WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Laminating differing species of wood question?

Posts

Laminating differing species of wood question?

#1

Laminating differing species of wood question?

Barry Irby

I am working a walnut bed for my son and DIL. I am running short of walnut and may have to make a trip to my stash about fifty miles away to get more. I have plenty of oak and poplar.

My question is can I laminate either of those to walnut to increase the strength of the part? Such as the side rail on the bed. Can I glue a 1 x 2 of oak to the walnut to serve as a ledge for the bed slats and to improve the strength of the rail? Or will they react differently to changes in the humidity?

Re: Laminating differing species of wood question?

#2

Re: Laminating differing species of wood question?

John Veerkamp

sure I know for certain that oak and walnut can be glued and laminated successfully. I made a mission style queen bed out of walnut and glued on ledgers

made from red oak to support the foundation and mattress. The bed is now about 10 years old and still solid(and heavy). If you are concerned about the glue holding by itself, you can reinforce it with screws thru the oak into the walnut rails. Be sure to predrill the oak.

Re: Laminating differing species of wood question?

#3

Re: Laminating differing species of wood question?

TomD

The key point is what do you expect in the way of seasonal, or relocation related, changes in humidity? If you live in a area where changes are gradual and mild that is one thing. Also well air conditioned spaces may be beneficial. But if you expect large changes, that could be a problem.

So some of the oaks are polar opposites in tangential shrinkage that walnut is. But some of them are really close. Walnut is 7.8, the red Oaks run 8-11, and poplar is in the 8 area.

I like to coat the ends with boat epoxy when I have have a structure I worry about. For instance, I use that trick instead of breadboards. Done properly it looks like either varnish or oil. But in something like side rails it would be hidden. The epoxy just soaks in, but you stop the gain and loss through the ends.

If you find an oak you want to use, you can give it the rusty water/vinegar treatment and it turns black, which will make it blend in with the walnut, since it will be on the back side anyway. This was done by a guy I suggested it to over the internet. He had this dull piece of red oak, and had never used the vinegaroon process before, turned out OK.


👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.