Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Best Top Finish ?

Posts

Best Top Finish ?

#1

Best Top Finish ?

Yonak

Would lacquer or polyurethane be a better finish over oil-based stain/paint ? Any color considerations are not important in this application. It's for a bed head- and foot-board so it's not going to see much wear (please, no jokes about my wife's and my waning youth).

Re: Best Top Finish ?

#2

Re: Best Top Finish ?

Dick Coers

Solvent based lacquer is like paint stripper to paint. Poly will probably be okay. Water based is even better over other paint finishes.

Re: Best Top Finish ?

#3

JL

Re: Best Top Finish ?

JL

How about floor polyurethane? It's a tough finish w/ high solids.

Re: Best Top Finish ?

#4

Re: Best Top Finish

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

If you're looking to use a clear over an old finish, consider using a "tie" coat of dewaxed shellac (see below) then apply a water-based finish like General's Enduro or High Performance Poly. All best if sprayed (especially the shellac) but I've gotten good results with a foam brush and the Enduro.

Re: Best Top Finish ?

#5

Re: Best Top Finish ?

David Weaver

I would've said some kind of curing finish years ago, but now, I'd say that shellac by itself ought to be fine. If it needs a touch up in the future, it'll be as easy (literally) as just padding a tiny bit more on.

I built two bookcases for my kids - one five years ago and the other about 8. They're just made with shellac. The kids slobbered all over them and left water marks on them, and some rings from cups. It may have taken 5 minutes to repair all of it with a paper towel and some zinsser spray shellac (spraying onto the paper towel - easier to transport the can and not dump it by accident).

Re: Best Top Finish ?

#6

Re: Best Top Finish ?

Don Stephan

So many finishes today use the word "lacquer" in the product name and/or description that it seems extremely vague.

Re: Best Top Finish ?

#7

Clint Searl

Varathane waterborne


Re: Best Top Finish ?

#8

Re: Best Top Finish ?

Yonak

Don, Sherwin Williams Sher-Wood Hi-Bild Precat lacquer is what I have on hand for cabinets and I would use it if I go the lacquer route.

Re: Best Top Finish ?

#9

Shellac - hmmm

Yonak

David, I'm not familiar with using shellac for finishing. Do you spray it thinned and many coats like lacquer ? Does it lay well ?

Re: Best Top Finish ?

#10

Re: Best Top Finish ?

Clementine

Polyurethane over a light paint color will yellow the color. If the color is white or pastel, it looks really bad.

Re: Best Top Finish ?

#11

Re: Shellac - hmmm

David Weaver

you can spray it, pad it or brush it. I generally don't spray it because I don't have a separate finishing room and don't want overspray on things, but generally apply it however you'd like, and typically apply a wax over the last coat when you're done.

https://i.imgur.com/LAyV1Hk.jpg

I'd imagine that among most folks doing large items, spraying is most common.

It's true that its durability isn't nearly as good as poly or crosslinked WB finishes, etc, but it's also true that quick repairs of just about anything minor are near zero effort. 30 years from now, if you wipe over a water spot the same way I described, the finish would adhere as if the last coat was laid down 2 hours ago.

I wouldn't use it for a surface that gets wet a lot (like a table top, though it would do OK as long as sweating cups weren't placed on the table top), but for everything else, the false sense that taking zero damage over 40 years is the most important metric is just that to me - it's a false sense on furniture that stays in my house because I can touch it up without guessing what it is or what repair method is needed.

Re: Best Top Finish ?

#12

I wouldn't call that a false sense...

John in NM

Its the conclusion of those who have had to fix old finishes :D

I've seen shellac that has failed after ~30 years or less. The cracking pattern is distinctive, so if you know it the solution is easy enough, just coat with more shellac would be my first try. Probably that would repair the old finish and then you'd have to lay on a nice version over the top - pad or spray.

The piece I saw it on I didn't know what it was until years later. Never liked that thing anyway, it was a table lamp my mother bought in the 70's, probably dated to the 1950's or early 60's.

Re: Best Top Finish ?

#13

cracking....

David Weaver

..I guess it depends on the item and where it starts and where it goes.

Cracking is very common in old guitars first finished with lacquer because the makers didn't use softer lacquer with plasticizer. I don't personally like the look, but now people do it on purpose.

I think when someone is building in their own house with an item that will stay in the house, we're not likely to see this. Especially now in the days of household climate control.

That said, if your table originated in the northeast or PNW and made it to NM, I wouldn't be surprised to see it craze. saw a canadian guitar maker at one point who liked to camp in the GWN (great white north) and designated one of his guitars his camping guitar. It looked like a car windshield that'd been smashed by a hammer all over.

Re: Best Top Finish ?

#14

alternative if you want to use WB..

David Weaver

..though my WB opinion isn't any better than anyone else's.

I've done shellac as a transition coat over oil and then sprayed target finishes over the shellac for years and never had an issue. The shellac makes for a nice tone, and the crosslinked target finishes (EM6000 types) haven't looked hazy and with crosslinker, they're very hard (much harder to buff and sand).

What I can vouch for is that if you spray them in a non-controlled area, the haze of overspray is dry before it lands and you can blow it away with a leaf blower or sweep it. Much different than finishes with a longer open time that land and cure slowly and become very difficult to get off of any innocent bystanding kids toys near the garage door.