Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

OT - tankless water heater

Posts

OT - tankless water heater

#1

OT - tankless water heater

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

Bear with me on this one please. I've seen numerous discussions of tankless on-demand water heaters here over the years.

Here's the backstory. I have two conventional 40 gallon water heaters in series. The first one does the majority of the work and fails twice as often as the second unit. I recently changed out my two furnaces to high efficiency condensing type, which left me with the two water heaters orphaned venting into a now oversized common flue in the chimney (previously shared with the furnaces). During very cold weather, this results in back drafting on the water heater vents. The solution is to install a smaller diameter vent in the chimney. My first water heater in series is now over 10 years old and probably about due to fail, if past performance over the last 30 years is any indication.

I'm faced with a choice of putting a smaller liner in the chimney to solve the backdraft situation, or just put in a direct vent tankless water heater and abandon the chimney vent and conventional water heaters altogether. The installed cost of a new conventional water heater and the chimney liner is about the same as the installed cost of a Navien tankless water heater.

I have no inherent preference for one or the other, but am clueless about the longevity of a tankless unit. Has anyone lived with a tankless water heater long enough to have a feel for the probable lifespan? I'm looking to reduce maintenance issues as I get older. I've lived with the dual tank-type heaters with no performance issues. If I can get longer maintenance free life out of a tankless system, I'd prefer that. And what brand did you use? Anyone have a Navien?

Just looking for recommendations from the collective brain trust that lives here.

Thanks in advance.

Re: OT - tankless water heater

#2

Re: OT - tankless water heater

Ian Neuhaus

Earlier this year I sold a house with a tankless (on demand) water heater.

The heater was installed in 1999 and was still going strong when the house was sold.

Issues you may care to consider.

When there is a blackout, or the main breaker trips (or is switched) the water heater needs to be reset.

In my area on demand heaters must have adjustable thermostats -- very hot water (140+ degrees) for the kitchen, not so hot water (about 110 degrees) in the bathroom and/or laundry.

Remote controls for adjusting the temperature are recommended.

Re: OT - tankless water heater

#3

Re: OT - tankless water heater

David Yoho

I installed a Rinnai tankless several years ago. Because it runs on natural gas, my electric bill decreased and my gas bill is very low. There are a few things to consider regarding tankless water heaters.

After a power outage mine comes back on and has not needed to be programmed again. Perhaps there are some that do. The electrician told me that because it doesn't require much power to operate I could plug it into the AC outlet in my truck during a power outage and it would work fine.

It is advisable to clean and flush the inner plumbing once a year to prevent a build up of scale and such that can develop depending on your water supply. The homeowner can do this with the right pump and chemical or the plumbing contractor can.

The big issue with tankless heaters is how long it takes for hot water to get to a faucet at the other end of the house. I think they've resolved this by adding a recirculating device to the plumbing.

The good news is a heater like mine will deliver constant hot water to 4 places at the same time without noticeable change in temperature. A standard water heater can't do this for long.

As far as longevity, we haven't had ours long enough to speak to that but my wife's aunt in Florida has. Hers is over 10 years old and still going strong. In fact, it's an outside unit, which makes sense in a warm climate state. I'm pretty sure she's never had the unit flushed but it's still working great.

Re: OT - tankless water heater

#4

Re: OT - tankless water heater

Ian Neuhaus

David commented: The big issue with tankless heaters is how long it takes for hot water to get to a faucet at the other end of the house.

Depending on how your house is laid out, the other way of dealing with this is to install more than one heater. Rather than one large heater serving the whole house, smaller heaters can be located close to each bathroom or either end of your house.

Of course each unit needs to vent to the outside.

Re: OT - tankless water heater

#5

Re: OT - tankless water heater

Steve jenkins

One thing to consider is flow rate at lower input water temperatures. The colder the water going into the heater the lower the flow rate to heat it to a given temp. My brother ended up having to use a standard water heater to preheat in order to get good enough flow for a good shower. It may be that his tankless was sized too small. That is something to confirm prior to purchasing.

Re: OT - tankless water heater

#6

Re: Possible low cost option!

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

It may be quite easy to correct the back draft issue! I have solved several problems like this by installing a directional chimney cap. Last one I installed was for a customer that had a multi-story commercial building that also had some apartments in the upper floors.

