Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Minwax Wipe On Poly

Posts

Minwax Wipe On Poly

#1

Alan Young

Minwax Wipe On Poly

Alan Young

I am in the finish process of my Dutch Pullout Table. I stained the entire piece with General Finishes Antique Walnut Stain.


I then started applying Minwax Wipe On Poly (Satin) to the Base section. I haven't applied any topcoat to the table top or extensions. I am really liking the look and feel so far of the WO Poly on the base. (No Pics to show) I have applied two coats so far to the base and plan on a third as per the directions:



Surface must be dry and free of old finishes in poor condition, wax, grease, polish, dirt or other foreign matter.

Sand to obtain a smooth, uniform surface. Remove all dust.

If desired, apply stain, such as Minwax® Wood Finish™ Stain, to unfinished interior wood surfaces. Follow directions for application instructions and dry times.

Shake Minwax® Wipe-On Poly container thoroughly before and during use to eliminate settling on the bottom of the can.

Apply a liberal amount of Wipe-On Poly to a clean, soft, lint-free cloth and rub it into the wood.

Let dry 2-3 hours. Then lightly sand entire surface with fine sandpaper (220 grit) to ensure an even finish and proper adhesion. Remove all dust.

Apply a second coat. If a third coat is desired, repeat step 6 before application.

After final coat, allow 24 hours before light use.


But I am wondering how many coats of this I should plan on applying to the top and the extension ie: the eating/working portions of the table. Or should I use a different version for the Top-Something that isn't as "thin"

Re: Minwax Wipe On Poly

#2

Re: Minwax Wipe On Poly

Dick Coers

I'd suggest at least 6 coats on the table top, but that depends on how thick you put it on. The traditional quick dry poly is thinner than it used to be, three coats of that do really nicely.

Re: Minwax Wipe On Poly

#3

Re: Minwax Wipe On Poly

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Someone in our club uses this material for his products. He uses 5 coats with light sanding in between. . I have experimented with spraying it on and that takes fewer coats. I like the appearance of it on case goods. Looks like a good old fashioned varnish. However, for a table top I use a urethane floor finish for durability. I think the floor finish cures harder. The General finishes wipe on got a slightly better review in a FW Article.

Re: Minwax Wipe On Poly

#4

Re: Minwax Wipe On Poly

David Yoho

I'm a General Finishes Arm-R-Seal user these days. But I'm in agreement with the use of poly for the table. That said, I am not a fan of multiple coats of any satin topcoat because, to me, it tends to have that "plastic" look. Instead, whenever the final look needs to be satin, I start with coats of gloss and finish the last coat or two with the satin. Just looks better.

Re: Minwax Wipe On Poly

#5

Alan Young

Mix and matching your responses

Alan Young

1 OK- Seems like moving away from wipe on poly for the top will reduce labor time.

2.I have used the General Finishes Oil-Urethane-I used it on this side board



BUT! I brushed it on and left each coat to dry with out wiping off. (Sanded lightly between Coats)

Is the General Finishes Oil-urethane "thinner" than say the Quick Dry Poly by Minwax mention by Dick? Is it more/less durable?

I Have Gloss General Finishes Oil-urethane so could proceeded with that as per David's experience.

Re: Minwax Wipe On Poly

#6

Re: Mix and matching your responses

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I always thin urethane varnish. It is formulated to met EPA volatiles not adequate leveling.

The urethanes vary in durability and hardness. After all, "urethane" tells us how the ingredients are hooked together (bonded) not WHAT is hooked together. Test cured varnish with a thumb nail. If you can't dent it with thumbnail it is hard and will make a durable top coat.

Re: Minwax Wipe On Poly

#7

Re: Minwax Wipe On Poly

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Thinning the Minwax poly is probably a good idea. The first coat dries well. Then I found that subsequent coats took longer to harden. (depending on temp/humidity etc) If the previous coat isn't cured enough the next application might streak.

With Minwax poly, I often reach for the furthest back can on the shelf. As stores rotate stock, the new stuff tends to be in the back. But check the dates. Poly that has been on the shelf too long is no fun at all.

T.

