Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Chair design/maker question?

Posts

Chair design/maker question?

#1

Chair design/maker question?

Barry Irby

Why does it seem most wooden chairs and bar stools rely on rungs/stretchers at about 90* to the legs for strength?

Why don't they have angle braces built in? It seems the use of triangles would make them stronger.

Is it that the flex inherent in the 90* frame is more comfortable? Are the joints less likely to have the parts extracted?

I know the rung in socket method is time honored and I know how to make them, but why?

Re: Chair design/maker question?

#2

Re: Chair design/maker question?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I haven’t seen many, but Thomas Moser designed a modern version of a continuous arm Windsor that has braces in lieu of stretchers. It works pretty well but flexes a bit.


Re: Chair design/maker question?

#3

Fulcrum Points

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

The closer the point of reinforcement is to the joint, the greater advantage for flex is given to the longer non-reinforced portion of the leg and the more torsional stress is put on the joint. Stretchers below the mid-points in the legs make the wood chair much stronger on the front-to-back axis.

Re: Chair design/maker question?

#4

Jeff Miller's book has excellent info

Howard in Toronto

Hi Barry

If you're new to building chairs, I'd recommend Jeff Miller's book. I took it out from the library so many times I just broke down and bought it a few years ago. Worth every penny.

Howard

Re: Chair design/maker question?

#5

I was trying to "Engineer" chairs

Barry Irby

Triangles are rigid structures. They don't change shape without the material deforming or the joints failing.

So, what I was questioning was why not use triangles in the design? Would a chair that rigid be less comfortable? Would they break rather than flexing? Would they be harder to build?

To me this is almost a philosophical question. Why has chair design emerged based on rectangles and trapezoids rather than triangles?

Clearly "chairs" are successful. I am considering building a few, Not sure why I think I can or need to improve on them. Just wondering.

Re: Chair design/maker question?

#6

Re: I was trying to "Engineer" chairs

Dick Coers

Moving point loads makes the engineering difficult. You slide fore and aft in a chair. If assisted into the sitting position by a gentlemen pushing on the back, you add a completely different load. Then the dreaded tilting back on the back legs! But the real purpose is just to withstand vertical load.

Our biggest concern now with chairs in our home, is scooting them on hardwood floors. My wife's knees and hips are really deteriorating. She can't take any weight off the chair while moving it. We'll be looking at casters really soon!

Re: Chair design/maker question?

#7

Re: Chair design/maker question?

Yonak

I'm thinking the designers rely on the angle of the legs for rigidity. The stretchers only keep the bottoms of the legs in the proper proximity. After all, you have to have a horizontal place to hike your feet on.

Of course, there are lots of chairs, especially more formal chairs that have straight legs. For these chairs the backs are normally extensions of the legs, and vice versa, which allow more attachment area to the seat. Also, these kind of chairs normally have extra bracing, often metal braces, under the seat.

It kind of reminds me of a question I asked my contractor when we had our house built, before the time when angled braces were incorporated into walls, "If all the members are either vertical or horizontal, what keeps the house from collapsing during a strong wind ?" The answer was the integrity of the entire structure teams up to hold everything together. No component, on its own could do it but, when it all works together, it's strong. Maybe this lends an answer to the vertical chair leg conundrum. All the braces, all the stretchers work in concert to maintain the integrity of the chair.

Perhaps the reason Stickley puts a series of vertical pieces on the sides is to help the strength from the, aforementioned, rocking back on the back legs. I feel certainly so.

Re: Chair design/maker question?

#8

Re: I was trying to "Engineer" chairs

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Barry, Dick makes some good points, above.

Over the past few weeks I built a prototype stool for the kitchen. This was a whole new world of learning for me. Not only was it necessary to carve a comfortable seat, or design aesthetic-looking legs, but calculating the number of legs (3 vs 4), their resultant angles (combination of splay and rake), and THEN how to brace them ...

Bracing could have been separate stretchers to each leg, as in this Estherick stool (I like very much) ...


... which made sense to me on an intuitive level since it triangulated the legs.

I went with a different design in the prototype.


I thought that this would be slimmer (I don't anymore), but had initial reservations since the rear leg did not receive support from the sides (as in the first design). Then it dawned on me that the force vector on the rear leg is straight back, not to the sides, since that is its angle. The T-stretcher simply prevents it stretching further than it should, and in turn prevents the front legs doing the same. The front cross stretcher prevents the legs splaying further. It is the combination that strengthens the legs. In practice, it is as steady as a rock.

(My wife did not like this prototype).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chair design/maker question?

#9

Re: Chair design/maker question?

Sgian Dubh

If you think about it Barry, a rectangle (or square) effectively creates four corner to corner triangles and four triangles that intersect at the rectangle's (or square's) centre point. True, the strength of a rectangle or square relies on a combination of the material's dimensions and the quality of the joinery in whatever material is used, but the construction is what's commonly described as triangulated.

