Dovetail saw smack down LV vs LN; 20 vs 14 tpi
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Dovetail saw smack down LV vs LN; 20 vs 14 tpi
I have recently finished dovetailing 8 drawers, about 100 dovetails. In almost all cases the parts mated acceptable right off the saw with no corrective paring. During the process I switched randomly between 3 dovetail saws- Lie Neilsen 15 tpi rip, Lee Valley 14 tpi rip and Lee Valley 20 tpi rip.
Conditions- The drawer sides were poplar, sawing both sides together for a 7/8 to 1” total thickness. Fronts were cherry (half blind) and backs were poplar or cherry 7/16 or ½”. For reasons that will be revealed in a later post the sides were sawed with the saw nearly perpendicular to the length of the side (parallel to bench, directly into the end grain) while the drawer ends were sawed with the saw at various angles as the cut progressed.
Judgement criteria- Smoothness of cut is irrelevant in a dovetail cut and rough may be better than smooth. Tracking, the tendency of the saw to continue heading in the direction it starts is important. Speed of cut is not of great importance for drawer parts but could be for chests and cases that may have a lot of dovetails in thick parts. Smoothness is important for accurate starting the cut without bouncing and effort in continuing the cut.
Prejudices- I was not enamored with the looks of the LV saws when they came out but decided to give them a chance when I got to try one at IWF. I thought 20 tpi saws were for sissies and builders of doll house furniture.
Results- All saws tracked equivalent as far as I noticed. Surprisingly, I did not see significant, for the task at hand, difference in speed. Where they differed was in smoothness in starting and sawing, that is to say how “grabby” they were in the wood. The 20 tpi saw was like slicing bread with a bread knife. It cut smoothly and effortlessly. There was more resistance with the LV 14 tpi and I got an occasional bounce when sawing directly into the end grain. The LN saw differed greatly. It bounced when sawing directly into end grain on the ends of the ganged drawer sides. This feature made starting the saw imprecise and sawing was often not smooth as the teeth grabbed into the end grain. Dropping the handle so the saw was not sawing directly into the end grain lessened this annoyance, but this was not the way I preferred to saw the tails.
Ergonomics- In spite of the different looks I had no preference in the feel of the saw when holding it.
Conclusion- For what I was sawing and how I sawed it the LV 20 tpi saw was a clear favorite. It may or may not be for your work. However, these results suggest this saw should be a consideration for anyone making dovetail drawers.




