Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

I'm Coming Unhinged!

Posts

I'm Coming Unhinged!

#1

I'm Coming Unhinged!

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I can always count on good questions from my friend Mr. Tindall when I post new work. One of the questions was about the hinges I used for the cabinet I posted last week. The quick answer is that I used Blum 110 degree soft close hinges.

But there was a time in my past where I would shudder to think of using such barbaric contraptions on fine furniture. So here is my hinge journey:

I am a self taught woodworker. But when I started out I started by designing very traditional style furniture. I used butt hinged, H hinges etc. as they were appropriate to the style and designs. But once I transitioned to studio art furniture I felt that butt hinges were distracting and so I changed to more concealed hinges.

I generally used either knife hinges or SOSS hinges. I generally liked the SOSS hinges until over time I started having problems with them. One downside of SOSS is that they are not adjustable. But the worst problem is that I had multiple failures with them. The hinging elements would either get bent or just flat out break. So I stopped using them.

What I hoped for was a discreet adjustable hinge. The problem is that there is no such animal. I stewed about it for quite a while and decided to poll my galleries to see what they thought. Much to my surprise they said they had no problem with euro styled hinges. They said that the customers didn't really care about the looks of the hinges as much as function. Another comment from the galleries was that if the doors needed any adjustment while in the gallery, they could simply do that themselves.

So here I had been worried for nothing. And I have found that for larger doors, patrons actually are impressed by the soft close feature. I am an artist and I hold myself to high standards. But I am also a businessman and if the euro hinges work, then I'm on board.

That said, of course the euro hinges do not work for all things. Small doors etc. are the exceptions where other hinge forms are needed.

Of course if anyone knows of a concealed hinge that is reliable and adjustable, I'm all ears! :-) T.

Re: I'm Coming Unhinged!

#2

Re: I'm Coming Unhinged!

Keith Newton

Good to hear Thomas. I'm pretty much in the same boat as you. I started using Euro hinges back in the mid eighties, and have been pretty happy with them, and very few failures. However Ive always used some of the better brands and stayed away from the cheaper stuff, and was very happy to leave face-frame behind.

Most of the problems I see are where most shops don't want to give up their face frames, which becomes a problem for the mounting plates. Just last week, I replaced all the hinges and drawer slides for some very good friends whole kitchen. They were done with the big box store stuff, and judging from the number of screw holes in the face frames, had been changed a few other times. Those cabinets were a mess. All the doors were barely hanging on. I normally wouldn't take a Job like this, except for them being such good friends, and I have always learned a lot from not just my own mistakes but seeing how others have failed.

I did use Blum soft close, which they liked, but had to stick with the same holes for the door cup, which were too close together because they had gone with the pullout shelves behind wide pairs of doors, and of course if the bottom hinge had been down near the bottom of the door where it should have been, the hinge would have been in the way of the drawer slide on the pull out shelf.

These hinges were designed to mount with screws 1.5" back in the side of the cabinet, not up on the 3/4" edge of a face frame.

Re: I'm Coming Unhinged!

#3

Re: I'm Coming Unhinged!

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Good points Keith. With me, a lot of my doors end up being solid wood panels. I do occasionally make rail and style doors. But with solid wood, expansion and contraction can be an issue. That is where adjustability can really help.

To be truthful, if someone were to criticize the use of euro hinges on furniture I'm not sure I would argue with them. They are not ideal in my view. But I do find them helpful for a number of applications. On the plus side, they are not externally visible. And knowing that my clients are generally not concerned then I feel somewhat better about their use.

T.

Re: I'm Coming Unhinged!

#4

Re: I'm Coming Unhinged!

Brian Holcombe

I sold furniture for a living for 7-8 years, in the consumer market it would be considered very high end furniture.

Pretty much all of the cabinetry, except that which was made in Denmark, had European type hinges and drawer slides.

I can't stand the stuff on furniture, personally, but I do see the appeal from the customer's perspective.

I prefer regular hinges and some type of catch for furniture.

Re: I'm Coming Unhinged!

#5

Re: I'm Coming Unhinged!

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I think for your work especially, traditional hinges are important. Traditional design and craftsmanship is your hallmark. It makes sense to me that you would not want to deviate with the hinges.

T.

Re: I'm Coming Unhinged!

#6

I feel the same way about drawer runners....

Barry Irby

I have always used drawers without mechanical runners in my furniture, but am being pushed toward soft close runners, particularly the under-mount ones. Some argue that antiques that are 200 years old did not use such modern contraptions, but OTOH they did not have them to use.

I am about to build a chest of drawers for my son and he wants under-mount soft close runners. What to do, what to do???

I just got about a hundred euro style hinges at a freight auction. I am good to go.

Re: I'm Coming Unhinged!

#7

That explains it

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have been puzzled that I almost never see a butt hinge in the Grove Park Inn Gallery, even when this style would make sense. The customer gets to choose and they probably like what they have in the kitchen. I don't like seeing all that hardware when I open a door, but I am not the customer.

Anyway, thanks for the discussion.

Re: I'm Coming Unhinged!

#8

Re: I'm Coming Unhinged!

Paul in NJ

I have used European hinges on several sets of frame-less kitchen and utility cabinets. I like the flexibility of adjustment they provide. One drawback is the cabinet side of the hinge is only supported by the screws. I have had screws loosen and the doors sag. Over the course of time and after a few tightenings, the holes wear out and need a little more attention to fix. This has happened on cabinets made with MDO and plywood. It might not be a problem with hardwoods. When I use them now, I add a little epoxy to the screw hole to keep them tight.

Paul Dzioba

Re: I'm Coming Unhinged!

#9

Re: I'm Coming Unhinged!

Keith Newton

Paul, Maybe you didn't use as large a screw as you could have, but one thing I've found that works pretty well, is to use the thin / fast CA in the holes. It really soaks into damaged torn fibers especially well in MDF, forming a solid plastic plug that will need a new pilot hole for the next screw. Otherwise, since I use the same line of 5mm holes for the adjustable shelves to mount the plates, I buy the mounting plates with those big fat screws already mounted in them. If you replace your mounting plates with these, I'm sure you won't have any problems, unless you have too large a door with too few hinges.

Just so you know, a 3/16" drill is close enough if you don't have a 5mm drill.

Re: I'm Coming Unhinged!

#10

Re: I'm Coming Unhinged!

Paul in NJ

I guess that happens when you don't buy the premium hinges. Mine came with at most a #8 size screw.

Re: I'm Coming Unhinged!

#11

Re: I'm Coming Unhinged!

Barry Irby

Many I buy now come with the plastic inserts already on the screws. You drill a larger hole (10mm?) and press the plugs into the holes. Sometimes I use the plugs and sometimes I remove them and just use the screws.