Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

OT - HVAC system problems.

Posts

OT - HVAC system problems.

#1

JL

OT - HVAC system problems.

JL

Noticed water in the pan of my furnace/HVAC system starting this season.

Opened the unit and found water seeping from a plastic "box" below the furnace - not much - but on a cold winter day, the condensate builds up.

The service tech checked it out and said that a gasket would have to be replaced.

He brought a replacement gasket and plastic part and started trying to disassemble it - without success.

To make a long story short, the heat exchanger unit would have to be replaced due to the nature of this model. It is a "warranty" repair - no cost for the unit, just the service tech time.

Now the conundrum. He reassembled and checked out the system. It worked. However, since he reassembled it, there has been no leakage of condensate. As far as Amana is concerned, the heat exchanger is still "bad".

Should I let him replace it or not?

Re: OT - HVAC system problems.

#2

A free, new heat exchanger? Why not!

Dick Coers

All units fail sometime in their life. Why not take advantage of a replacement part that will extend the overall life of the furnace? Just have him wait till a less severe cold day.

Re: OT - HVAC system problems.

#3

Re: OT - HVAC system problems.

ken combs

IME those types of warranty repairs cover parts only, labor to be paid by owner. So, I would be getting a firm quote for the labor and make my decision based on that.

Re: OT - HVAC system problems.

#4

Danger???

Bill Howatt

Bad, as in leaking, heat exchangers are a major source of letting CO into your house. If this is an issue then the answer is obvious.

When I was getting a new gas furnace I was told the heat exchanger had something like a 15-20 yr warranty. I asked if that really meant much because it might be better to just replace the furnace at that age. I was told it well could be since changing the exchanger was a pretty labor intensive job. In other words, find out what it will cost even if the parts are under warranty. With what you might get with a new furnace warranty it may not be worth fixing the old one. Apparently after 7 years furnaces tend to have more maintenance issues but take that with a grain of salt!!!

Bill

Re: OT - HVAC system problems.

#5

JL

Sounds like I should change it...

JL

The cost would be on the order of $500.

Re: OT - HVAC system problems.

#6

Re: OT - HVAC system problems.

Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)

Are you sure it isn't the combustion blower that is leaking water. Otherwise known as the inducer. Had 2 replaced on my furnace over the years. Symptoms are they leak condensate water and in my case it remained on the surface of a pan. If it builds up enough, it will begin to drip down to the lower part of the furnace and appear to be coming from elsewhere.

Replace inducer assembly aka. combustion blower and problem solved.

these are the motor assemblies with a squirrel cage housing that draws condensate out of the heat exchanger and routes it through a series of channels to the black box you are referring to and out through a drain hose.

If it is the combustion blower, it is a 20 minute fix to replace the assembly. My service plan covered this easily. the combustion blowers are often universal between manufacturers.

Also check that the black box is not blocked and/or drain hose is not plugged up.

Norman

Re: OT - HVAC system problems.

#7

Re: OT - HVAC system problems.

Keith Newton

Are you burning natural gas, or propane? Isn't water a byproduct of burning propane?

Re: OT - HVAC system problems.

#8

Re: OT - HVAC system problems.

Don Stephan

It just so happens . . . had to call my HVAC expert yesterday for our high efficiency gas furnace. As he explained, when a high efficiency furnace strips extra heat from the exhaust water condensate is produced in the burn chamber. A rubber hose directs the water to a plastic collection box or trap, and another hose directs the overflow from the trap to the drain line. A second hose from this trap is used as a sensor to turn off the furnace if the trap is not draining. He explained that over time dirt accumulates in the trap (and probably mold grows) and the trap does not drain as it should. With a portable vacuum he cleaned the two drain hoses and the trap now all well.

We did not have water at the base of the furnace.

Re: OT - HVAC system problems.

#9

Re: OT - combustion forms water

Henry (Raleigh NC)

Water is a (by)product of the combustion of organic material - regardless of the fuel.

Combustion reaction:

CxHyOz + O2 --> CO2 + H2O

generalized organic molecule + air --> carbon dioxide and water

I'm neglecting coefficients so reaction is not mass balanced

Henry

Re: OT - HVAC system problems.

#10

Re: OT - combustion forms water

Bill Howatt

If you have a higher efficiency condensing furnace the combustion products go through a second heat-exchanger where more heat is extracted from the flue gas. So the "steam" gets condensed rather than just going up a the chimney. This resulting water condensate is what gets directed out of the furnace via the condensate trap. The now cooler flue gas can just be piped outside via the plastic pipe.

Bill