Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Dovetail saw smack down LV vs LN; 20 vs 14 tpi

Posts

Dovetail saw smack down LV vs LN; 20 vs 14 tpi

#1

Dovetail saw smack down LV vs LN; 20 vs 14 tpi

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Dovetail saw smack down LV vs LN; 20 vs 14 tpi


I have recently finished dovetailing 8 drawers, about 100 dovetails. In almost all cases the parts mated acceptable right off the saw with no corrective paring. During the process I switched randomly between 3 dovetail saws- Lie Neilsen 15 tpi rip, Lee Valley 14 tpi rip and Lee Valley 20 tpi rip.

Conditions- The drawer sides were poplar, sawing both sides together for a 7/8 to 1” total thickness. Fronts were cherry (half blind) and backs were poplar or cherry 7/16 or ½”. For reasons that will be revealed in a later post the sides were sawed with the saw nearly perpendicular to the length of the side (parallel to bench, directly into the end grain) while the drawer ends were sawed with the saw at various angles as the cut progressed.

Judgement criteria- Smoothness of cut is irrelevant in a dovetail cut and rough may be better than smooth. Tracking, the tendency of the saw to continue heading in the direction it starts is important. Speed of cut is not of great importance for drawer parts but could be for chests and cases that may have a lot of dovetails in thick parts. Smoothness is important for accurate starting the cut without bouncing and effort in continuing the cut.

Prejudices- I was not enamored with the looks of the LV saws when they came out but decided to give them a chance when I got to try one at IWF. I thought 20 tpi saws were for sissies and builders of doll house furniture.

Results- All saws tracked equivalent as far as I noticed. Surprisingly, I did not see significant, for the task at hand, difference in speed. Where they differed was in smoothness in starting and sawing, that is to say how “grabby” they were in the wood. The 20 tpi saw was like slicing bread with a bread knife. It cut smoothly and effortlessly. There was more resistance with the LV 14 tpi and I got an occasional bounce when sawing directly into the end grain. The LN saw differed greatly. It bounced when sawing directly into end grain on the ends of the ganged drawer sides. This feature made starting the saw imprecise and sawing was often not smooth as the teeth grabbed into the end grain. Dropping the handle so the saw was not sawing directly into the end grain lessened this annoyance, but this was not the way I preferred to saw the tails.

Ergonomics- In spite of the different looks I had no preference in the feel of the saw when holding it.

Conclusion- For what I was sawing and how I sawed it the LV 20 tpi saw was a clear favorite. It may or may not be for your work. However, these results suggest this saw should be a consideration for anyone making dovetail drawers.

Re: Dovetail saw smack down LV vs LN; 20 vs 14 tpi

#2

Re: Dovetail saw smack down LV vs LN; 20 vs 14 tpi

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Good info Bill. Thanks. I have an LV saw but almost never use it. Truth be told however, I typically use Japanese saws. But the LV saw looks like a well thought out tool.

T.

Re: Dovetail saw smack down LV vs LN; 20 vs 14 tpi

#3

Dovetail saw smack down LV vs LN; 20 vs 14 tpi

Tom Colligan

Thanks, Bill.

The LN saw looks just like you'd want a saw to look like and that's why I have one. But, to be honest, I seem to get better results with other saws like the Japanese ones.

Re: Dovetail saw smack down LV vs LN; 20 vs 14 tpi

#4

Re: Dovetail saw smack down LV vs LN; 20 vs 14 tpi

Don Stephan

Very happy with the LN dovetail saw. I may use the saw differently than you are describing.

Re: Dovetail saw smack down LV vs LN; 20 vs 14 tpi

#5

Re: Dovetail saw smack down LV vs LN; 20 vs 14 tpi

Stuart Hough

Bill, Thanks for the comparo! My wife bought me the three saw set from LV for Christmas three years ago (what a great wife!). I received both the 14 tpi and 20 tpi rip dovetail saws and the 14 tpi cross-cut saw. I have used all three saws over the last three years, and I concur with your assessment. The 20 tpi saw starts much smoother than the 14 tpi saw, and helped this neophyte to produce some very nice dovetails. Both tracked very well, even with my limited experience. The cross-cut saw tracked equally as well, as long as I paid close attention to the fundamentals. I am extremely pleased with these saws ( and, of course, the wife)!

Re: Dovetail saw smack down LV vs LN; 20 vs 14 tpi

#6

Re: Dovetail saw smack down LV vs LN; 20 vs 14 tpi

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bill, as you may recall, I reviewed these saws in years past. Mine are no longer original since I have sharpened them. Nevertheless, I have a good memory, plus my notes, to jog me.

My recall is that the saws are all different. The difference comes out with the hardness and thickness of the wood. The Veritas 20 tpi is best for thin boards, say around 1/4", where thicker would be a slower cut. I recognise that you did not find this to be so with much thicker stuff, and I am trying to understand why. Certainly, the Veritas 14 tpi is a faster saw. Both the Veritas saws have a 14 degree rake on their teeth, and this makes for a softer start, but also a less aggressive sawing.

The LN 15 tpi dovetail saw generally is an aggressive cutter as it has close to zero rake. This also makes it grabby when starting, and it is this factor that has inspired some into building saws with very relaxed rake at the start if the saw plate. I dislike these variable rake saws, personally. There is technique needed to master with saws that have very low rake. They require the lightest of touches when starting. All dovetail saws benefit from a light hand when sawing. Once mastered, the LN is a wonderful saw with a fast, powerful cut. Certainly my preference.

For those starting out, I would always recommend the Veritas over the LN. For those with experience, the LN is preferred.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Dovetail saw smack down LV vs LN; 20 vs 14 tpi

#7

15 tpi vs 20 race

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


It took 6 seconds to make a rip cut the length of this dovetail in 7/16" poplar. I could not detect a difference in time between the LN 15 tpi saw and the LV 20 saw. However, it took much longer to make this cut to establish a dovetail in a drawer side. Much longer than 6 seconds was spent locating the saw for the start of the cut and ending the cut at the base line front and back. The result being that there was no significant difference in overall how fast I could cut dovetails in drawer sides with either saw. The fact that the LN saw was bouncy and hard to control cutting straight into ganged sides (7/8 to 1" total thickness) actually made the LN saw slower.

The conclusion I reached is that speed is not a significant factor in my saw preference. Control and smoothness of cutting was, and here the 20 tpi saw was a clear favorite.

Re: Dovetail saw smack down LV vs LN; 20 vs 14 tpi

#8

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Dovetail saw smack down LV vs LN; 20 vs 14 tpi

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Well done Bill,

I have several options for HC DT's, my LN, LV and Japanese saws... I sort of go with the one that feels right in the wood I'm using, no rational other than feel...works for my process..

You have to have at least 3 saws for DT's, right??

:-)

Take care, Jim

Re: Dovetail saw smack down LV vs LN; 20 vs 14 tpi

#9

Re: Dovetail saw smack down LV vs LN; 20 vs 14 tpi

Jesse Cloud

3 saws? Depends on how many different types of wood you work with, I think. I seem to need a couple more...;)

Re: Dovetail saw smack down LV vs LN; 20 vs 14 tpi

#10

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Dovetail saw smack down LV vs LN; 20 vs 14 tpi

Jim in Burlington

I bet you you find them pretty quickly! LOL