Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

LV Med. Shoulder vs. LN 60 1/2R

Posts

LV Med. Shoulder vs. LN 60 1/2R

#1

LV Med. Shoulder vs. LN 60 1/2R

Greg Phillips, Medford, OR

>I am planning to purchase a plane for trimming tennons and other joint fitting work. I am wondering what a shoulder plane can do that can't be done with the LN 60 1/2R. I can't think of much beyond cleaning the bottoms of dadoes. I have heard a ton of positive feedback on the LV medium shoulder plane, but my only block plane is a LN 102, and I think that the 60 1/2R could be a pretty versatile addition to my arsenal. I'm sure as the slide continues, I'll end up getting them both at some point in time. Which one first? What do ya'll think?

Thanks,

Greg

Re: LV Med. Shoulder vs. LN 60 1/2R

#2

Re: LV Med. Shoulder vs. LN 60 1/2R

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>The 60-1/2R is a nice plane, and definitely more versatile than a shoulder plane. But the shoulder plane is specifically designed for trimming shoulders on tenons; the tall flat design helps it register against the side of the tenon, which has already been made flat and square, and make the shoulder nice and flat and square. The rabbeting block plane is not nearly as tall, so making a shoulder square to the tenon is a bit more difficult. My 60-1/2R has a nice tight mouth, but I really look forward to getting the LV shoulder plane with an adjustable mouth sometime this year; I'm now officially on a tool budget, so aquisitions will be a bit easier to schedule ;)

Re: LV Med. Shoulder vs. LN 60 1/2R

#3

Re: LV Med. Shoulder vs. LN 60 1/2R

Ron Smith

>Greg, I have been considering this question for some time. I was ready to order the LV Medium Shoulder but decided it was inadequate for shaping the large tennons I will encounter in making my workbench. The narrow blade make the job too slow and invites uneven surfaces on 2X4 tennon faces. The plane is just too narrow for large tenons, and at the same time too long for comfortable and accurate work on smaller ones. I think the LN Rabbet is a better choice, and it should slice the shoulder line perfectly. However! . . . .I am looking for a plane similar to the LN . . BUT . . . with depth, and width of cut control for use as a proper rabbet plane in addition to shoulder and tennon work. When I layout $150.00 I expect a properly engineered tool.

Re: LV Med. Shoulder vs. LN 60 1/2R

#4

Re: LV Med. Shoulder vs. LN 60 1/2R

GolfSteve in Calgary

>The 60-1/2R is a very versatile tool. It is great for trimming tenons cheeks, but tends to be a bit "tippy" when trimming the shoulders.

The tippiness is due to the large holes in the sides of the plane - these catch on the corners of the tenon. As the holes pass over the tenon cheeks, the amount of plane face registering against the cheek changes. If you're not 100% attentive, the plane can tip.

It sounds obvious, but the shoulder plane is better at trimming shoulders than a rebate plane.

Nevertheless, I bought the 60-1/2R before the shoulder plane. They are both useful. The 60-1/2R can do all your tenon trimming work but it is a bit harder to use when trimming shoulders than a proper shoulder plane would be.

Re: LV Med. Shoulder vs. LN 60 1/2R

#5

Tool budget - what a concept!

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I've counted myself lucky that I get what I do with a combination of slipping it into the shop and begging when I must. An actual BUDGET - wow.

Re: LV Med. Shoulder vs. LN 60 1/2R

#6

Re: LV Med. Shoulder vs. LN 60 1/2R

Dennis Mcdonaugh

>This doesn't sound like an either/or situation. Buy both and be happy!

Re: LV Med. Shoulder vs. LN 60 1/2R

#7

Tool budget - Not necessarily a good thing

Wendell @ Murphy, TX

>I got caught up in a few too many Ebay auctions lately. Now LOML has put me on budget. This is good for the family bank account but it is going to put a crimp in my tool collecting/acquiring.

Wendell

Re: LV Med. Shoulder vs. LN 60 1/2R

#8

Re: LV Med. Shoulder vs. LN 60 1/2R

Kirk in HMB, CA

>I agree with Steve. The shoulder plane is much better for the task as named than the rebate plane. Both are great planes, but I tried to use the 60 1/2R for shoulder work, and it was not nearly as useful.

I was putting shoulders on 1x4 QSWO, and the rebate would wander, while the shoulder tracked much better.

��

Re: LV Med. Shoulder vs. LN 60 1/2R

#9

Re: Tool budget - what a concept!

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>In a way it is tough; I get $20 a week, and I think if I need more than that I may need some direction towards a local 12 step program. If I want more money I can always buy from local auctions and sell on e-bay. I did save up the last five weeks and get a pretty nice type 1 #66 beader at a local antique store, and now will try to discipline myself to save all my money for the national M-WTCA meet coming up in June in Ohio. The shoulder plane I think will have to wait until the end of the year, or if I don't see something at the national meet that I want I'll buy the shoulder plane in June.

Re: LV Med. Shoulder vs. LN 60 1/2R

#10

Only $340 for the MWTCA national meeting!!!!

Russell Seaton

>By my calendar its only 17 weeks until the MWTCA meeting. If you haven't spent this week's $20. I've been to a few of my local MWTCA meetings and I always go with a few hundred in cash just in case. But for the national meeting, with all of those fine old still in the box with the instructions never even touched wood tools, I'd want more just in case.

Re: LV Med. Shoulder vs. LN 60 1/2R

#11

Re: Only $340 for the MWTCA national meeting!!!!

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>Like I said, maybe I need a 12 step program. I could easily take a credit card and get $20,000 cash and spend it all on one plane. Would this make me happy? I can probably negotiate an extension on my budget and take $400 to the national meet; if I can't have a good time with $400, I can't have a good time. If I can't have a good time without money, I can't have a good time; the Moses philosophy ;)