OT - tankless water heater
Tim Greif - West of Chicago
Bear with me on this one please. I've seen numerous discussions of tankless on-demand water heaters here over the years.
Here's the backstory. I have two conventional 40 gallon water heaters in series. The first one does the majority of the work and fails twice as often as the second unit. I recently changed out my two furnaces to high efficiency condensing type, which left me with the two water heaters orphaned venting into a now oversized common flue in the chimney (previously shared with the furnaces). During very cold weather, this results in back drafting on the water heater vents. The solution is to install a smaller diameter vent in the chimney. My first water heater in series is now over 10 years old and probably about due to fail, if past performance over the last 30 years is any indication.
I'm faced with a choice of putting a smaller liner in the chimney to solve the backdraft situation, or just put in a direct vent tankless water heater and abandon the chimney vent and conventional water heaters altogether. The installed cost of a new conventional water heater and the chimney liner is about the same as the installed cost of a Navien tankless water heater.
I have no inherent preference for one or the other, but am clueless about the longevity of a tankless unit. Has anyone lived with a tankless water heater long enough to have a feel for the probable lifespan? I'm looking to reduce maintenance issues as I get older. I've lived with the dual tank-type heaters with no performance issues. If I can get longer maintenance free life out of a tankless system, I'd prefer that. And what brand did you use? Anyone have a Navien?
Just looking for recommendations from the collective brain trust that lives here.
Thanks in advance.



