Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Question for Derek

Posts

Question for Derek

#1

Question for Derek

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Can we look forward to some pictures of the show entries? I enjoy seeing other's work. (keeps me humble)

Note the responses to the shop music discussion. That same personal preference will bias any judgment. Those striving to win will build for the judges. Those that build for themselves need to get lucky once they achieve a threshold of accomplishment (which you clearly have reached).

I have judged a few things and it was not a pleasant experience. I tried to get the group to agree at least on criteria and even that was not possible. Those that like to judge apparently like to apply their bias.

Re: Question for Derek

#2

Re: Question for Derek

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

Of course I plan to post pictures. I do so every year.

The issue of judging is relevant. I posted a response to a similar question on another forum, so I apologise for repeating myself here.

The question of criteria is very pertinent on a couple of levels. It is not simply about the competition, but the work we do for ourselves. It is my perception that there is a difference between work taken for competitions and clients, and work we do for ourselves or era-correctness. The former group demand a different level of perfection than the later group.

My standards are high-ish. I often say that I aim for perfection, but I do not expect it - which is really to mean that I will do the very best and accurate work I can, but I shall not be that fussy that I become frozen with anxiety at the thought of a mistake. Years ago I chose to publish my work warts and all because I thought that it would be a truer reflection of the process of a Weekend Warrior building furniture. I stutter and struggle through many tasks. I am not fluid as I would like. I make mistakes and correct them. I am getting quite good at correcting them!

By contrast, the standards set in a competition rule out any imperfections. A bit of tearout here-and-there, a little spelching, or a gap ... these are a definite no-no. Marks are taken away for such evidence. No matter the level of complexity, how original the design, or how difficult the construction, lesser pieces will win if they are flawless. My pieces are not flawless. They are made for home, not for critical clients or perfection-orientated judges. I believe that is a reason why a few years ago my Lingerie Chest did not win even a place, and third went to a simple, but well-make sofa table. Last year I won with a sofa table, which was not simple but it was near-perfectly executed.

The guys who tend to feature highly in our competitions are those that work with veneer. I believe there is an advantage: unseen joinery that does not need to be traditional, perfect alignments, and MDF/Ply substrates cut with machines.

I am not expecting a win (I have seen some of the other entrants - wow!). It will be a bonus to get a place. I am just happy to be out there among my peers.

Regards from Perth

Derek