Re: Minwax Wipe On Poly

#8

Re: Minwax Wipe On Poly

Don Stephan

There would not seem to be a correlation between how thick the finish build is, and how hard the surface of it is.

A thicker build might be an advantage if it were going to be worn down over time. On the other hand, a professional finisher/refinisher with decades of experience suggested that today's thick factory finishes are more prone to chipping because they are so thick. Some people feel a thicker finish is higher quality, others feel a thick finish feels "plasticy" and detracts from the enjoyment of the wood.

Re: Minwax Wipe On Poly

#9

Re: Minwax Wipe On Poly

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I’ve used three coats, and it seemed liked the finish didn’t last particularly well. I’ve not tried five.

Re: Minwax Wipe On Poly

#10

Re: Mix and matching your responses

David Yoho

I don't know the answer to the GF product being thinner than the Minwax. Actually I don't care for one reason and that is I can wipe on either and have them look great.

I just bought a can of the Gloss Arm-R-Seal yesterday for a quick project for a neighbor. This finish will be clear gloss to match his other cabinetry. I always start out by applying the first coat to raw wood with a foam brush. I give it a little time to soak in before wiping away the excess. From there I wipe on successive coats until done.

Although wiping yields thinner coats requiring more applications, I think it looks better in the end.

Re: Minwax Wipe On Poly

#11

Ellis Walentine

Couple things

Ellis Walentine

I echo David's advice for satin finishes: Build all your preliminary coats with gloss, then use the Satin for the final coat only. Each successive coat of satin only obscures the grain more.

I don't know how the finish hardness of Wipe-On Poly compares to Arm-R-Seal or floor varnish, but I suspect all are adequate and suitable for table tops, as would be other varnishes. It's the combination of thickness and hardness that counts.

To me, wipe-on finishes should be just that -- wipe-ON finishes. Wiping them off is just a waste of finish. (This is my biggest gripe with "Danish Oil" finishes: you're buying thinned product then throwing three quarters of it out with your wiping rags.) When my objective is to build a thicker film, as for tabletops, I generally don't wipe the finish on; I apply it with a foam brush because it lays down a thicker millage, and I'm more interested in getting to the desired thickness than worrying about dust.

FWIW, I've used Minwax Spar Urethane with excellent results on countertops, which get a lot of abrasion, so I wouldn't hesitate to recommend it for this tabletop. I brush on two thin coats of gloss, then lightly sand back any dust nibs with nothing coarser than 320-grit Dri-Lube or other stearated paper, so you don't sand down into your stain layer. Tack it off with a tack rag, then apply another coat of gloss. Sand very lightly with 400 grit, tack rag the surface again, and apply your final coat -- this time with the finish sheen you're looking for, e.g., Satin, Flat or more Gloss, if that's what your're after. Works for me. You can probably get similar results with other brands with similar characteristics of composition and viscosity.

Parenthetically, there are many, many formulations of varnishes out there, with many combinations of resins -- phenolic, urethane and others -- and different handling, application and performance characteristics. Every finish and application method has its dedicated followers and advocates. It's all about finding the combination -- primarily function, application method, cost, and appearance -- that works best for you, and for the job at hand.

If you had started with water-based stain, I would have recommended another General Finishes product, their water-based Enduro-Var Urethane. I think it has some advantages over oil based products: It dries very quickly, it sands nicely, you can recoat in an hour, and it levels out beautifully. I apply it over a coat or two of thin shellac, sanded back to minimize grain raising with the Enduro Var.

Ellis

Re: Minwax Wipe On Poly

#12

Re: Minwax Wipe On Poly

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

A few years ago Michael Dresdner was quite active on this site, In my opinion he is one of the top experts on finishing in the world.

When the question of "Minwax Wipe on finish" was discussed as I recall, he recommended buying the standard Minwax Poly and thinning it to the desired consistency. He stated the regular Minwax was exactly the same formulation as the wipe on except for the amount of solvents and the price of the poly was far higher than adding solvent yourself!

I have done this and have thinned to wipe on consistency and also sprayed a thinned version, both methods worked well for me. As Bill Tindall has stated (and Michael D. agreed) all of the current solvent based finishes are mixed and sold too thick to meet the EPA standards. So thinning is required regardless of which you use.

