Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Kitchen Table done (almost) and a question

Posts

Kitchen Table done (almost) and a question

#1

Kitchen Table done (almost) and a question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.



The top is round. The support is a cross. How to fasten top to cross?

One long arm of the cross could be installed parallel to the long grain of the top. It seems like it might look better this way. The screws might locate in the center top joint-probably not the best. But there would be no expansion/contraction issues with these screws. However, I would have to allow for ample changes along the other arm which would be perpendicular to the long grain.

Arms could be installed 45 degrees to the long grain. Surprisingly it looked ok in this orientation. All the screws would have expansion/contraction to deal with but it would be minimized by 45 degree orientation. Unsure if potential cupping of top would be better or worse restrained by this orientation.

No doubt someone in 1720 figured out empirically what worked best. But I have never looked under a round top to see what was done.

Opinions? BTW the cabinets in the back are ash and finished with the same product as the table. They darkened that much over time!

Re: Kitchen Table done (almost) and a question

#2

Re: Kitchen Table done (almost) and a question

William Duffield

In 1720, I don't think most of them had figured it out yet (or couldn't afford screws), and were still attaching tops with wooden pegs, and the tops eventually split.

I also like the looks of the diagonally oriented leg supports, but they don't provide as much support across the whole width of the table, and they increase the chance of cupping, and complicate the elongation of screw holes, which should be oriented across the grain. They would also complicate the installation of figure-8 fasteners if you decided to use them.

Intuitively, I think your top is strong enough that support all the way to the edges is probably not necessary. Also, I think your supports are wide enough to accommodate screw hole elongation at 45°.

Re: Kitchen Table done (almost) and a question

#3

Re: Kitchen Table done (almost) and a question

Barry Irby

I built a round table years ago and had two parallel arms across the grain with a block between them that could slide in and out. A screw through the block and the top was attached.

In your case I would use a "z" clips on both sides of the cross grain arm and let it slide.

I also think the arms mounted at a 45 and screwed in would work fine. The arms would flex.

Re: Kitchen Table done (almost) and a question

#4

A point I didn't consider, Decision made.

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"The arms would flex. " That factor determines the choice. I love it when mother nature provides an elegant solution.

Re: Kitchen Table done (almost) and a question

#5

Re: A point I didn't consider, Decision made.

Barry Irby

You could look up the expansion of ash with changes in MC across quarter sawn lumber and get some idea of the change knowing the changes in the RH inside your house. I am betting it's pretty small. For a little insurance, you could lay a straight edge across the to supports, mark the holes and elongate them a bit perpendicular to the grain at the top. That is, wallow the holes out. Wallow being an ancient but highly scientific woodworking term.

MC equilibrates at about 1/5 of RH.