I've just finished an oak bookcase and oiled it with several coats of Watco oil natural. I've been using the stuff for years and never had a problem until now. It won't dry properly. After sitting for 2 weeks, it's still a bit sticky. I'm thinking it's old (despite the fact this was a new can from the store) - and I believe there's a way of decoding the production date from numbers on the can. Where will I find that info and are there any suggestions as to how I can get this to dry properly.
If you don't wipe it dry between each coat it will be sticky.
I apply the first coat, wait about 20-30 minutes, wipe it off completely and let dry for at least 24 hours, better, 48. The first coat will soak into the wood grain a bit if it can so it needs to dry longer than the next coats.
I apply subsequent coats the same way and let dry overnight. For woodturnings I apply 6-10 coats. For a smoother surface I wet sand with oil on some coats. I have no idea how many coats would be good for a bookcase.
If it wasn't wiped off completely, you can probably wipe off the sticky coat with mineral spirits or sometimes, just a bit of the "oil" from the can, let that dry then continue.
You might test the product - put a little on a piece of glass and see if it dries/hardens in a couple of days. If not, toss it.
Best Watco I ever used was a half full gallon can that had been sitting around for 10 years.... I figured that like linseed oil it had slowly pre-polymerized, taking up small amounts of oxygen I think. It was thicker than new Watco and seemed to cure harder and form a film.
I bet your problem is related to temperature (low?), humidity (high?), application (left too heavy?) or a combination of these factors.
Oil went on to clean wood, brushed on and allowed to sit for half hour or so then all the excess was wiped off. It sat for 24 hours then another coat was brushed on and the excess was wiped off. That sat for a week then steel wool with another coat and wiped dry. Humidity was around 30%, temp about 70f.
Still sticky but sounds like old age of the oil is not a problem. FWIW 10 year old Watco was a slightly different formula I think.
Guess I'll just have to live with it but I will try the drop or two on a piece of glass and see what happens.
If you can get it someplace warmer than 70 that will help. Next time use wipe on varnish. In fact you can overcoat what you have with wipe on after removing excess with a rag dampened with a bit of solvent. I have not used Watco in many years. I just use "boiled" linseed oil. It takes a couple of weeks to cure.
BTW, as long as it smells of oil it is still curing.
Question? If you wiped off the excess what is left to be sticky?
Try scrubbing with gray stotchbrite and naphtha to remove as much sticky as possible followed by a naphtha wipedown. Dry for a few hours. Re-oil and wipe down completely.
Conventional wisdom that flooding the surface will increase penetration is wrong. The polymerizing factors in the finish never penetrate more than a mm or so, and as the first coat does polymerize, it impedes any penetration of subsequent applications.