WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Period Styled Sideboard Finished

Posts

Period Styled Sideboard Finished

#1

Alan Young

Period Styled Sideboard Finished

Alan Young

About six months ago I was asked if I could make a revised version of this piece.


The client wanted it sized to fit a specific location in her home. She wanted the details to remain-except the twisted carvings on the corners and wood to replace the marble Top. I submitted this design:


Sideboard in Solid Mahogany and Mahogany Veneers. Red Mahogany Stain,Toned Shellac, Trim highlights: Arteza Metallic Acrylic colors mixed and applied by my wife-Eileen M Young.Here is the final result photographed this weekend in the client's home:





Re: Period Styled Sideboard Finished

#2

comments

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Period Furniture makers are not doing well. If they would broaden their horizons a bit and modernize Period designs as you have done on this piece I think they would have more work. You have kept the basic design of the piece, which is well designed, but nudged it from a great aunts musty parlor to a place where it would be at home in her great niece's living room. It is a delight to see the evolution.

Even the finish, reminiscent of classic Cordovan Mahogany, is modernized in this piece. Personally, I am not fond of this shade in Mahogany, preferring the browner effect one gets from yellow dye stain followed by redish brown dye stain, then oil.

I don't think the desire for fine furniture with classic lines has disappeared. Rather furniture makers have not adopted these designs to modern simpler tastes. Your success with this piece illustrates the opportunity.

Federal Furniture is an excellent candidate to modernize. Largely stripped of its embellishments it too would be accepted by modern tastes, I think.

Re: Period Styled Sideboard Finished

#3

Re: comments

John Jardin

Outstanding in both design and craftsmanship

Re: Period Styled Sideboard Finished

#4

What Bill said

David Yoho

Alan, that's one handsome piece of furniture. Very well done!!

Re: Period Styled Sideboard Finished

#5

Wow!

Tony-Memphis

Very nice work!

Re: Period Styled Sideboard Finished

#6

Perfect Fit

Yonak

The only thing that could make it better is if there were a Rembrandt in that frame instead of a mirror.

Re: Period Styled Sideboard Finished

#7

Alan Young

Re: comments

Alan Young

I learned a lot building this piece. One "skill" I was required to refine was the ability to "hear" what the client really wanted. We exchanged a variety of e-mails in the process of building this sideboard. We did not argue or have conflict but there was a point where I found that my interpretation of the original design did not match hers in some of the details- particularly the trim inside the panels and around the drawers. In previous pieces in this genre-I have employed mica powders in gilding-I was thinking that mica powder gilding would be my go to technique for this piece. Then I remembered Clint S. suggesting gold leaf. I gave that some thought for this project but decided the required learning curve was more than I wanted to engage for this piece. So I used an amber shellac for the trim pieces.

The client wasn't wild about the result:


We had some e-mails and phone calls (She lives 70 miles away) to attempt to find agreement on what she was actually looking for. Sparing this post too many details it was finally solved by her saying the trim needed to mimic the hardware in color. My wife saved the day by ordering these Arteza Metallic Acrylic colors.


Eileen mixed a couple of these colors and arrived a a very good match-She also had the steady hand to apply the finish.


Re: Period Styled Sideboard Finished

#8

Re: comments

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If the last picture is representative of the actual color I do like it. Rich and elegant like the piece itself.

Thanks for the added detail on the trim "painting". It take some getting used to but it works to embellish in a tasteful way.

Re: Period Styled Sideboard Finished

#9

Alan Young

Re: comments

Alan Young

I appreciate the "Appreciation". This piece photographs so differently depending on the lighting. Whether photos were taken in my shop,my living room, outside the house or at the client's home it seems to have highlights that vary from setting to setting.

When we began negotiations I mailed her several finish samples-Mahogany, Sapele and Cherry all with a Spray lacquer finish. She chose the Mahogany finish which was much closer to the shading in my drawing:


Then about a month into construction she said she wanted the color to "match" a table she had. She brought a leaf from the table to me and I made a few samples to get a match to the leaf. She was not desperate to have the sideboard match exactly - My look is a tad "darker" than the table but is accurate in tone. This Mahogany was a bit frustrating to work with. The solid pieces took the original Red Mahogany Stain quite differently despite my efforts to make application in a consistent manner. This required the "toning" of Shellac with some Trans Tint dyes to get the solid lumber to match. Mixing sessions were interesting...

Re: Period Styled Sideboard Finished

#10

Re: Period Styled Sideboard Finished

AZ in Colorado Springs

Very nice! Thanks for the detailed explanations.

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.