Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

More Shellac / Finishing Questions

Posts

More Shellac / Finishing Questions

#1

More Shellac / Finishing Questions

Stuart Johnson

I have a can of Bulls Eye clear shellac that is a few years old. How do I tell if it's still good? The can says it can be tinted with universal colorant. What is that and how do you tell what color is needed? My bookcase is red oak and I would like to darken it more toward brown. If it makes any difference I have better results spraying and would like to reach the desired color as was suggested earlier with the shellac and then top with lacquer.

Re: More Shellac / Finishing Questions

#2

Re: More Shellac / Finishing Questions

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Bulls Eye is a "waxy" shellac as opposed the SealCoat which is "dewaxed". The difference is 2-fold.

1. Waxy shellac, while favored for some finishes, presents adhesion problems with many top coats, especially waterborne finishes like the acrylic lacquers.

2. As a durable finish, the amount of esterification must be determined, The shellac finish ages in the can and may not set up hard. Pour some onto a glass plate and allow to dry overnight. If it scrapes or abrades into power it is still usable. Otherwise pitch it. If good, it will still present adhesion issues.

3. Dewaxed shellac will not present adhesion issues, but is still subject to degradation with age. Test before using.

4. Using shellac as a sealer/toner under other top coats is subject to "cold checking" of the shellac where the shellac layer literally fractures under the top coat. You must, therefore, keep your shellac fresh and as thin a coating as possible.

From the description, some preliminary use of stain may get you closer to your goal. You can then seal the stain with a light coat of dewaxed shellac, and top coat with whatever you wish. The shellac will prevent the top coat from lifting the stain.

Re: More Shellac / Finishing Questions

#3

Question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A book case is not an easy object to spray. Lots of inside corners that are hard to coat uniformly. Spraying a tinting lacquer or shellac, I don't see that it makes any difference, and getting the application uniform on a bookcase will be a daunting task. Why are you avoiding the vastly easier route to coloring oak -a wipe-on stain?

Re: More Shellac / Finishing Questions

#4

Re: Question

Stuart Johnson

The few times I've tried using a stain that you apply and then wipe off I've had very uneven results. I thought if I found something I could spray that didn't need to be wiped off it might turn out better.

The bookcase is a prototype or leaning project leading to a couple for my wife's sewing studio. I've made a few mistakes in the construction that I now know how to avoid so I would like to do the same with the finish.

Re: More Shellac / Finishing Questions

#5

Try a different kind of stain, or dye.

Dick Coers

I'm guessing you mainly tried Minwax stain? Try a professional stain from a Sherwin-Williams store. Campbell's Wind Song was my favorite when I had to stain wood for customers.

As far as the old shellac, throw it out. Not worth causing trouble with the finishing process for less than $15. It takes way to long to get a project done, then mess it up so you save a few bucks!

Re: More Shellac / Finishing Questions

#6

Re: Question

David Yoho

The few times I've tried using a stain that you apply and then wipe off I've had very uneven results.

I agree with Bill about the difficulty with spraying a bookcase and would also suggest coloring the wood directly and then top coating it. The idea of applying the color via a sprayed sealant (shellac or lacquer), while appealing, would be problematic in this case.

I think the reason you have experienced problems before with applying stain to red oak is probably due to using a pigmented stain. Red oak is one of those woods with open pores that pigment loves to get into and cause the finished appearance to look uneven. I find the best thing to use for a wood like this is a dye. You can use either a powder dye you mix yourself or a liquid like Transtint. Just follow the directions and experiment. A dye will give you a much more even look and can be wiped, brushed, or sprayed on.

Re: More Shellac / Finishing Questions

#7

See any unevenness in this stain?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.



It is Minwax. But it matters not what stain it is, I would get the same result. Note that even the end grain of the dovetails is not overly dark.


Here is a book shelf my 9 year old granddaughter stained. Again Minwax.

It is neither the stain nor the person staining that leads to these results. rather it is the sanding and application. Ask if interested and I will repeat what I have said before about using pigment stain.

Re: More Shellac / Finishing Questions

#8

Wiping/Blotching

Don Stephan

One possible outcome some find undesirable, when hand applying a dye or stain, is uneven absorption, unfortunately termed "blotching." Cherry is generally considered especially prone to this.

Some areas of a cherry surface are able to absorb more liquid than others, and if given the opportunity will do so. If color is sprayed as a stain or in finish as a toner, all areas of the surface receive the same amount of colorant so there is no opportunity for the more thirsty areas to absorb more. Apply colorant by wiping or rubbing and the more thirsty areas have the opportunity to absorb more.

Not all woods are subject to blotching. If unsure, test on a leftover piece from the same project.

In discussions about spraying bookcases and similar, a common suggestion was to leave the back off and spray both separately for a more even application, then apply the back.