I also agree with using standard finish material for all the coats except using satin finish for the final coat. I do this with Lacquer and poly.

Re: Minwax Wipe On Poly

#13

Re: Minwax Wipe On Poly

Thomas Starbuck Stockton

I do something similar to what Larry does. I put on two or three coats using regular thinned poly (I use naptha), I don't sand between the coats until I have at least two on unless the coat is really rough.

I then use the wipe on poly for the final two , usually gloss it dulls down pretty well with steel wool. I find that the wipe on goes on a lot better than thinned poly from the can , less streaking more even finish just easier to use.

Three to four coats this way gives good protection and using the poly from a can builds the finish quicker

Tom

Re: Minwax Wipe On Poly

#14

Not what I remember his teaching

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

My recollection of his teaching is that if you desire a wipe on it is best to buy a varnish formulated from resins that enable it to perform "wipe on". While I have never analyzed the stuff I think wipe on varnish achieves its wiping properties not by thinning but by formulating with lower molecular weight, and hence lower viscosity, resins.

Re: Minwax Wipe On Poly

#15

Alan Young

can I Mix and Match???

Alan Young

I discovered I had a can of Unopened McCloskey Man-O-war Spar varnish in Gloss. So I have proceeded by using this. So far two coats thinned with mineral spirits applied with foam brush-Tonight I'll apply a third- then probably buff back to satin-UNLESS??? I can use the Minwax Satin Wipe on Poly for the last coat???

Re: Minwax Wipe On Poly

#16

Be Wary

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It is not nice to do chemistry experiments on the finished product.

It may be presumptuous to assume that "spar varnish" today has any resemblance to its original properties. But if.....spar varnish was formulated to be flexible and suitable for outdoor exposure (like on spars!). This property was achieved by ratioing the hard resin component of varnish to the soft oil component to achieve a softer flexible result(plus UV stabilizers). Just what you want for a picnic table outside. Maybe not what you want for an indoor fine furniture table.

What is going to happen if the finish is composed of soft flexible layer bonded to a hard ridged layer I can't guess. But I would not want to do the experiment to see what happened.

Re: Minwax Wipe On Poly

#17

can you spray?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If so, you should be using conversion varnish for this kind of product. Start to finish done in half a day with less than an hour of labor.

Re: Minwax Wipe On Poly

#18

Alan Young

-Hard finish over a Flexible finish.

Alan Young

That was my concern I have way too much into this project to experiment! I will buff the gloss back when time comes..

Re: Minwax Wipe On Poly

#19

Alan Young

Not for another 3 months at least

Alan Young

I have sprayed smaller pieces in my basement shop. But becasue of it's size this would need to go to the unheated out building-and that won't be warm enough till Spring.

Re: Minwax Wipe On Poly

#20

winter spraying

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Probably not a solution for this difficult to move monster but I spray all year outside, even below freezing. Success depends on getting the object warm and the finish warm. Warm finish atomizes normally. The heat capacity of the object will flash the solvent. The problem to solve is how to get the object warm, then move outside, then move inside to complete cure.

My van on a sunny day becomes a greenhouse for curing anything that fits. I sprayed a table yesterday, a chest of drawers a month earlier. The chest of drawers was on a dolly which I rolled in and out of the front hall to warm and cure.

Re: Minwax Wipe On Poly

#21

Van spray booth!

Dick Coers

I also joked about having a school bus solar kiln. Park is over by the mall and bicycle over in the afternoon and move it to a better orientation spot. Now with the increasing numbers of failing stores, parking is certainly not an issue!

Re: Minwax Wipe On Poly

#22

Re: Not what I remember his teaching

Don Stephan

Can't recall ever seeing any discussion about resin molecules in regular and wiping varnish. I thin P&L 38 alkyd varnish 50-50 with a good quality mineral spirits and have been very satisfied for five or six years now. Recently I started keeping the varnish in a Stop Loss bag to see if it will prevent jelling in the can. The wiping varnish I mix in a quart paint can, and it jells in 3-4 days.