Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

How would you repair this spindle

Posts

How would you repair this spindle

#1

How would you repair this spindle

john lucas

I've done a lot of chair repairs over the years but this one needs something a little different. I usually dissassemble the chair and reglue everything with the new spindle. This chair is really solid so I would rather not do that. Sometimes when taking chairs like this apart I've broken 1 or more spindle because the wood is brittle. What I'm toying with is possible a long scarf joint in the wood. Make the spindle about 1/8" too long to compensate for the saw kerf and then cut the spindle at a long angle so I'll have a fair amount of side grain to side grain glue joint. Then just insert the tenons in the holes and squeeze the joint together and wrap it with string until the glue dries. I've got 2 spindles to replace.


Re: How would you repair this spindle

#2

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: How would you repair this spindle

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Make a new spindle. At the top rail, deepen the hole for the (new) spindle. Insert the new spindle, top first, so that it goes deep enough to allow the bottom of it to be inserted into the bottom rail. No mid-spindle joint, and no noticeable repair.

Re: How would you repair this spindle

#3

Re: How would you repair this spindle

Philip Duffy

--Add to Jim's reply; I steam bent a spindle for a chair and slide it into place while bent then straightened it in place. My sister was thrilled! Philip

Re: How would you repair this spindle

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

Ditto Mr Delaney

Jack Guzman from Maine

John ,I have done that exact thing. It is the method I would also recommend.---Jack

Re: How would you repair this spindle

#5

Re: How would you repair this spindle

Barry Irby

I would consider two approaches.

If I could drill the hole on one end deeper without compromising the integrity of the post, I might make the two spindles, insert one end deeper and the slide it back into the other end's hole/mortise.

Or, I might try a paper joint. make up blanks with a very long scarf joint with a piece of paper in them joint. Perhaps and 1/8" or a 1/16" too long, split it along the paper, scrap the joint clean, insert the two pieces int the respective mortises/holes and re-glue the scarf joint. If I understand the chair these two pieces won't show much. Looks like you could use a woven seat, which would hide the repair completely. But other types of seats will cover it also.

You could also make a 1 x 2 with an offset tenon on each end for the repair. And a scarf joint. Just round over the front edge.

Re: How would you repair this spindle

#6

Re: Ditto Mr Delaney

john lucas

I've done that before but I'm not sure there is enough room on this chair. I'll measure it before I start and see if that's possible.

Re: How would you repair this spindle

#7

DUH why didn't I think of the paper joint

john lucas

I do paper joints all the time. I use white vinegar to get all the glue and paper off. slower than scraping but doesnt change the integrity of the joint at all. This will be covered by a woven seat so the joint will really never show.

Re: How would you repair this spindle

#8

the myth of needing to remove all the glue

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In some unpublished data, from a reputable source, it was found, no too surprising, that new Titebond glue bonds to cured glue with nearly identical strength. There is no reason it should not. All the new glue has to accomplish is to soften the first few micron layer of the old glue. The new glue molecules will entangle with those of the old, once the old are put in motion by softening, and the bond will form.

Obviously there can't be any lumps of old glue or paper that will prevent perfect mating.

I have no idea what the vinegar application does, if anything. I have never used it to remove old glue. I will have to do some tests to see what it does. It may be that it dissolves into the old glue to soften it and aid re-bonding.

Re: How would you repair this spindle

#9

Re: How would you repair this spindle

Don Stephan

If I am reading the picture correctly, the two missing spindles form the front and side of the seat. When people sit and get up, is more of the person's weight placed on the front spindle?

My image of a scarf joint is grain the entire length of the piece at an angle to the axis of the spindle. My understanding of chair bodgers is that they split out wood for the legs and spindles, so the grain would be parallel to the axis of the spindle, for maximum strength and resistance to splitting.

Perhaps I am the only one concerned about diagonal grain the length of the front and side seat spindles.

Re: How would you repair this spindle

#10

Vinegar....

Barry Irby

I am not a chemist at all, but if I leave a glue brush sitting out, forgetting to wash it out, and it hardens I know I can stick it in a vinegar solution and it will soften overnight. OTOH, if I stick it in a container of hot water, it will soften also, and either way I can clean the brush and use it again. I have not tried all the possible permutations.

John, I like the idea of the rectangular or oval shaped piece concealed in the seat. I think that would be stronger than new. You could do an offset turning , making the dowels/tenons on the same side, then angle rip it and glue it back together in place. Taper the rip to be behind the tenon on one end and in front of it on the other. Then spokeshave it to shape. My spidie sense tells me this would work and be stronger than a dowel. Use straight grained oak. OTOH, the original lasted a long time, but people are a lot fatter now.

Re: How would you repair this spindle

#11

Re: Vinegar....

David Yoho

I'm assuming the glue in question is yellow glue. Like Bill, I'm not sure what the vinegar does for it. However, whenever I've needed to take apart joinery or pieces where hide glue was used, I brush on hot water or vinegar until it comes apart. Both will dissolve protein, of which hide glue consists.

Re: How would you repair this spindle

#12

Re: Vinegar....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

vinegar makes sense for hide glue. It will protonate the amines on the protein and make then water soluble.

Re: How would you repair this spindle

#13

Re: Vinegar....

john lucas

The vinegar softens the glue so it will be easily removed. This also in this case make it easier to get rid of all the paper residue. In some of my turnings the split paper joint will actually show so all of the glue needs to be removed.

Barry I am of course a wood turner so I cut the scarf joint while the wood is square. I glued it back together with the paper joint while it was square. I'll turn it in the next few days. I put the scarf joint a little off center. It's a long joint so should have a lot of long grain to long grain glue contact so I think it will be very strong.

Re: How would you repair this spindle

#14

Excellent, post a pic


Re: How would you repair this spindle

#15

Re: How would you repair this spindle

Tony - Memphis

Well, if you really want to get fancy, make the spindle as usual. Saw it between two beads. Drill a hole in each cut face. Insert a small spring in one hole. Insert a floating tenon who's length is such that the spring will push it into the other mortise/hole such that it will bridge the cut. Use lots of glue of course.

Tony

Re: How would you repair this spindle

#16

Re: Vinegar....

John in NM

I've seen vinegar used on PVA joints needing to be disassembled before, but it didn't seem to be much quicker or effective than just water. I always assumed it was a technique held over from hide glue where it's use is more effective than water alone.

Re: How would you repair this spindle

#17

Re: How would you repair this spindle

Larry Barrett

I agree with Don. The four spindles (I would call them rungs) - the two you are replacing plus the two remaining - will have to support the entire weight of whoever sits in the chair. So maybe 50 lbs each if a 200 lb man sits down. I would only use straight grain wood, rived would be best. And if necessary drill the mortise all the way through a leg to allow a new rung to be inserted. The mortises are already nearly all the way through; the tenon, when inserted, will make the leg 'whole' again. Plus there is no stress on the posts, except straight down.

Do you still have the broken rungs? If so, you might examine them to determine how they failed. It is often the case that they were turned from something less than rived wood. Grain runout is often a clue to rung failure in chair seats.