WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

OT-Paint

Posts

OT-Paint

#1

OT-Paint

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Trying to decide between Benny Moore and Sherman Williams for flat wall paint. Anyone have real experience as to which is more durable for cleaning scuffs and such?

TIA

Re: OT-Paint

#2

No, but...

Henry (Raleigh NC)

SW has about 7 grades of interior wall paint (not that I have ever counted).

Comparisons need to be made among at least comparable cost paints.

Re: OT-Paint

#3

Re: OT-Paint

David Weaver

I don't know of any flat wall paints that will be good for cleaning scuffs (they are like sandpaper).

I like SW paints the most (they build fast/cover well, and you just more or less lay them on and don't have to play much with them), but that said, they also are one of the least durable in my experience (which only comes into question if something runs into them). In my house, even with paint that was installed over primer in new construction, they will give way due to kid impact (toys running into them, etc) and need touch up.

Re: OT-Paint

#4

Clint Searl

Re: OT-Paint

Clint Searl

Consumer Reports always rates BM or Behr near/at the top. Behr usually costs less.

Re: OT-Paint

#5

JL

Re: OT-Paint

JL

I wouldn't go w/ a flat paint for ease of cleaning. A satin (AKA eggshell) finish is recommended for that.

My personal preferences for paint are either Benjamin Moore or Sherwin Williams satin finish w/ a slight preference for Sherwin Williams.

Re: OT-Paint

#6

The problem with experience

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Paint manufacturers reformulate with such frequency that historical information may be unreliable.

Cost will be an indication. The more durable chemistry costs more to make.

Re: OT-Paint

#7

Re: OT-Paint

Ralph Lipeles

Over the years I have found that Benjamin Moore is the best. I haven't painted in a while so I do not know if they are still on top.

Re: OT-Paint

#8

Thanks All

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Going with SW eggshell. Memsahib wants to be able to wipe stuff off.

Re: OT-Paint

#9

I agree with Ralph ...

Michael Farinella

I used BM many years ago and was amazed on the quality of the product (finishing paint).

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.