In the case of actual triangular frames, there's always the conundrum of how to make them. Each side is only together in the right place when they're assembled, but how do you bring them together with an effective joint? In many cases the only way to get the assembly together is to make the joints sloppy so that the parts can be brought together. Loose or slip tenons are another option, but these are more akin to a bridle joint than the inherently stronger mortice and tenon joint. Then you could simply align the three parts in their allotted place and drive dowels in to hold the joint together.

There's more, but this response is just a quick snapshot of my first thoughts on the subject. Slainte.

Re: Chair design/maker question?

#10

Re: I was trying to "Engineer" chairs

Brian Holcombe

Some chairs do include struts that effectively make a triangle. Others use s combination of effects to make one. The back of a Windsor chair is a triangle when viewed from the side, for instance.

As another poster pointed out, triangles are awkward to build, compared to simply adding a stretcher.

Re: Chair design/maker question?

#11

Re: Chair design/maker question?

Philip Duffy

It seems to me that a fundamental characteristic of Windsor chairs is the flex that comes from the thin but very coherent parts working together to provide comfort to the client sitting. Strength in the legs can be achieved in many ways but the chair has to be survivable over time. - -my 2cents Philip

Re: Chair design/maker question?

#12

Re: I was trying to "Engineer" chairs

Joseph Mulherin

Barry, regarding the chair legs and bottom rails......look at the design Sam Maloof did and Hal Taylor did for the rigidity using 1/8" slats glued together in a form to weld the boards into a rocking curve for the chairs.

Look at: www.rockingchairuniversity.org to see Hal's chairs.

These are the ones I will be making for my relatives later this year.

Re: Chair design/maker question?

#13

Thanks for the thoughtful responses....

Barry Irby

I have been out of town for four days taking care of a friend who had back surgery. That went well, but I am glad to be home again.

I am still milling over the chair options and it may never happen.

Thank's again.

Re: Chair design/maker question?

#14

JL

Re: Chair design/maker question?

JL

Drew Langsner has an excellent book.

"The Chairmaker's Workshop: ..."

If you can find (or buy) a copy, it is well worth the read.

Re: Chair design/maker question?

#15

Re: Chair design/maker question?

Mark Hennebury

Triangles are the bases for structural rigidity.

Besides the obvious ones, there are many hidden triangles in most all construction.

As has been stated mortise and tenons rely on triangles for structural stability.

Curved backs offset the pivot point forming a triangle dramatically increasing the strength by redirecting the forces to make use of the materials best properties. introducing triangles, curves, compound curves, into structural design is all about redirecting the force to make the most of the materials properties.

Experiment, tinker, play, learn. push to find the limits; Failures teach you a lot.







Re: Chair design/maker question?

#16

Did you make those?

Barry Irby

Either way, that's quite a selection. I like the first one and....

One thing I was thinking about was making stacking chairs. And perhaps something minimalist. My son is in the military and will be moving around for a while. Minimalist and extremely sturdy don't seem to be a natural combination.

I also liked the dining chairs that had the extremely tall backs (Mc....?) that "enclosed" the table and confined the conversation. But that's an opposite.

Re: Chair design/maker question?

#17

Re: Did you make those?

Mark Hennebury

I made the ones in the previous photos and below. i also made many more regular chairs. and a bunch of Maloof-ish rockers and Nakashima variations.

Chairs give you endless room for experimentation and learning. There are so many things that you can do with chairs, stacking chairs are no exception, i had played around with a few prototypes many years ago. Chairs are easy to do rough mock-ups of to see if they will work also.

The first photo is part of a dining room set that i made and was delivering.




Macintosh made the tall chairs to which you refer.

Re: Chair design/maker question?

#18

Re: Did you make those?

Barry Irby

Mark, that is some interesting and fabulous work. One picture even reminded me I used to wear bell bottoms. Some of the chairs are very minimalist. The first one really got me to thinking about a sculpted seat that is an "exploded" view of strips. Wondering what the spacing would be to keep it comfortable. You are lucky or forsited to have the pictures. I failed to take many and now some of my work is only available in my mind. Thanks for taking the time to post. Lots to think about.

Re: Chair design/maker question?

#19

Re: Did you make those?

Mark Hennebury

Hi Barry,

Chairs give you an immense about of freedom to experiment with design. I would have a lot of fun if i were to get back to making furniture today, maybe i will sometime soon. Cantilevered seats are incredible strong, laminated curves can give beautiful flowing lines, lots to imagine. The demands of comfort and support are easy to meet, the rest is up to your imagination. Have some fun and see what you can come up with.

I wish that i had taken more and far better photos, lots of projects never got photographed, most of the times my jobs were way behind schedule when i was finishing them, so didn't have much time to set up any decent photo shoots, as in the dining set that was on the lawn, we managed to get a few photos as i was delivering it, and i was installing the cabinet. Unfortunately i have way more embarrassing photos of me in bell bottoms than i would like. Good times all the same. Still have a few old LP's and turntable set up in my workshop.

Thanks for the nice comments and i look forward to seeing what you came up with.