I like using my 12" drawknife and have so far just held work in poppets elevating it off the benchtop. How many of you have a shavehorse, and what kind do you prefer? It isn't real high on my 'to-do' list, but I sure would like to make one to have ready for use any time I want it. -Barb Siddiqui
I use poppets too when I use my drawnknife and spokeshave. I don't have a shaving horse. So why am I posting? When I'm really trying to hog off wood between my poppets, I've definately wondered if I needed an alternative. For thin shavings they've been great - but for hogging....
In any case, I once saw an idea posted on the Pond by William Duffield of a clamping system he uses when he's shaping cabriole legs (especially when he's away from his own bench). He's cut a decent size "V" notch in each of the two jaws of a large wooden clamp - opposite one another. He then clamps the leg he's working on in the wood vise (in the "V" notches) and - then, if I recall correctly, clamps one of the two jaws of the wooden vise into a bench vise. That way he can relatively easily articulate the angle of the leg - and - again, IIRC, since only one jaw of the wooden vise is clamped in the bench vise he can loosen the leg being held in the wooden vise and rotate it (as necessary) while it is still being held secure in the bench vise.
Probably clear as mud. Sorry. I know William had posted pictures of the set-up a while back on the Pond (when he was giving a presentation to some NJ woodworker IIRC) - but I don't know where they are.
I put William's name in the subject heading above in case he drifts over here from the Pond. If so, and if your interested, he might be able to shed some light on my inadequate description of his process.
Regards -
Dave
P.S. I haven't tried William's approach myself. But, as you can tell, I've filed it away for future reference. Looked like it might be a better way of holding my material when I'm hoggin' away.
I use a number of different holding devices for drawknife work, depending on what I'm doing and what time of year it is - my shave horse is out in the (unheated) garage, so it doesn't see a lot of winter use. For things like stick making/carving, I think the horse can't be beat. The ergonomics and the ability to rapidly reposition the work make it the best tool for that type of work. Because I use it mainly for stick making and stick carving, I went with the dumbhead style. This lets me reposition long pieces and flip them around by simply slippping them out the side rather than having to pull them all the way through the way you'd have to on a bodger's bench. The other thing I added to my horse was a tall homemade 360 degree vise-like clamp (kind of hard to describe) on the back to make it easier to do the final carving. This vise can also be mounted in the face vise of my regular bench to let me do drawknife and spokeshave work at a more comfortable height in my "year round" shop (aka down da sella).
If it weren't for the stick making, I don't know if I would have taken the time to make a shaving horse. I do use the drawknives and spokeshaves quite a bit for general woodworking, but the other workholding devices in my shop do the job just fine. Maybe if I really get into chairmaking...
Thanks again to everyone here for making us displaced neanderthals welcome!
First, you can often do without a horse, just use a lathe or lathe like setup on the bench. This works fine for smaller jobs like tool handles.
Second, pony's are pretty cool if you want to save some space. Check out Tom Holloway's, Dave Matthews', and Robb Young's versions at http://home.rochester.rr.com/dmatthews/shavepony/
Then there are the full horses, Drew's (last name?) Country Workshops and John Alexander's Greenwoodworking versions. It goes on and on.
to hold parts for shaving. While I do use my poppets, I found that for cabriole legs, clamping a Bessey in the face vise of the bench and tilting one end higher than the other allows you to clamp the top of the leg post and the bottom of the foot between the jaws. A slight loosening or tightening of the hand screw jaw allows great adjustment.
Another option is to make a shave pony. This is essentially a clamp in the vise version of a shave horse which also uses a foot control to tension or detension the jaws. I think I got the photos to make one of these from the old tools website back a few years ago. Checking their archive might provide you with the info, if not, email me and I'll take a digital photo and send it to you.
I know about the types, and have Drew Langsner's and John Alexander's books, plus Scott Landis. Just curious as to what others find best. Interesting about the dumbhead/bodger versions differences in use; I hadn't thought of having to pull long work through, never having sat at one. Thanks for the input and all the holding ideas...maybe I'll concentrate on benchtop alternatives to save space in my small shop. -Barb S.
I don't know if my dear pal Don Weber has visited your forum in the past, but I'll bet I can get him to pop in here once in a while. He has a lot of good insights about shaving horses.
Here's the site I did for him a couple years ago...
I've used a few shave horses and have a few observations.
I prefer the dumbhead for its mass, ease of use and stiffness.
I prefer Roy Underhill's design to all the others. I made mine in a weekend, carefully following Roy's instructions. It was time well spent. I find rough hewn horses better for three reasons.
1) The rough seatingsurface keeps me from sliding off teh back of teh horse
2) The added mass of my oaken horse makes a more stable horse
3) I use the seat as a chopping block.
Horses made of sawn construction lumber just aren't as nice. Pay atention to the angle of the bench. Know what you want (I like it low) and make it that way.
I have pictures of mine I can send anyone who e-mails me.
I saw an interesting design by Brian Boggs in a picture in Wookwork (IIRC). When I inquired about it, I was told I had to contact a John Kennedy who told me no plans were available and the kit was $175, again IIRC. It was shorter than most and the dumbhead was a ratchet arrangement. It was nice, but to much for me! Paul
on considering the seating and sliding issue...thanks. I have Underhill's 'Woodwright's Apprentice' but it lists his shavehorse "from a single log" in 'The Woodwright's Shop' 1981...is that the horse you are refering to? I'll e-mail for a photo, and thanks for the info. -Barb S.
I saw that photo of Brian Boggs' and thought it looked awfully small. I doubt 'plans' would be necessary, the things are so basic. I'm over six feet tall when I have shoes on, and need something a bit heftier (because I'm heftier than average, too) but it did look like a clean little, functional unit. John Alexander's is quite small, too, but any of them could be beefed up. -Barb S.
Jim Alexander,Drew Langsner,and Roy Underhill all have good info on building one of these useful tools/benches.I think the shaving mule that Langsner offers plans for(at $12)is the best of the lot though.Remember to build a low bench at the same height as the horse(you`ll want both)
that hybrid has both heads for any use....very interesting. I may undertake one of these before I intended to, with that picture to follow. Thanks for the page of info, too. That's a great help. -Barb S.
To use for boring and morticing and assembly among other things.If you need more info on the shaving mule you can find it on countrywoodshops.org/mule or look at www.greenwoodworking.com/shorse for John Alexander`s info(where did I get Jim instead of John?)
Not yet, but thinking on it. Mainly, I just like utilizing my drawknife...fairing an edge, stripping off bark to resaw my fruitwood, other odd jobs. I have a froe I haven't used much, and a gutter adze blade from Kestrel Tools over on Lopez Island, WA, that I have yet to make a handle for. I'm not rich in processed wood, but can be knee-deep in logs any time I wish, so want to use these tools. -Barb S.
I think that just about all of the available published information on shaving horses has them being built on the small size. Mine is considerably larger (longer legs and longer length), and if you're tall, you'll want yours that way, too.