WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

Posts

A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

#1

A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.




I make what I make because somebody needs it. I will muster whatever skill I have, or can acquire, to come to an end. The petrified table is a case in point. In my mind I envisioned a table with arty legs that would hold the slab of petrified wood to become a functional table in the dining/sun room. My skill set is good engineering, acceptable execution of traditional joinery, and not proficient in design and sculpture.

Designing something to hold the slab was easy enough- four legs, some crossed stretches and points to capture the slab. The question was how “arty” I could make it. Limited success was the result. I am pleased with the shape of the leg and the outside profile. I had expected to profile the inside of the leg and here is where I ran out of ability. The challenge is where profiles meet in intersections. Copes and other techniques are employed for intersecting molding. I knew in advance it would be a daunting task to use these techniques on the stretcher to leg intersections. I did not further consider this possibility.

What I did consider was shaping the inside of the leg to flow into these joints. After failure to execute a satisfactory solution of many test joints I gave up and left the insides flat and the edges chamfered. (The chamfers do not show up in the picture. As a result the legs look a bit larger than in real life) I am simply not good at sculpture with a spoke shave.

The assembly is good enough and I’m done with it. A lesson learned a long time ago is to accept good enough. I wonder how many people could be making stuff that don’t because they have failed to come to terms with good enough. The table will meet the need and acceptable by most.

Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

#2

Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Very nice.

Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

#3

Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

John in NM

I remember reading once about a professional model maker, who said he never said to himself "good enough, I'll do better on the next one". Maybe he really did always view the execution of his work this way, but us mere mortals profit greatly from learning how to recognize the point of diminishing returns. We would never get anything done otherwise!

I like the table - I see what you mean about the intersection, but only other woodworkers will have any idea what you're talking about. I think you hit good enough pretty square on with that one. Solve the problem another couple times and you'll probably work out something clever and raise the bar on good enough.

Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

#4

Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

Don Stephan

With the top in place I see lots of very pleasing curves. A great result.

Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

#5

Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

Ray man. Home at.

Very nice. I would be proud to have that in my house.

Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

#6

Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

Barry Irby

Very nice table. In this case, to me, Good Enough really is good enough.

I was thinking about the problem of "thinking outside the box". Creativity. What is it? Can we learn it? I know you have admired some of Krenov's work. Is he really Creative or just in a different box than the rest of us? Is the Box your mind or is it your shop and the space and tools it contains? Or the materials available to you? Perhaps that petrified top tugged your creativity outside the box for a moment. Did you look at Krenov's work for inspiration? Some of his stands for his cabinets look like they might collapse in a gentle breeze. (To me)

Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

#7

Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bill, context is everything. When you first posted pictures of the legs I could not see where you were going, and wondered what you were doing. Now I see the result and I like it a lot. Anything too "arty" would have distracted from the top. The legs do the job. Simple and attractive.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

#8

ebd

Looks great to me!


Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

#9

Kneale Brownson

^^^This^^^  Better'n Good Enuff


Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

#10

I really like the way the bowed legs

Chuck Nickerson

and stretchers communicate the weight of the top. Nicely done!

Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

#11

Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Well done. The petrified wood is the star of the show. Any grander of a base would simply compete. You lifted the petrified wood gracefully and allowed it to be the focus of the piece. Mission well done.

T.

Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

#12

Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Some sculpturing of the upper leg, tapering it some from the inside, would refine the shape. But I rediscovered I have no talent for sculpturing with a spoke shave. I would like to see what you could do with this form if you ever needed to make a low table. One of your colorful wood assemblies for a top would be pretty.

Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

#13

Clint Searl

Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

Clint Searl

One measure of success is, " How much would you pay for it?"

Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

#14

What the art critic said

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have a friend that is both an artist and designer of Arts and Crafts furniture. She is not hesitant to be critical of my designs. Of my former proclivity for embellishment she would say, "what is that all about"! And it would be purged from the design.

She said,

"I think it looks perfect the way it is! Sculpting would be inappropriate. The top is the sculpture. “Less is more” as Mies van der Rohe says."

So, I guess I will continue to be satisfied and more so when the cherry colors up to better match the red in the petrified wood. Now it is on the designing a "modern" looking corner cupboard. Daughter was not smitten by the classic 18th century examples I hoped to make with crown molding, dentils, and divided glass doors. Thanks to the help offered here I have the framing worked out.

Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

#15

Clint Searl

De gustibus non est disputandum


Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

#16

Re: What the art critic said

Sgian Dubh

""Now it is on the designing a "modern" looking corner cupboard. Daughter was not smitten by the classic 18th century examples …"

But I guess something like this isn't to either yours, or her taste, ha, ha. Slainte.


img

Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

#17

I like it

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I think it would look better in rift cut ash though. What you posted I would describe as a display cabinet. What I was requested to make is storage for dinnerware and accessories. Daughter has specified that the door be no more than translucent glass.

Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

#18

Re: I like it

Sgian Dubh

That's kind of you Bill. You're right about it being a display corner cabinet. It was built to commission for my parents reasonably early in my career, therefore I 'inherited' it after they'd both died. The brief was to build a corner cabinet for a specific place to display dinner ware my mother valued: plates, tureens, serving dishes, that sort of thing.

Ash, I'm afraid was never a consideration because another specification was to build using oak harvested from my family farm. My father loved oak trees, and even when he grubbed out hedges to make bigger fields for the sake of efficient farming he could seldom bring himself to take out the oaks dotted along the length of the hedges. They remained as sentinels dotted around the larger fields he'd created although, even to this day, I can still pick out where the hedges were through tracing their route by the oaks still standing - my brother farms the place now, and it will no doubt pass on to my nephew in time.

So, my father being what he was, would generally only cut those oaks down when they had to really come down, e.g., lightning damaged or disease. To him, they were a source of usable wood to be milled, stickered and dried for some undefined future purpose. Some of it, as you see, became a corner cabinet. Yet more became a tambour topped drinks cabinet, another piece I 'inherited'. Slainte.

Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

#19

Clint Searl

Great design


Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

#20

Bent glass

GolfSteve in Calgary

Did you have trouble obtaining the bent glass?

Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

#21

Re: Great design

Sgian Dubh

Thanks, Clint. Slainte.

Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

#22

Re: Bent glass

Sgian Dubh

Actually Steve, the glass around the corner isn't curved. It's two straight narrow pieces of equal width per corner separated by a slim vertical wooden astragal. So, on this occasion, there's no curved glass. Slainte.

Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

#23

A way of glazing a curved door

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


I used the same approach in these doors. At first glance they look like they have curved glass, but don't. The lady that cut the glass took great care in fitting the pieces and the result was so tight the glass became structural as if it was one piece.

Re: A tale of limitations- Petrified Wood Table

#24

Love It!

Don Orr

Simply elegant and functional.

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.