The renter had problems with the older furnace pilot light being blown out often. My customer had more than one contractor work on the problem with no help. I checked the furnace and found it to be properly adjusted and looked at the chimney!

I found the issue was due to the building construction and the variable wind directions on the roof that caused the downdraft. I changed the chimney cap and had no more issues in at least 4 or 5 years I know about!

This is not the brand I used but is similar to the design - they are available for Metalbestos, plain pipe, brick chimneys etc.

Re: OT - tankless water heater

#7

Re: OT - "Perfect" timing

Gary Smyth

Standard water heater -- eleven years old -- blew three days ago. Spent the last two days looking at alternatives. PA passed new laws concerning water heaters and the price jumped almost $300 from eight months ago. Gas in place. With the increase in price tankless looking better but no one can tell me in comparison if they will last as long or longer than the traditional unit. Venting is not a problem nor is distance. My age is a concern as I don"t want t worry about the expense less than ten years forward. {Think the tariffs will still be in place?) Would you bite the bullet for unlimited hotter than typical house water?

Re: OT - tankless water heater

#8

Re: OT - "Perfect" timing

Barry Irby

One thing to check is how much gas is available. The heaters I see on larger houses have a huge demand. I have seen water heaters that use 175,000 btu firing rates while the furnace for the house only demanded 80,000 BTUH. And you have to have enough gas flow to fire both at the same time.

Also, some very large heaters won't do well heating a small amount of water. They have to have significant flow of water to trigger the firing of the heating burners.

My info may be slightly out of date, but it's worth checking.

Re: OT - tankless water heater

#9

Are electric heaters different?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have had water heaters outlast my stay in two houses >20 years. A single 80 gal heater was never taxed by our family of 4. Our family of 2 with occasionally 6 more visiting has never demanded more than our current 50 gal heater provides.

Why are two heaters in series necessary?

Re: OT - tankless water heater

#10

Re: Are electric heaters different?

Barry Irby

Bill, you must have excellent water, from the water heater's point of view. the chemistry must very low in corrosiveness.

Locally, gas heaters outperform electric ones both in output and longevity. Common for gas heaters to last 25 years but electric ones usually last about half that. I have wondered about that.

Recently the government required an upgrade in the insulation on both. This has created a problem for many who have their heaters in tight spaces. On one of my rentals I had to replace a 40 gallon gas unit with a 30 gallon one. With only two people living there it has been successful.

I will have to check with some of my fellow home inspectors to see if they have worked some of the bugs out of the on demand heaters. There has been a huge learning curve, both for the builders and plumbers and for the industry.

Re: OT - tankless water heater

#11

water chemistry

John in NM

What gets us out here is the scale. One place I live has a ton of gypsum in the water, the other has calcium carbonate. I prefer the carbonate as the tap water tastes a bit better and the gypsum is harder on plumbing. Water heaters seem to last about 10 years under normal use.

I've seen mention of special dip tubes that help stir up the sediment as new water comes into the heater, but I doubt they work - doesn't take scale long to be too hard to stir up!

Re: OT - tankless water heater

#12

My two heaters...

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

I have two heaters primarily due to a large whirlpool tub in the master bath, that realistically only gets used a few times a year as a fun pool by the grandkids. I've seen dual heaters plumbed both ways, in parallel and in series. Both seem to work just fine to provide the volume of water needed on the large tubs, plus we never run out of hot water for consecutive showers. I've replaced three conventional heaters over the 30 years I've lived there. Two were the first in the pair and one was the secondary unit. These are Bradford White pro-installed models.

In my river house, I just replaced a 32 year old unit that started leaking. No idea why I get 30 years in one location and 10 years in another. Both places have about identical hardness.

Re: OT - tankless water heater

#13

Re: My two heaters...

Barry Irby

Could it be that you don't use as much water at the river house? Corrosion is related to volume as well as hardness. And, if the River house heater does not cycle as often it may have taken longer for the anode rod to die and for the glass lining to fail. Life of the anode would be related to volume.

Re: OT - tankless water heater

#14

Re: My two heaters...

John Veerkamp

Around my part of the country, anode rods need to be replaced between 7 and 10 years. Dip tubes will also deteriorate and can be replaced. The dip tube function is to keep the sediment stirred instead of settling to the bottom causing problems with both electric and gas heaters.