Re: Scarf joints
E Phillip Smith
This reminds me of a story my dad told me decades ago when I was in high school.
When dad was a young carpenter back in the 50's they were remodeling a house on Green Street in Gainesville, Ga. The street is lined large 2 story homes owned by the mill owners and other well to do in the day. The boss had recently hired a new lead finish carpenter, after a couple days on the job the new guy came down the stairs cussing up a storm carrying his tool bag. He had been fired that day. Just behind him came the boss also cussing up a storm saying among other things that if had to use caulk on trim you were not a finish carpenter. That's the day dad became lead finish carpenter. Never seen him use caulk to hide a crack on trim.
The trick to trim is to hide the crack. It's almost impossible to get perfect cuts on every piece and not have them open up when nailed. The trick is to slightly undercut the joints so there is a small clearance (crack) on the back side, so when the trim is nailed the face pulls up tight. When cutting by hand block plane is your friend.