning to often.
For what it's worth, I flatten all my blade backs on a 12000 Shapton stone, and hone all my flat blade edges with .5 micron papers applied to the platters of the Lee Valley Power Sharpening System. Wood is too expensive not to use the best possible edge available when forming it.